COI = Conflict Of Interest M&G = Meet and Greet
Non Profit Organization involved is SBFII Susan Boyle Fans International
Director of the Board : Pickled Tink
Board Members : GritsT, sunandroses, John V, Lonnirose, truusbuist, wasforgas
Non Profit Organization involved is SBFII Susan Boyle Fans International
Director of the Board : Pickled Tink
Board Members : GritsT, sunandroses, John V, Lonnirose, truusbuist, wasforgas
Issue : A Meet & Greet was initiated by Sony 2-3 weeks ago. They contacted Board/Staff of the non profit to make arrangements quietly for a focus group meeting of about 20 members of the Susan Boyle fandom. The itinerary included lunch with Susan, footage was shot for an upcoming documentary, screening of 4 rough cuts of new material from Susan Boyle's 3rd CD, due Nov. 2011. The bulk of the arrangements were made by a Board Member. At least 2 Board Members and 1 Staff Member of the non profit attended and accepted gifts (hotel accommodations, meal, etc..) from the for profit corporate entity (ies). Some were hurt as the selection process favored this one forum over others in the fandom (again), and the disclosure of the M&G came from a tweet by an employee at the restaurant. Adding to the non-transparency, a list of attendees has not been made public and posts and threads with members expressing disappointment were deleted. Members that expressed any displeasure or criticism at how this incident was handled were dismissed as suffering from sour grapes at not being included, and the non profit Management excused themselves by stating that they were simply doing what Susan and her Management Team(s) wanted/asked of them. Most of the main discussion thread (pre-deletion) was saved and is available below for reference.
Posts are shown in Central European Summer Time (CEST) +0200 UTC
Meet And Greet 20th August 2011, Susan In New York.
Meet and Greet in New York, News On Susan In New York
Well, at last we can tell you what has been going on. We gave our word to Susan and to Andy that we would not say a word until now , and we are sure that you all understand that we could not break the trust which was placed in us.
As you know Susan has been in New York this week end. Knowing that Susan was going to be travelling to New York on business they decided that it would be a good opportunity to combine business with pleasure. They decided to arrange a meet and greet with some of of Susan’s fans and of course Susan was to be the guest of honour. Originally this was going to be a small group of 4/5 fans but about 2/3 weeks ago they decided to make it a much bigger occasion and go all out for a meet and greet with 20 or more fans. They don’t do things by halves do team Subo!
Now obviously some people will immediately want to know why this was not made public, why didn't everyonel know about it , why they were not invited, who decided who was going to go and how this all went down? That's a normal human reaction, and this is Susan we are talking about. We were not involved in deciding who went , and it is understood that team Subo have focused on folk whom Susan has never actually met. However Susan does like to have familiar faces present at these occasions so they contacted Grits T directly and asked that she and Randma would be involved. Andy Stephens suggested them because Susan knows, likes and gets on well with these ladies, and they were personally asked to attend and to liaise with the fans who would be attending and to organise the fun and games. Team Subo are in touch with fans from many places.
This event was set up at very short notice and we are amazed that Grits managed to pull it all together so quickly , so well done to her. She had about 24 hours in which to get every one organized and confirmed. Everyone then had to make their own travel arrangements. We understand that Team Subo provided hotel accommodation for all those attending and also the meal at the restaurant for the meet and greet. For some folk it was their first time in the big apple! We gather that it was all quite a mad scramble but that it all came together.
Grits enlisted some help from Janna55, (who unbeknown to us was going to be going along and like all of the attendees was sworn to secrecy), in organising the sequence of events and all of the ensuing fun. The fans all met at the St Andrews restaurant in New York, and they had exclusive use of two rooms for several hours. Fans with good memories may remember that in 2009 a large group of Susafans met there for an evening meal and that it is a well known Scottish themed restaurant in New York. There were several tables with ample room for all the Susan posters, Susan faces, and of course flat Susan was there as well. After the meal Susan went from table to table talking to all of the fans, also stopping for a wee chat with flat Susan along the way. As you might expect she made sure that everyone had the opportunity to talk to her. I am sure that many are looking forward to sharing their accounts of the occasion with you and relaying what Susan said to them. Susan was presented with some very special gifts and I am sure that, having contained the secret for what must seem like an eternity to them they will now all be bursting to tell you all about it. By all accounts Susan had an amazing time and so did those attending. They have till know been unable to share this with you at Susan and Andy's request, but they have now been given the green light to do so. We know that you will all want to share their joy with them and also Susan's joy as she so loves meeting with her fans; and to join together in celebrating the fact that so many were able to enjoy this wonderful and unique opportunity. Please be patient - they are currently on the way back to their hotel so we may have to wait a wee while for the first hand accounts..
RIK Thanks!
Lots to digest here...
Great! Waiting to hear accounts (and hopefully see pictures)
Thank you Pickled Tink for this exciting news for Susan and about 20 fans. Waiting to hear from the fans in attendance. Lovely news.
Awesome! :cool:
:thanks: PT, I am looking forward to hearing every tidbit and Congrats to those in attendance, :fantastic:
:popcorn:
Sure hope there's pictures - lots and lots of pictures!
Thanks, PT. Pictures and accounts should be forthcoming soon. Know all had a wonderful time.
RIK Full Disclosure Statement
"For The Record" I was asked via e-mail by GritsT to attend the M&G some weeks ago, was asked then to keep this confidential. I had to decline because of time contraints & economics. Congratulations to all those who did attend the event. Richard
I wish that some of the rest of us could be invited sometimes.
I had figured out that one of the fans was going, and when Susan said on FB that she was going to meet some wonderful people thought there might be a fan meet. I'm glad that everyone who was invited got to see Susan though.
Please invite me next time. (I'm not selfish, am I? LOL) I was left out of the quilt presentation and went to LA the time Susan didn't get to perform. Surely hope to meet her one day.
Please everybody who went, post pictures and tell us all about it.
Quote:
Originally Posted by cac1936
Thanks, PT. Pictures and accounts should be forthcoming soon. Know all had a wonderful time.
Great news. Glad they had a big group, so we'll have lots of reports. And big cheers to Grits, Randma and Janna for being able to get it all organized on short notice. Never a dull moment in Subo fandom (or at least not for very long).
Thanks PT and it’s already 11PM. I’m just wondering if I will be able to sleep. Great (and very hot) Sunday ahead! :smiley-bounce:
I hope someday be invited as well. Congrats to all. Its wonderful. Waiting for pictures.
wow, let's hear all about it you lucky fans
:popcorn::popcorn::popcorn:
Quote:
Originally Posted by jclar
I wish that some of the rest of us could be invited sometimes.
I had figured out that one of the fans was going, and when Susan said on FB that she was going to meet some wonderful people thought there might be a fan meet.
It is my understanding that with the exception of Grits T and Randma, who were specifically asked to attend for by Team Subo, not one single person attending has ever met Susan before. We understand that was a pre requisite of this event. I think we all wish that everyone could have been invited but I am sure that we also all realise that's just not possible. Team Subo has contact with fans who are not just members here and are free to invite whomsoever they wish. I think that we should just be happy for those that did get invited.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Retired In Kalifornia
"For The Record" I was asked via e-mail by GritsT to attend the M&G some weeks ago, was asked then to keep this confidential. I had to decline because of time contraints & economics. Congratulations to all those who did attend the event. Richard
So sorry RIK, that you could not make it to NY.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Pickled Tink
It is my understanding that with the exception of Grits T and Randma, who were specifically asked to attend for by Team Subo, not one single person attending has ever met Susan before. We understand that was a pre requisite of this event. I think we all wish that everyone could have been invited but I am sure that we also all realise that's just not possible. Team Subo has contact with fans who are not just members here and are free to invite whomsoever they wish. I think that we should just be happy for those that did get invited.
Absolutely.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Pickled Tink
It is my understanding that with the exception of Grits T and Randma, who were specifically asked to attend for by Team Subo, not one single person attending has ever met Susan before. We understand that was a pre requisite of this event. I think we all wish that everyone could have been invited but I am sure that we also all realise that's just not possible. Team Subo has contact with fans who are not just members here and are free to invite whomsoever they wish. I think that we should just be happy for those that did get invited.
Good grief, I would hope Team Subo would invite people from other fan sites to the M&Gs. We're all united in the same purpose. In fact, I had been a little worried that perhaps this site was getting all the attention, because it was the first and is still the largest. I shouldn't have worried. No flies on Team Subo.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Pickled Tink
It is my understanding that with the exception of Grits T and Randma, who were specifically asked to attend for by Team Subo, not one single person attending has ever met Susan before. We understand that was a pre requisite of this event. I think we all wish that everyone could have been invited but I am sure that we also all realise that's just not possible. Team Subo has contact with fans who are not just members here and are free to invite whomsoever they wish. I think that we should just be happy for those that did get invited.
That is just marvelous. Everybody who has never met Susan needs to. She is just such a joy. Congratulations to all who were there.:biggrin:
Quote:
Originally Posted by soothed
Makes me feel like a damn fool, but that's okay...not the first time.
Why on earth, would you feel like a damn fool, Soothed. Much as she loves us, Susan didn't fly to NY to just M&G with 20 fans. There's more to the story, which I'm sure will begin to unfold over the coming weeks. For openers, Susan had photogs with her in Tribeca. I'd be surprised if there weren't cameras at the M&G. Stay tuned.
Just had an update.
All of the fans got to spend time with Susan in the second room, they took it in turns adn everyone had some one on one time with her. She was wearing a purple blouse and slacks. She arrived at 1.00 and left at 3.45.
She will sing one of her new songs on AGT :)
And........ THE LUCKY fans were asked to give up their cell phones, cameras etc.... and then they heard a couple of her new songs.... and now actually I think I hate them all..... :( ..... they said WOW WOW WOW ......
I live in NYC (Manhattan) and met some wonderful fans from this site this summer at a Meet and Greet Lunch. I was so excited to hear that Susan is in the City and would have loved to be part of today's events.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Pickled Tink
It is my understanding that with the exception of Grits T and Randma, who were specifically asked to attend for by Team Subo, not one single person attending has ever met Susan before. We understand that was a pre requisite of this event. I think we all wish that everyone could have been invited but I am sure that we also all realise that's just not possible. Team Subo has contact with fans who are not just members here and are free to invite whomsoever they wish. I think that we should just be happy for those that did get invited.
It's wonderful that fans that haven't met Susan before were invited to meet her this time. I'm wondering how other people who haven't met Susan can let her team know that they would also love to meet her someday.
Quote:
Originally Posted by antique
It's wonderful that fans that haven't met Susan before were invited to meet her this time. I'm wondering how other people who haven't met Susan can let her team know that they would also love to meet her someday.
I am wondering that too.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Pickled Tink
Just had an update.
All of the fans got to spend time with Susan in the second room, they took it in turns adn everyone had some one on one time with her. She was wearing a purple blouse and slacks. She arrived at 1.00 and left at 3.45.
She will sing one of her new songs on AGT :)
And........ THE LUCKY fans were asked to give up their cell phones, cameras etc.... and then they heard a couple of her new songs.... and now actually I think I hate them all..... :( ..... they said WOW WOW WOW ......
PRIVATE CONCERT !!?!! AWESOME !! Good on them !! :clappinghands:
May I ask what the criteria was for attending this M&G?
Quote:
Originally Posted by Pickled Tink
Just had an update.
All of the fans got to spend time with Susan in the second room, they took it in turns adn everyone had some one on one time with her. She was wearing a purple blouse and slacks. She arrived at 1.00 and left at 3.45.
She will sing one of her new songs on AGT :)
And........ THE LUCKY fans were asked to give up their cell phones, cameras etc.... and then they heard a couple of her new songs.... and now actually I think I hate them all..... :( ..... they said WOW WOW WOW ......
WOW and WOW again PT. Everyone had a chance of a one to one with Susan? :shocked:
And do you mean she sangs two songs for the fans? Acapella? :happydancing::happydancing::happydancing:
:dance::smiley-bounce::dance::smiley-bounce::dance::smiley-bounce::dance::smiley-bounce::dance:
Quote:
Originally Posted by Pickled Tink
Just had an update.
All of the fans got to spend time with Susan in the second room, they took it in turns adn everyone had some one on one time with her. She was wearing a purple blouse and slacks. She arrived at 1.00 and left at 3.45.
She will sing one of her new songs on AGT :)
And........ THE LUCKY fans were asked to give up their cell phones, cameras etc.... and then they heard a couple of her new songs.... and now actually I think I hate them all..... :( ..... they said WOW WOW WOW ......
Heard a couple of new songs? Live or recorded? Wow, now I wonder how they can keep quiet about what they heard. Hard to keep all that under your hat for over 2 months.
I laughed PT when you said "and now actually I think I hate them all".
Joan M
Quote:
Originally Posted by Pickled Tink
Just had an update.
All of the fans got to spend time with Susan in the second room, they took it in turns adn everyone had some one on one time with her. She was wearing a purple blouse and slacks. She arrived at 1.00 and left at 3.45.
She will sing one of her new songs on AGT :)
And........ THE LUCKY fans were asked to give up their cell phones, cameras etc.... and then they heard a couple of her new songs.... and now actually I think I hate them all..... :( ..... they said WOW WOW WOW ......
Wonderful - but what is the date for AGT for sure :puzzled:
Quote:
Originally Posted by ZaSu
PRIVATE CONCERT !!?!! AWESOME !! Good on them !! :clappinghands:
I think I may know why it will be a while before we hear from them - on their way back to the hotel, they are probably walking on air!:laught2:
WOW WOW WOW is this NEWS , NEWS , NEWS !!!:pompom::dance::clap::smiley-bounce:
Its like being splashed with a bucket of ice cold water to wake one up out of slumber so they are fully on alert from this time forth.
Okay .....I now see this is going to be a VERY 24/7 round the clock thread in the next 48 hours .
YIPPEE!! TWEET THE DETAILS FOR SURE !!!
Quote:
Originally Posted by Pickled Tink
Just had an update.
All of the fans got to spend time with Susan in the second room, they took it in turns adn everyone had some one on one time with her. She was wearing a purple blouse and slacks. She arrived at 1.00 and left at 3.45.
She will sing one of her new songs on AGT :)
And........ THE LUCKY fans were asked to give up their cell phones, cameras etc.... and then they heard a couple of her new songs.... and now actually I think I hate them all..... :( ..... they said WOW WOW WOW ......
Holy Moly!!!! Wonder if the ones who were there can let us know what songs she sang??? I agree, PT, everyone there is now on my S list. LOL Just kidding, but am sure ready to get some news and pictures from the ones who were there.
what date for AGT? so I can tape
Quote:
Originally Posted by trennie
Why on earth, would you feel like a damn fool, Soothed. Much as she loves us, Susan didn't fly to NY to just M&G with 20 fans. There's more to the story, which I'm sure will begin to unfold over the coming weeks. For openers, Susan had photogs with her in Tribeca. I'd be surprised if there weren't cameras at the M&G. Stay tuned.
I hope everyone had a wonderful time. I don't feel left out. I just don't like secrecy. How much more exciting if we had known that she was meeting fans and stories and pictures were coming soon, instead of wondering. I just like to have a good time here, and sometimes I may act childish, but I am not a child. I can handle the truth.I meant what I said on the other thread in a post to Lisa. I truly believe Susan loves us all, all over the world. I am more upset with myself for being so gullible. I won't make that mistake again.
:yeewhooooo::fan_too_fast::beingfunny::bagpiper: I'm so excited I can't stand myself!
Hurry it up all you lucky people, we're waiting here with baited breath!!!!
Quote:
Originally Posted by bernicer
May I ask what the criteria was for attending this M&G?
As I pointed out this was not one of the forum meet and greets so we don't know. I would suggest that question is directed to Susan's management.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Pickled Tink
Just had an update.
All of the fans got to spend time with Susan in the second room, they took it in turns adn everyone had some one on one time with her. She was wearing a purple blouse and slacks. She arrived at 1.00 and left at 3.45.
She will sing one of her new songs on AGT :)
And........ THE LUCKY fans were asked to give up their cell phones, cameras etc.... and then they heard a couple of her new songs.... and now actually I think I hate them all..... :( ..... they said WOW WOW WOW ......
Boy, is that good news. Particularly the review. WOW WOW WOW
Quote:
Originally Posted by blessdalotbysusan
WOW WOW WOW is this NEWS , NEWS , NEWS !!!:pompom::dance::clap::smiley-bounce:
Its like being splashed with a bucket of ice cold water to wake one up out of slumber so they are fully on alert from this time forth.
Okay .....I now see this is going to be a VERY 24/7 round the clock thread in the next 48 hours .
YIPPEE!! TWEET THE DETAILS FOR SURE !!!
I hope those guys aren't taking time to eat or any of that kind of stuff.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Pickled Tink
As I pointed out this was not one of the forum meet and greets so we don't know. I would suggest that question is directed to Susan's management.
Thank you, will do.
I feel sorry for those living in New York and are great fans of Susan. They must be hurting "just a little."
I wish that her management could arrange a meet and greet that is not secret. There was a mention of scheduling one once, but it was in Las Vegas, and I think there was not enough interest although that is hard to imagine. Or course, her management does what they think is best for Susan, and her time in the US is valuable. Glad she got to do something fun.
Quote:
Originally Posted by soothed
I hope everyone had a wonderful time. I don't feel left out. I just don't like secrecy. How much more exciting if we had known that she was meeting fans and stories and pictures were coming soon, instead of wondering. I just like to have a good time here, and sometimes I may act childish, but I am not a child. I can handle the truth.I meant what I said on the other thread in a post to Lisa. I truly believe Susan loves us all, all over the world. I am more upset with myself for being so gullible. I won't make that mistake again.
Soothed, I don't understand why you say you were gullible? Because you didn't know this was going to happen? I don't think it was kept a secret in case we got too excited. But I seem to remember that it was explained some time ago when something similar had happened, that the reason for the secrecy was to ensure that the tabs and paps were kept out of the picture. As we know, we have people here who are on the lookout for any interesting news that might be passed on to the tabs as soon as they are aware of it. :smiley-rolleyes:
:Ilovesusan::susanrocks:big grinI don't know why people get so upset. I am thrilled that many fans who had not met Susan got the chance. It's possible that her management could plan more of these meetings. How many celebrities even entertain the idea of meeting with their fans. Susan has a lot of fans, and not everyone is going to be chosen. Frankly, I am glad we get updates from those who attend these functions. I would certainly keep it a secret. I wouldn't want party crashers arriving to ruin the event. Can't wait to hear updates from the lucky 20 fans.
Quote:
Originally Posted by JudyMcKinn
I would imagine if it was announced, the place would be swarmed with hundreds of fans, and they couldn't have done anything as planned. I can understand completely why it needed to be kept quiet. I strongly suspect that this will be part of the documentary they are working on--Susan having a meet and greet with some of her fans. Wonder if some came from around the world, or just those close by? I wonder a lot of things--will you guys get busy sending us your stories and pictures, please? LOL
this reasoning makes sense to me, Judy
Quote:
Originally Posted by Pickled Tink
As I pointed out this was not one of the forum meet and greets so we don't know. I would suggest that question is directed to Susan's management.
And how do we contact Susan's management?
Quote:
Originally Posted by skschulz43
:I don't know why people get so upset. I am thrilled that many fans who had not met Susan got the chance. ...I would certainly keep it a secret. I wouldn't want party crashers arriving to ruin the event. Can't wait to hear updates from the lucky 20 fans.
I completely agree. It was most considerate of them to include dedicated fans in their tight schedule and to make an effort to have folks that haven't met her their focus.
Well done!
I am so happy for those who met Susan today and that they actually were able to hear two of Susan’s songs. I cannot wait to hear from them. I guess I can say I met Susan, though Susan didn’t know it. I still remember the hug I got at JFK airport. I can actually still feel it, let alone visualize it. WOW WOW WOW. I cannot wait to hear Susan’s new MUSIC.
Whilst I understand that everyone wants to know how or why the people who attended got to go. Can I make the following points. This was not a forum meet and greet, there may be a lot of things we are not privy to and which they do not yet want us to know, they have their reasons, and we should respect them. So, maybe some of the comments and questions are perhaps not helpful. It is understandable that everyone wants to be there etc... .However, Susan has MILLIONS of fans and if there was a meet and greet every single day for the next ten years she could not meet them all. It's just not practicable. Yes of course everyone wants to meet her. Some of us have been very very lucky and we know that. Some have not been and I so wish that more folk had been. I also know that more folk will be in the future.
But can I ask you for for a few minutes to put yourselves in the shoes of those who have met Susan today. They have just had the time of their lives; they will be excited, over the moon, and just itching to share their news. They will come to the forum and what will they see? Posts which quite frankly seem a little resentful that some were chosen and they were not. How would you feel if that were you? There will always be someone who will be disappointed whatever criteria are used. But surely it is not too much to be happy that others got this opportunity and that they are willing to share it with you?
I am glad Susan takes the time to connect with her fans. I feel lucky just to be involved long distance. Isn't it wonderful that our Fan Site has wonderful ladies that Susan likes enough to want to see them again and again. That says a lot about those fans and our Fan site as a whole. I thank my lucky stars that I joined and feel apart of it all. You have to remember that they do it the best way possible for Susan not us.
Quote:
Originally Posted by antique
It's wonderful that fans that haven't met Susan before were invited to meet her this time. I'm wondering how other people who haven't met Susan can let her team know that they would also love to meet her someday.
I think there must be a few million who fit the category of wanting to meet Susan! :biggrin:
Quote:
Originally Posted by UKSusanfanAnn
Apart from not having met Susan before, what is the criteria for being invited, I know its impossible to ask everyone. I am sure if it was announced on this closed thread and people were told that it was confidential and only a small gathering that we are all grown up enough to keep it to ourselves but would still then be able to enjoy the aniticipation, :(
JMHO, it sure would be nice to feel included instead of excluded.
I'll say I'm shocked...to say the least. There are a lot of people right here on this Forum who have never met Susan. Am I delighted that there was a Meet and Greet (secret) in NY? No, not really. Not like this. Put myself in the shoes of people who attended? Can't bear to do it. Have I been negatively affected by this? Yes. There are fans, and then there are FANS.
Quote:
Originally Posted by bernicer
JMHO, it sure would be nice to feel included instead of excluded.
The Susan team are not doing themselves any favourites. They are alienating fans.
Quote:
Originally Posted by MollBobbers
Soothed, I don't understand why you say you were gullible? Because you didn't know this was going to happen? I don't think it was kept a secret in case we got too excited. But I seem to remember that it was explained some time ago when something similar had happened, that the reason for the secrecy was to ensure that the tabs and paps were kept out of the picture. As we know, we have people here who are on the lookout for any interesting news that might be passed on to the tabs as soon as they are aware of it. :smiley-rolleyes:
Why do I feel gullible? Because I should have picked up on it sooner. It is not the first time it has happened. I feel no animosity towards anyone who got to attend this fun event. I just had so much fun here yesterday that I didn't stop to think everything through as to what was going on. More power to them. Don't know really how to explain it, it is just kind of like a gotcha moment when you were not expecting it...lol
Quote:
Originally Posted by Pickled Tink
, (excerpted)
But surely it is not too much to be happy that others got this opportunity and that they are willing to share it with you?
I, for one, (and surely there are others) am very happy for those who got to attend this M & G. As with so many other events before, there is a vicarious enjoyment, well-fleshed out by those who were there. Has it not always been our experience that those who attended any such event were gracious and generous with their time, stories, pictures, recollections, etc.? Can we not be equally gracious and generous with our appreciation for their good fortune and delight in being able to attend? I'm happy for them! :dance::Ilovesusan:
I'm happy for the fans who were a part of this M&G especially the first timers. I'm looking forward to sharing the experience through reading their stories. How exciting!! I hope we hear from them soon.
:Ilovesusan:
Quote:
Originally Posted by andyp
Subo's team are doing all they can to alienate fans, for certain.
Well, I can certainly understand why there would be some "ruffled feathers" - this was handled poorly IMHO - no flames please.
Im so happy for everyone that got to meet her. I hope one day Ill be able to make a trip to a meet and greet with her. :D
Quote:
Originally Posted by antique
And how do we contact Susan's management?
hahaha ... I think that's a secret. :D I wonder if MartyPA was one of the lucky members? I hope so. I notice she's not here commenting. hmmmmm? :p
Quote:
Originally Posted by Retired In Kalifornia
"For The Record" I was asked via e-mail by GritsT to attend the M&G some weeks ago, was asked then to keep this confidential. I had to decline because of time contraints & economics. Congratulations to all those who did attend the event. Richard
"I too for the Record" was invited to attend this M&G some weeks ago, and was asked to keep this confidential as well. I had to heartbreakingly decline due to funding (as always-story of my life). I could not be more happy for those that could make it and meet the One and Only Miss Susan Boyle. Congratulations to you all. :D
Well, I will probably never be able to meet Susan so I'm quite happy to see any pictures and read the reports of the lucky ones who get to meet with Susan. I'm just happy for those who had the opportunity. Get busy ladies - we are waiting.................
http://i717.photobucket.com/albums/w...s/32-thumb.gifhttp://i266.photobucket.com/albums/i...84runhappy.gifhttp://i717.photobucket.com/albums/w...s/32-thumb.gif
Quote:
Originally Posted by andyp
Subo's team are doing all they can to alienate fans, for certain.
Come on folks - it is a case of "damned if you do and damned if you don't" - let's be happy for those fortunates who attended, a day they will never forget - we can still speculate as to WHY she is in New York in the first instance and impatiently await AGT!
Quote:
Originally Posted by Pickled Tink
Whilst I understand that everyone wants to know how or why the people who attended got to go. Can I make the following points. This was not a forum meet and greet, there may be a lot of things we are not privy to and which they do not yet want us to know, they have their reasons, and we should respect them. So, maybe some of the comments and questions are perhaps not helpful. It is understandable that everyone wants to be there etc... .However, Susan has MILLIONS of fans and if there was a meet and greet every single day for the next ten years she could not meet them all. It's just not practicable. Yes of course everyone wants to meet her. Some of us have been very very lucky and we know that. Some have not been and I so wish that more folk had been. I also know that more folk will be in the future.
But can I ask you for for a few minutes to put yourselves in the shoes of those who have met Susan today. They have just had the time of their lives; they will be excited, over the moon, and just itching to share their news. They will come to the forum and what will they see? Posts which quite frankly seem a little resentful that some were chosen and they were not. How would you feel if that were you? There will always be someone who will be disappointed whatever criteria are used. But surely it is not too much to be happy that others got this opportunity and that they are willing to share it with you?
I am very pleased for the fans, I just don't see the need for secrecy, it would have been the next best thing to have known about it and to have waited for posts with eager anticipation and I am sure if we were told that it was a small gathering the members would have respected that but felt involved. JMHO Sorry.
:excellent:
Quote:
Originally Posted by MollBobbers
Soothed, I don't understand why you say you were gullible? Because you didn't know this was going to happen? I don't think it was kept a secret in case we got too excited. But I seem to remember that it was explained some time ago when something similar had happened, that the reason for the secrecy was to ensure that the tabs and paps were kept out of the picture. As we know, we have people here who are on the lookout for any interesting news that might be passed on to the tabs as soon as they are aware of it. :smiley-rolleyes:
I regret to say I feel a little kicked in the gut. I am very happy for those who got to visit, but that does not quell my disappointment in how it all came about. JMHO.
I may go down in history as the one fan she will never meet, but that is okay. I will always love her. She doesn't have to shake my hand to touch me. I do hope she is having fun.
Quote:
Originally Posted by bernicer
JMHO, it sure would be nice to feel included instead of excluded.
Was not going to post on this at all, as no doubt it will be another mark against me.
I am very happy for the fans who were there and would like to know who they are and what exciting things they have to say about the M&G. No resentment against them for being the chosen ones.
I would also like to request that perhaps Susan or Andy or Joanne or GritsT or Randma or whoever puts together the list of attendees would let everyone else know what the criteria are to be included in one of these exclusive events. Then maybe others could make themselves known to the right people. Since RIK was invited this was obviously nothing to do with proximity to NYC.
I am sure that I will never be invited, and I accept that, but it would be nice to give all the good people on this site a clue-and other sites as well.
All of this secrecy and exclusiveness is not what we would have expected from Susan, so it comes as a shock and a disappointment, I am not posting again on this, and I don't care what anyone thinks. I regret that the message will never get to Susan that people feel bad.
Just because some dont see the need for secrecy does not mean that there was not a very good reason for tsecrecy on this occasion. We are not privy to everything. I have often been puzzled by things and thought "I really dont see why they do that" only for things to become clear further down the track. I suspect that this is one of those occasions. I am sure that things will be made clear all in good time.
Quote:
Originally Posted by UKSusanfanAnn
I am very pleased for the fans, I just don't see the need for secrecy, it would have been the next best thing to have known about it and to have waited for posts with eager anticipation and I am sure if we were told that it was a small gathering the members would have respected that but felt involved. JMHO Sorry.
Ann
While I understand your feelings, the secrecy was requested by Andy and there was nothing we could do.
I'm sure ALL of us are disappointed that we weren't included, at least with the planning of it. But you know what, I'm a grown up and I can take it and I'm sure as heck not going to let it ruin my enjoyment of Susan's visit here. I don't care how it was planned, with Susan's best interest in mind, I'm sure. I'm just glad we now have SUSA NEWS, however it comes about.
Mollbobbers, I felt gullible in that I should have picked up on the intrigue. I was having too much fun here yesterday, to notice. It has happened before and will probably happen again. No big thing in the scheme of things.
Quote:
Originally Posted by soothed
I may go down in history as the one fan she will never meet, but that is okay. I will always love her. She doesn't have to shake my hand to touch me. I do hope she is having fun.
Well said Soothed. I too will likely never meet Susan, but that does not change how much I love & admire her. Thanks for putting it into perspective.
Quote:
Originally Posted by soothed
Why do I feel gullible? Because I should have picked up on it sooner. It is not the first time it has happened. I feel no animosity towards anyone who got to attend this fun event. I just had so much fun here yesterday that I didn't stop to think everything through as to what was going on. More power to them. Don't know really how to explain it, it is just kind of like a gotcha moment when you were not expecting it...lol
Then we are all equally "gullible". Even though it has happened before, I don't think anyone picked up on it. Which I hope means that the tab spies didn't pick up on it either. That was the whole idea - and well done to them. The privacy of Susan and of her fans have been respected. And IMO it is even more exciting this way when we never guessed what was coming, to get such great news and to be able to look forward to twenty first-hand reports. Just can't wait. :happydancing::happydancing::happydancing:
Quote:
Originally Posted by Retired In Kalifornia
"For The Record" I was asked via e-mail by GritsT to attend the M&G some weeks ago, was asked then to keep this confidential. I had to decline because of time contraints & economics. Congratulations to all those who did attend the event. Richard
"I also for the Record" was invited by GritsT to attend some weeks ago, but due to finacial reasons (as always with me), I had to heartbreakingly decline. I could not have been more happy and excited for those that got to go. I knew I was going to miss something great, and great it was I am sure! Congratulations to those that got to chat with The One, The Only, Miss Susan Boyle! :D
Quote:
Originally Posted by Kalua
Ann
While I understand your feelings, the secrecy was requested by Andy and there was nothing we could do.
Thanks Kalua, I appreciate your reply and I appreciate your predicament, will say no more, except I look forward to member's reports, :thanks:
Quote:
Originally Posted by UKSusanfanAnn
I am very pleased for the fans, I just don't see the need for secrecy, it would have been the next best thing to have known about it and to have waited for posts with eager anticipation and I am sure if we were told that it was a small gathering the members would have respected that but felt involved. JMHO Sorry.
There seems to be a big lack of understanding that you can't whisper in the ear of people you want to know and do it on-line. If you want the whole world to know, just put it on-line. Can you imagine what would have happened if they put out the word in advance?
:eek2::eek:
First I'd like to say I'm not the least bit concerned about not being invited because I would have declined anyway . But just an objective observation , I think the secrecy is a big mistake. It's not the part about not being invited that is insulting,it's keeping the meet and greet a secret. What's the point of it? Why all the scheming? Why did Tink say Grits had 24 hrs notice and RIK say he was invited weeks ago? It sends a message that they think Susan fans are dumb . Why does team Subo feel they have to manipulate Susan's fans to this extent? I'm merely curious.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Henny
There seems to be a big lack of understanding that you can't whisper in the ear of people you want to know and do it on-line. If you want the whole world to know, just put it on-line. Can you imagine what would have happened if they put out the word in advance?
:eek2::eek:
http://www.villaspeople.com/images/r...bteaserimg.jpg
It seems I'm not the only one with a kick in the stomach sort of feeling. Not a good ploy in my opinion, although it is wonderful that at least 20 fans had some pleasure.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Henny
I think there must be a few million who fit the category of wanting to meet
Susan! :biggrin:
That's for sure. My thinking was since Susan is coming to LA for AGT that just in case there might be a M & G here, I wanted to let Susan's team know I haven't met her and would love to if they would be so kind as to invite me. I am so very happy for those who have met Susan today in NY and for everyone who has met her at any time before.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Little Lulu
I'm sure ALL of us are disappointed that we weren't included, at least with the planning of it. But you know what, I'm a grown up and I can take it and I'm sure as heck not going to let it ruin my enjoyment of Susan's visit here. I don't care how it was planned, with Susan's best interest in mind, I'm sure. I'm just glad we now have SUSA NEWS, however it comes about.
:excellent::Ilovesusan::Its All Good:
I can think of 20 folk right now who on reading this thread will be getting that kick in the stomach feeling and quite frankly they should not be!!!
Quote:
Originally Posted by Henny
There seems to be a big lack of understanding that you can't whisper in the ear of people you want to know and do it on-line. If you want the whole world to know, just put it on-line. Can you imagine what would have happened if they put out the word in advance?
:eek2::eek:
Perhaps I am naive, but if I were told it was a small gathering I would not have gone and spoilt the party, not that I could have done anyway, being in the UK, I would have sat by my computer happily awaiting reports, as I will do for AGT.:)
Quote:
Originally Posted by Robert the Bruce
http://www.villaspeople.com/images/r...bteaserimg.jpg
:rofl:<=3:overjoyed:
More truth than fiction!!!!
:susanrocks:I am somewhat psychic. Lol I never get any tips on the stock market or what horse will win a race, but lots of my feelings about what is going on come true. I felt there was something different going on so I didn't post. I hope forum members,who were not invited-I wasn't invited either; will not get their knickers in a twist. I am sure that Susan's team did the best they could with the invites. I hope in the future Susan's website will keep us up to date better than they have.
:susanrocks::susanrocks: :biggrin:
Quote:
Originally Posted by bernicer
JMHO, it sure would be nice to feel included instead of excluded.
Bern, TRUST ME, if I could had been able to "share my slot" after declinging the offer to attend the first person I'd ask to go would be SusaFan Lorias as she's my Fans For Susan Boyle Websites "boss" and a good friend. Lori has number of disabilities, I'd do anything short of carrying her on my back to NYC from Indiana for her to see Susan. I'll glady give up my "slot" for anybody else, including transporting any fan between Cameron Park to CBS Television City within reasonable distance from California State Route 99 to see Susan perform on AGT - if she indeed does - late this month or next for free, including paying for overnight lodging if we couldn't make it a day trip. I'd offered last year to do something like this to see Susan at AGT & DWTS BTW.
The one report I am most interested in is what we didn't get: info on what Susan is working on that took her to NY in the first place. This isn't info the m&g people would know, so the waiting will continue to find out what the heck Susan is up to.
There will be other meet and greets everyone. Dont worry, be happy. :) Im sure no one on Susans team wanted us to get upset over this. They didnt mean for anyone to get mad.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Henny
There seems to be a big lack of understanding that you can't whisper in the ear of people you want to know and do it on-line. If you want the whole world to know, just put it on-line. Can you imagine what would have happened if they put out the word in advance?
:eek2::eek:
But we did plan a very delightful, and open to anyone, dinner and brunch last year in NYC, to which Susan and Amber were invited. Right here on this forum. But there ARE reasons for what was planned this time, we just don't know what they were. In this day and age with I'm surprised they did it at all. I would feel horrible if something bad happened if the wrong people got wind of it. Just sayin.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Lisa Pully
"I also for the Record" was invited by GritsT to attend some weeks ago, but due to finacial reasons (as always with me), I had to heartbreakingly decline. I could not have been more happy and excited for those that got to go. I knew I was going to miss something great, and great it was I am sure! Congratulations to those that got to chat with The One, The Only, Miss Susan Boyle! :D
Lisa, I'm heartbroken, let me know if such an opportunity comes up again I can help pay for the trip! Richard
Quote:
Originally Posted by Pickled Tink
I can think of 20 folk right now who on reading this thread will be getting that kick in the stomach feeling and quite frankly they should not be!!!
PT, I am absolutely sure no one feels resentful of the members who have got to meet Susan, I am sure they are thrilled for them that is not the point. I personally am thrilled for everyone so please don't feel bad it is wonderful and good on them.:)
Quote:
Originally Posted by Pickled Tink
I can think of 20 folk right now who on reading this thread will be getting that kick in the stomach feeling and quite frankly they should not be!!!
From my perspective, this unrest has nothing to do with the lucky 20 who got the privilege of meeting Susan. I am happy for them. I could not have gone even if invited, so it is not about me either. It is about treating us as if we are three and can't be trusted. I would have loved to have been informed and in on it, so to speak. My life needs all the excitement it can get, right at the moment. Also to make sure the invited were evenly represented from all fansites. JMHO
Quote:
Originally Posted by Patriciasart
First I'd like to say I'm not the least bit concerned about not being invited because I would have declined anyway . But just an objective observation , I think the secrecy is a big mistake. It's not the part about not being invited that is insulting,it's keeping the meet and greet a secret. What's the point of it? Why all the scheming? Why did Tink say Grits had 24 hrs notice and RIK say he was invited weeks ago? It sends a message that they think Susan fans are dumb . Why does team Subo feel they have to manipulate Susan's fans to this extent? I'm merely curious.
You obviously misread or misunderstood what I said. RIK was contacted severl week ago. Grits had 24 hours notice to get them organised. In a 24 hours period 2/3 weeks ago Grits had to nail it all down so that everyone could make their travel arrangements.
The secrecy issue is something for which there is probably a very GOOD reason. When that reason is made public we may all understand. It is all too easy to jump to conclusions when we are not in the full possession of the facts. These people are professionals and they do not keep things secret just to annoy fans. Yes we are curious, and they understand that but they will reveal all when the time is right to do so. Their primary aim is to protect and support Susan and that should be ours as well. A little faith would not hurt now and again. I am not suggesting we all follow blindly, that would be naive in the extreme, but that that we actually wait and see for once and then if it turns out that the reasons dont stand up to scutiny - then and only then - do we start with the recriminations and what would be legitimate complaints.
Quote:
Originally Posted by ilovethesingingbird
:susanrocks:I am somewhat psychic. Lol I never get any tips on the stock market or what horse will win a race, but lots of my feelings about what is going on come true. I felt there was something different going on so I didn't post. I hope forum members,who were not invited-I wasn't invited either; will not get their knickers in a twist. I am sure that Susan's team did the best they could with the invites. I hope in the future Susan's website will keep us up to date better than they have.
:susanrocks::susanrocks: :biggrin:
So are you saying that if we keep in touch with you you will tell us? We do keep up to date, but this was done in secret, remember?
Quote:
Originally Posted by antique
And how do we contact Susan's management?
People from the northeast should have been invited first, IMHO- then Sony would have not had to pay expenses. I am puzzled by this, but i won't make any waves- I can get my questions answered in due time.
In the meantime, I have one- were the people there today filmed for use in the documentary? I am looking forward to reports from those fortunate enough to have been able to attend today.
"I'm very excited to be in New York, it's so good to be back in this wonderful city. I've got a busy few days meeting some wonderful people and you'll be the first to hear my news when I can tell you." (Susan Boyle)
I am pleased that yet more fans got to meet with Susan "one to one" and that a good time was had by all. I also assume that, in the fullness of time, they will post their reports of this meet and greet to all of us here and on other sites so that we can share in their excitement and hopefully also get some idea of what transpired.
I, for one, look forward to that with great anticipation.
I am surmising that, on this occasion, the meet and greet involved such secrecy because it was more than just a meet and greet and that there may be other reasons, unknown to all of us at this moment, for such secrecy.
Maybe it would be prudent for us all to wait and hear from those in attendance and especially from Susan herself.
JMHO
Quote:
Originally Posted by andyp
The Susan team are not doing themselves any favourites. They are alienating fans.
Come on, Andy. You don't mean that. Look they're trying to launch Susan's all-important 3rd CD in the best way, possible. I'm sure the activities were filmed and some of that will be used for a later promotion. I understand that Susan needs a few familiar faces around her, because she is shy, but I think it's lovely she asked for the great proportion to be people she'd never met. And she got an audience to try out a couple of new songs on and got a great reaction. That must have been reassuring for her.
I don't know what the criteria were for choosing people to invite, but if it were me, I would have asked those who had volunteered the most time toward keeping the sites running.
I believe it had to be kept secret, because an awful lot of Susan fans live in and around NYC and they all would have wanted to go. And the group had to be kept small for the larger promotional purpose of the M&G. I understand some are offended by the knowledge that they weren't in on the secret and others were, but honestly, I don't see how it could have been done any other way.
The exciting times are just starting. The ones we've been waiting for all year. Let's not spoil it
Quote:
Originally Posted by donniecat
Well, I can certainly understand why there would be some "ruffled feathers" - this was handled poorly IMHO - no flames please.
I agree but there are fans who keep in constant contact with Susan's team- we are not one of them. I suppose they deserve to be the ones asked to put something like this together. It is just reality. I could not have gone to NY anyway with my back, had i been asked- but i am glad RIK was asked!!!!!!
I am thrilled that these 20 people got to see Susan and hear her sing, can't wait for reports. I am also very disturbed by the negative and jealous comments by some of you.
Quote:
Originally Posted by soothed
I may go down in history as the one fan she will never meet, but that is okay. I will always love her. She doesn't have to shake my hand to touch me. I do hope she is having fun.
That goes for me too. Thanks for saying it so well. Also I just really want Susan to have that longevity,lots of it.
Quote:
Originally Posted by andyp
Andy may have been in the business for a long time, but he sure knows how to lose Susafans. This is the second time that he messsed up in my opinion. What a jerk. And please, mods, this is my honest opinion and I am entitled to it. No warnings, please. leave my post up if you are a democracy.
I believe Andy is a businessman and he takes the line of least resistance- if someone told him that they could guarantee a certain number of susan fans to show up at short notice, he took this person's assistance. It is not his fault- so do not blame him
RIK On The Subject Of Who's Invited Or Not
Listen Carefully Folks:
If Susan ever comes to Canada I'd love to meet her so take note Team Subo. Congratulations to the lucky 20 and where are you! We want details!!
Don't want to make this a reply to anyone. Just wanted to say that if this or any other M&G or anything else "alienates" a Susan Boyle fan, then there is something mightily wrong, not with her management but with the fan themselves. If Andy decided secrecy was the way to go (and with the tabs being what they are) I can certainly understand it. If it was posted on the forum, you can bet your bottom dollar that it would have been posted elsewhere. Since it was limited to 20 people, how else does anything think it could have been handled differently? I am as avid a fan of Susan as anyone, but I don't have the need to meet her or even be invited to meet her to feel that way. I love her persona and I love her music. There seems to be an attitude that we should somehow be privileged to know everything she does or is doing and the reasons behind it. Wondering is fine. Speculation can be fun. But I do not think being loyal and supportive fans gives us any special "rights". I hope we will get pictures and news from those who were there. I can understand if we do not.
Quote:
Originally Posted by soothed
I may go down in history as the one fan she will never meet, but that is okay. I will always love her. She doesn't have to shake my hand to touch me. I do hope she is having fun.
No you won't, there are millions of us, lets be realistic. Susan can never meet us all. By meeting some and sharing time with them - knowing they will in turn share the experience with fans who were not there, is very generous of Susan and we're very lucky imo - those who do meet Susan, and those who get first hand accounts about it. Love your line, 'she doesn't have to shake my hand to touch me.' Eloquent and so very true :>)
Quote:
Originally Posted by diane wheldrake
I am thrilled that these 20 people got to see Susan and hear her sing, can't wait for reports. I am also very disturbed by the negative and jealous comments by some of you.
I suspect that's why no one has posted anything - in fear of being "flamed"
Quote:
Originally Posted by diane wheldrake
I am thrilled that these 20 people got to see Susan and hear her sing, can't wait for reports. I am also very disturbed by the negative and jealous comments by some of you.
Same here Diane, I am really sad to see all of this , and if I was one of the 20 and I was reading this thread I would not feel much like posting. Just listen to yourselves, ME ME ME.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Clarissastarr
There will be other meet and greets everyone. Dont worry, be happy. :) Im sure no one on Susans team wanted us to get upset over this. They didnt mean for anyone to get mad.
You are so right. I am so surprised at some of the posts on here. I couldn't have gone if asked, and probably a lot of others couldn't have, either. And surely most of us realize why it couldn't be made public. Even tho this is a thread everyone can't read, we know there are some on here who are newspeople and or paps. If they had made it public, the whole thing would have been swarmed. I am so happy I am a member of this forum, so I can read about these meet and greets, and enjoy the pictures taken by those lucky enough to have gone.
I just hope the postings of some on this forum so far today doesn't turn Susan's people off from doing other meet and greets. If there are people keeping track of who might be good to invite next time, I would say a few have cooked their goose today. Please, everyone, let's enjoy the fun here, and enjoy Susan. We wouldn't know any of this if it wasn't for this forum.
Quote:
Originally Posted by cac1936
Don't want to make this a reply to anyone. Just wanted to say that if this or any other M&G or anything else "alienates" a Susan Boyle fan, then there is something mightily wrong, not with her management but with the fan themselves. If Andy decided secrecy was the way to go (and with the tabs being what they are) I can certainly understand it. If it was posted on the forum, you can bet your bottom dollar that it would have been posted elsewhere. Since it was limited to 20 people, how else does anything think it could have been handled differently? I am as avid a fan of Susan as anyone, but I don't have the need to meet her or even be invited to meet her to feel that way. I love her persona and I love her music. There seems to be an attitude that we should somehow be privileged to know everything she does or is doing and the reasons behind it. Wondering is fine. Speculation can be fun. But I do not think being loyal and supportive fans gives us any special "rights". I hope we will get pictures and news from those who were there. I can understand if we do not.
Bravo cac!
Quote:
Originally Posted by OGM45
I suspect that's why no one has posted anything - in fear of being "flamed"
I agree with you.
Quote:
Originally Posted by JudyMcKinn
You are so right. I am so surprised at some of the posts on here. I couldn't have gone if asked, and probably a lot of others couldn't have, either. And surely most of us realize why it couldn't be made public. Even tho this is a thread everyone can't read, we know there are some on here who are newspeople and or paps. If they had made it public, the whole thing would have been swarmed. I am so happy I am a member of this forum, so I can read about these meet and greets, and enjoy the pictures taken by those lucky enough to have gone.
I just hope the postings of some on this forum so far today doesn't turn Susan's people off from doing other meet and greets. If there are people keeping track of who might be good to invite next time, I would say a few have cooked their goose today. Please, everyone, let's enjoy the fun here, and enjoy Susan. We wouldn't know any of this if it wasn't for this forum.
Thank you Judy! Ditto
Quote:
Originally Posted by diane wheldrake
I am thrilled that these 20 people got to see Susan and hear her sing, can't wait for reports. I am also very disturbed by the negative and jealous comments by some of you.
Diane, I think I have proved myself to be a true and loyal fan of both Susan and the Forum, so I can assure you I am not the least bit jealous of the fans who were invited, I am truely pleased for them, I would have just liked to have kn own about it to enjoy the anticipation and feel involved but possibly as stevieboy has said there are reasons for the secrecy, I hope so. :)
:excellent::excellent::excellent:
Quote:
Originally Posted by cac1936
Don't want to make this a reply to anyone. Just wanted to say that if this or any other M&G or anything else "alienates" a Susan Boyle fan, then there is something mightily wrong, not with her management but with the fan themselves. If Andy decided secrecy was the way to go (and with the tabs being what they are) I can certainly understand it. If it was posted on the forum, you can bet your bottom dollar that it would have been posted elsewhere. Since it was limited to 20 people, how else does anything think it could have been handled differently? I am as avid a fan of Susan as anyone, but I don't have the need to meet her or even be invited to meet her to feel that way. I love her persona and I love her music. There seems to be an attitude that we should somehow be privileged to know everything she does or is doing and the reasons behind it. Wondering is fine. Speculation can be fun. But I do not think being loyal and supportive fans gives us any special "rights". I hope we will get pictures and news from those who were there. I can understand if we do not.
Quote:
Originally Posted by terijay7
I believe this was something that was done for the documentary- the fact that several have come forward and said they were invited ( weeks ago) to be in NYC today, shows that they did not mention it either. So, it was secret, because the producers who wanted footage wanted it kept that way- still-- it does make some fans a little less trustful of the way it was kept secret- remnds me of the scene in the film "Guys and Dolls"- where the character says he can produce 20 qualified sinners in 24 hours- someone was contacted by Susans team and did just that. I do not think we should bash the person contacted, however. It was not their doing. This person- appears to be Grits-- arranged things and did so because she was asked to do so. No point in bashing her.
There's no point in bashing anyone, Teri. It is a shame if that is what happens.
Quote:
Originally Posted by ilovethesingingbird
:susanrocks:I am somewhat psychic. Lol I never get any tips on the stock market or what horse will win a race, but lots of my feelings about what is going on come true. I felt there was something different going on so I didn't post. I hope forum members,who were not invited-I wasn't invited either; will not get their knickers in a twist. I am sure that Susan's team did the best they could with the invites. I hope in the future Susan's website will keep us up to date better than they have.
:susanrocks::susanrocks: :biggrin:
Well, I wouldn't count on the website, but I do agree Susan's team has probably learned from this. Susan is not an ordinary global star and neither are her fans and it's a mistake to give the impression, wrongly I'm sure, that there is an "inner circle" of select fans, privy to secret information. There are other ways I believe to winnow the crowd. Maybe by lottery.
I'm not speaking personally. I don't care. I just want Susan to sell lots of CDs, make lots of money and live happily ever after. But obviously some do.
It would help if the folks, who were there, would get on the stick and report. As chosen representatives of Subo Fandom they are privileged but timely reporting is also the responsibility.
Quote:
Originally Posted by cac1936
Don't want to make this a reply to anyone. Just wanted to say that if this or any other M&G or anything else "alienates" a Susan Boyle fan, then there is something mightily wrong, not with her management but with the fan themselves. If Andy decided secrecy was the way to go (and with the tabs being what they are) I can certainly understand it. If it was posted on the forum, you can bet your bottom dollar that it would have been posted elsewhere. Since it was limited to 20 people, how else does anything think it could have been handled differently? I am as avid a fan of Susan as anyone, but I don't have the need to meet her or even be invited to meet her to feel that way. I love her persona and I love her music. There seems to be an attitude that we should somehow be privileged to know everything she does or is doing and the reasons behind it. Wondering is fine. Speculation can be fun. But I do not think being loyal and supportive fans gives us any special "rights". I hope we will get pictures and news from those who were there. I can understand if we do not.
:excellent: Of course, you speak great sense carol, it just would have been lovely to have it to look forward to but in the real world I guess it is not possible. Will delete some of my posts.:)
I was invited with the criteria that I had NOT met Susan before. I had met Susan in NYC in 2009, so I relinguished my spot to someone who had not met Susan. I can assure you that I have no priviliege with Susan's team or administration of this website. I Believe I was chosen randomly. I do believe that those who met Susan today felt at the top of the world as I did in 2009, and it lives with me still.
Ok all you lucky dogs, POST we love you and we love Susan. We are sittin here on the edge of ours seats. Except Teri, that is, she's got to be careful.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Retired In Kalifornia
Lisa, I'm heartbroken, let me know if such an opportunity comes up again I can help pay for the trip! Richard
RIK my dear friend, you are making me cry this very moment. :'(:hug: I love you my friend. After last years trip to NYC to see Susan perform (which I am still over the moon over with) I really do not think I could accept, I do not think it would be right. I am not so desirving of your generious kindness. You mean more to me then you know. :hug-2:
Quote:
Originally Posted by trennie
Well, I wouldn't count on the website, but I do agree Susan's team has probably learned from this. Susan is not an ordinary global star and neither are her fans and it's a mistake to give the impression, wrongly I'm sure, that there is an "inner circle" of select fans, privy to secret information. There are other ways I believe to winnow the crowd. Maybe by lottery.
I'm not speaking personally. I don't care. I just want Susan to sell lots of CDs, make lots of money and live happily ever after. But obviously some do.
It would help if the folks, who were there, would get on the stick and report. As chosen representatives of Subo Fandom they are privileged but timely reporting is also the responsibility.
Why would they want to post here? They likely don't want to read all the negative they most probably would get
Quote:
Originally Posted by Pickled Tink
You obviously misread or misunderstood what I said. RIK was contacted severl week ago. Grits had 24 hours notice to get them organised. In a 24 hours period 2/3 weeks ago Grits had to nail it all down so that everyone could make their travel arrangements.
The secrecy issue is something for which there is probably a very GOOD reason. When that reason is made public we may all understand. It is all too easy to jump to conclusions when we are not in the full possession of the facts. These people are professionals and they do not keep things secret just to annoy fans. Yes we are curious, and they understand that but they will reveal all when the time is right to do so. Their primary aim is to protect and support Susan and that should be ours as well. A little faith would not hurt now and again. I am not suggesting we all follow blindly, that would be naive in the extreme, but that that we actually wait and see for once and then if it turns out that the reasons dont stand up to scutiny - then and only then - do we start with the recriminations and what would be legitimate complaints.
Thank you PT for being the voice of reason.
Quote:
Originally Posted by cmenard23
I was invited with the criteria that I had NOT met Susan before. I had met Susan in NYC in 2009, so I relinguished my spot to someone who had not met Susan. I can assure you that I have no priviliege with Susan's team or administration of this website. I Believe I was chosen randomly. I do believe that those who met Susan today felt at the top of the world as I did in 2009, and it lives with me still.
YOU, are "true" Susan fan. It's something Susan would do. Thank you.
Quote:
Originally Posted by stevieboy49
"I'm very excited to be in New York, it's so good to be back in this wonderful city. I've got a busy few days meeting some wonderful people and you'll be the first to hear my news when I can tell you." (Susan Boyle)
I am pleased that yet more fans got to meet with Susan "one to one" and that a good time was had by all. I also assume that, in the fullness of time, they will post their reports of this meet and greet to all of us here and on other sites so that we can share in their excitement and hopefully also get some idea of what transpired.
I, for one, look forward to that with great anticipation.
I am surmising that, on this occasion, the meet and greet involved such secrecy because it was more than just a meet and greet and that there may be other reasons, unknown to all of us at this moment, for such secrecy.
Maybe it would be prudent for us all to wait and hear from those in attendance and especially from Susan herself.
JMHO
Well said, Stevieboy!
Quote:
Originally Posted by OGM45
Why would they want to post here? They likely don't want to hear all the negative they most likely would get
Hopefully they will post here because they understand that most of Susan's fans here are eagerly looking forward to hearing all about their adventure - what Susan said, what Susan did, how Susan looked.... and maybe a word or two about themselves. lol
Come on folks - as trennie fairly said - timely reporting is a responsibility and I have started timing you.:biggrin:
Quote:
Originally Posted by cac1936
There's no point in bashing anyone, Teri. It is a shame if that is what happens.
I agree- no point in bashing anyone. It is what it is....we are all Susan fans and want to hear about the times they had today-- i am just shooting off my first reactions- but- my reactions are not negative towards the lucky fans- not at all. I want that to be clear.
Quote:
Originally Posted by CanadianBill
Hopefully they will post here because they understand that most of Susan's fans here are eagerly looking forward to hearing all about their adventure - what Susan said, what Susan did, how Susan looked.... and maybe a word or two about themselves. lol
Come on folks - as trennie fairly said - timely reporting is a responsibility and I have started timing you.:biggrin:
Thanks Bill, we need some humor here. LOL
Quote:
Originally Posted by CanadianBill
Hopefully they will post here because they understand that most of Susan's fans here are eagerly looking forward to hearing all about their adventure - what Susan said, what Susan did, how Susan looked.... and maybe a word or two about themselves. lol
Come on folks - as trennie fairly said - timely reporting is a responsibility and I have started timing you.:biggrin:
I do hope they will post their exciting and unforgettable time. I'm looking forward to it, but if they don't I will understand
I'm ready for the reports! :thirsty::popcorn::D
Quote:
Originally Posted by Pickled Tink
You obviously misread or misunderstood what I said. RIK was contacted severl week ago. Grits had 24 hours notice to get them organised. In a 24 hours period 2/3 weeks ago Grits had to nail it all down so that everyone could make their travel arrangements. The secrecy issue is something for which there is probably a very GOOD reason. When that reason is made public we may all understand. It is all too easy to jump to conclusions when we are not in the full possession of the facts. These people are professionals and they do not keep things secret just to annoy fans. Yes we are curious, and they understand that but they will reveal all when the time is right to do so. Their primary aim is to protect and support Susan and that should be ours as well. A little faith would not hurt now and again. I am not suggesting we all follow blindly, that would be naive in the extreme, but that that we actually wait and see for once and then if it turns out that the reasons dont stand up to scutiny - then and only then - do we start with the recriminations and what would be legitimate complaints.
Thanx for explaining this misunderstanding,LOL! big grin I guess all the secrecy seems silly to me but maybe it is a PR ploy . Oh well,that's show biz big grin
Quote:
Originally Posted by Lisa Pully
RIK my dear friend, you are making me cry this very moment. :'(:hug: I love you my friend. After last years trip to NYC to see Susan perform (which I am still over the moon over with) I really do not think I could accept, I do not think it would be right. I am not so desirving of your generious kindness. You mean more to me then you know. :hug-2:
Lisa, my regret is there was no time to let Lorias much less you or anybody else to be substituted for today's M&G. GritsT et.al. setting it up "from the fandom side" had to work fast as those putting on the M&G wanted those who could be there - there - and as many possible who never met Susan before and that so happened to include me. There WILL be other opportunities to meet with Susan, I'll settle seeing her on AGT IF she does appear on it next few weeks. I just envy those lucky SusaFans who got to her Susan sing not one but TWO new songs today - man how I just wish!
Quote:
Originally Posted by Little Lulu
Ok all you lucky dogs, POST we love you and we love Susan. We are sittin here on the edge of ours seats. Except Teri, that is, she's got to be careful.
you got that right- i have to refill the hot water bottle and I am NOT kidding :'(:'(
Quote:
Originally Posted by time2live
I'm ready for the reports! :thirsty::popcorn::D
Yeah, me too. I already poured my beer. :biggrin:
i would like to hear about the songs she sang- were they new ones? That i would love to know
Quote:
Originally Posted by Cee
I'll say I'm shocked...to say the least. There are a lot of people right here on this Forum who have never met Susan. Am I delighted that there was a Meet and Greet (secret) in NY? No, not really. Not like this. Put myself in the shoes of people who attended? Can't bear to do it. Have I been negatively affected by this? Yes. There are fans, and then there are FANS.
Hopefully speaking from an objective viewpoint, being too far away to ever have been "invited" - the issue seems to be how some are worthy of being invited, and others are not. Huge disappointment for those who are relegated to the second category. The secrecy does seem hard to figure, because on other occasions they want a crowd for publicity purposes. Would it matter if the media knew about the meeting? The restaurant could have removed any obvious paparazzi. The World Fan Meeting was open to all fans, was wonderfully well organised and was not secret. As far as I am aware, there were no problems with intrusive media.
Quote:
Originally Posted by OGM45
Why would they want to post here? They likely don't want to read all the negative they most probably would get
Once we get news, I think we'll lose the negative comments. At the end of the day, we're all here for Susan and what we're interested in Susan's mood, what she says, what she sings (or if not that, at least whether they were good songs) and generally if the prospects for the Fall are bright.
Quote:
Originally Posted by terijay7
i would like to hear about the songs she sang- were they new ones? That i would love to know
Tink said they were Teri...and you gotta know WHICH one I'm praying for here!
Ok folks if we want to know how that M&G went, better stop all this.
If I were one of the fans there, only by reading all that has been posted I would run away.
Whatever the reasons for the requested secrecy, what we have to do now is appreciate the reports
which I sincerely hope will be forthcoming.
I intend to enjoy them fully.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Helen101
Hopefully speaking from an objective viewpoint, being too far away to ever have been "invited" - the issue seems to be how some are worthy of being invited, and others are not. Huge disappointment for those who are relegated to the second category. The secrecy does seem hard to figure, because on other occasions they want a crowd for publicity purposes. Would it matter if the media knew about the meeting? The restaurant could have removed any obvious paparazzi. The World Fan Meeting was open to all fans, was wonderfully well organised and was not secret. As far as I am aware, there were no problems with intrusive media.
As Tink has said, this was done by Susan's PR and Mgt Team contacting people-- beyond that, that is all i will say.
They needed bodies. I do not think they were thinking they were hurting anyone's feelings really. Just my take.
I'm sitting at the edge of my seat waiting for some reports. PLEASE!!! :biggrin::biggrin:
Waiting, waiting, waiting......
:popcorn::popcorn:
Quote:
Originally Posted by trennie
Once we get news, I think we'll lose the negative comments. At the end of the day, we're all here for Susan and what we're interested in Susan's mood, what she says, what she sings (or if not that, at least whether they were good songs) and generally if the prospects for the Fall are bright.
Yes agree trennie, I apologise for my negativity, was just a bit disappointed but please please everybody post soon as it is getting very late here in the UK, LOL.:biggrin:
I am so happy for the 20 fans who met Susan today. I can't wait to hear their reports!!! big grin
Quote:
Originally Posted by Kalua
Ok folks if we want to know how that M&G went, better stop all this.
If I were one of the fans there, only by reading all that has been posted I would run away.
Whatever the reasons for the requested secrecy, what we have to do now is appreciate the reports
which I sincerely hope will be forthcoming.
I intend to enjoy them fully.
Hey, not all of us are b.....!!!!!!!!.
I personally have no interest ever to meet Susan that does not make me less of a fan I hope...:hiding:
Secrecy bothers me and I do not trust people who engage in it no matter the reason.
I am happy for the 20 fans and I am sure they are having a great time.
Maybe we hear from them maybe we do not maybe that is secret too...Who knows....We see.:biggrin:
Quote:
Originally Posted by Kalua
Ok folks if we want to know how that M&G went, better stop all this.
If I were one of the fans there, only by reading all that has been posted I would run away.
Whatever the reasons for the requested secrecy, what we have to do now is appreciate the reports
which I sincerely hope will be forthcoming.
I intend to enjoy them fully.
Me too, Kalua, but maybe in the morning now,:smiley-rolleyes:
Quote:
Originally Posted by terijay7
As Tink has said, this was done by Susan's PR and Mgt Team contacting people-- beyond that, that is all i will say.
They needed bodies. I do not think they were thinking they were hurting anyone's feelings really. Just my take.
Teri, that's the clearest statement of truth I've read so far today, thank you :love: Richard
Quote:
Originally Posted by UKSusanfanAnn
Yes agree trennie, I apologise for my negativity, was just a bit disappointed but please please everybody post soon as it is getting very late here in the UK, LOL.:biggrin:
You don't have anything to apologize for Ann. You do more for this Forum than many. Everybody has a right to express disappointment.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Retired In Kalifornia
Teri, that's the clearest statement of truth I've read so far today, thank you :love: Richard
well it just seems true. this was not a regular meet and greet. It could have been done better though. But, I can take that up with a person that has nothing to do with this forum for the future.
Quote:
Originally Posted by terijay7
As Tink has said, this was done by Susan's PR and Mgt Team contacting people-- beyond that, that is all i will say.
They needed bodies. I do not think they were thinking they were hurting anyone's feelings really. Just my take.
I think you are right, but I also think they should have given more consideration to the feelings of her other fans. They have alienated a lot of fans, even though unintentionally, by the way they have handled this.
Quote:
Originally Posted by UKSusanfanAnn
Me too, Kalua, but maybe in the morning now,:smiley-rolleyes:
Well. it's only 8pm EST.
Quote:
Originally Posted by trennie
You don't have anything to apologize for Ann. You do more for this Forum than many. Everybody has a right to express disappointment.
:hug: and goodnight, looking forward to reports in the morning, :goodnight:
MY HEART IS RACING, TEARS ARE FLOWING...WOW!!! WHAT GREAT NEWS!!! Our Susan and Andy are the absolute BEST, aren't they?! Imagine...faithful fans who had never had an opportunity to meet Susan in person, finally experienced that JOY of spending quality moments with her, and even had their hotel and meal arrangements comped! SPEAKING OF DREAMS COMING TRUE!
AND, YES, GRITS IS ABSOLUTELY THE BEST OF THE BEST ORGANIZER, AND DEVOUT SUSAFAN. IT WILL BE SO EXCITING TO HEARJUST WHO WAS ABLE TO BE INCLUDED IN THIS GLORIOUS EVENT.
THANKS, PT, FOR SHARING THE JOYOUS NEWS WITH OUR FORUM FAN FAMILY! Hugs, Trish
Quote:
Originally Posted by trennie
Well. it's only 8pm EST.
It's 1am in the UK trennie, I need my beauty sleep, I wish, lol
Randma & GritsT, please post if you ladies can. I see you all are viewing this thread :D:D:D:D:D.
Quote:
Originally Posted by trennie
You don't have anything to apologize for Ann. You do more for this Forum than many. Everybody has a right to express disappointment.
And my post was for those who were disappointed. I feel very sorry for them. For those who were invited it would have been absolutely wonderful.
hoping toreturn a bit later and hear what songs Miss Boyle was singing- my back is in spasms- so blows!!! even with the hot water bottle- sitting is the worst thing in the world for a compressed lumbar disk- makes me mad as a hatter, more so than i can say!
Quote:
Originally Posted by Retired In Kalifornia
"For The Record" I was asked via e-mail by GritsT to attend the M&G some weeks ago, was asked then to keep this confidential. I had to decline because of time contraints & economics. Congratulations to all those who did attend the event. Richard
At least you, of all people should have been invited, and I'm thankful you were, Richard, for you do so much to ferret out Susanews for all of us to enjoy! Thanks for your service to Susan's fan family! We love you!
Quote:
Originally Posted by diane wheldrake
I am thrilled that these 20 people got to see Susan and hear her sing, can't wait for reports. I am also very disturbed by the negative and jealous comments by some of you.
Me too.
Quote:
Originally Posted by trennie
Great news. Glad they had a big group, so we'll have lots of reports. And big cheers to Grits, Randma and Janna for being able to get it all organized on short notice. Never a dull moment in Subo fandom (or at least not for very long).
Yes, I agree...with Grits, Carol, and Janna organizing the gathering, a great time would be guaranteed!
Quote:
Originally Posted by Trish (Pat Pierce)
At least you, of all people should have been invited, and I'm thankful you were, Richard, for you do so much to ferret out Susanews for all of us to enjoy! Thanks for your service to Susan's fan family! We love you!
Me too RIK, I wish you could have gone.
Quote:
Originally Posted by terijay7
well it just seems true. this was not a regular meet and greet. It could have been done better though. But, I can take that up with a person that has nothing to do with this forum for the future.
Teri, I think that Tink and Kalua will also pass it on as well. And perhaps, members of other sites, who had reps there.
Quote:
Originally Posted by trennie
Yes, Teri, that's what they did and where their mistake lay. They treated fans as "bodies" and not as people. Producers may be able to get away with this with Bieber and Swift fans. It's dangerous with the "boomer" cohort.
Calling the fans bodies is insulting, and I do not think Andy decided they needed bodies.
I would like to assume that some of the fans present there were chosen by Susan.
Frankly I'm appaled with this kind of vocabulary, this is not animal farm it is a fansite!!!
Quote:
Originally Posted by kathymc
Me too.
What you both said. There is no reason at all for disappointment and jealousy.
Quote:
Originally Posted by trennie
Yes, Teri, that's what they did and where their mistake lay. They treated fans as "bodies" and not as people. Producers may be able to get away with this with Bieber and Swift fans. It's dangerous with the "boomer" cohort.
Yes, Susan fans are like no other fans. We're not fans of just Susan's music. We are fans of her magic, that has touched us all.
RIK What A GREAT Friend!
Quote:
Originally Posted by bernicer
Me too RIK, I wish you could have gone.
:love2:
Why is it I don't feel like pick of the litter?...lol Come on , we might as well have fun with it all...
Dear Pickled Tink,
Thank you so much my dear Susafriend, for these great News.
I'm so happy for you all and for Susan.
I can't wait to hear more and to have some lovely and funny Pics.
I can imagine Susan talking to Flat Susan.....LOL
Susahugs xxxx :yeewhooooo::yeewhooooo::thanks::thanks::pompom::p ompom:
:Its All Good:
Thanks, Kalua...and I intend to join you in celebration!!!
How blessed we are that those who were so fortunate to attend, will be willing to share their joys with the rest of us. We've been longing for something new and refreshing to celebrate, and now we have their moments to cherish...so let's get on board and enjoy their memories by celebrating with them!!!
AS YOU IMMERSE YOURSELF VICARIOUSLY IN THEIR JOY, SUSAFRIENDS, YOU WILL VICARIOUSLY EXPERIENCE THE JOY YOURSELVES!
I for one, am anxiously awaiting any news about the M & G from Grits and Randma as well as any others who might have been in attendance!!! We have been in a drought for news for soooo long, and new news would "make my day". I will bask in the joy!
Quote:
Originally Posted by andyp
Andy may have been in the business for a long time, but he sure knows how to lose Susafans. This is the second time that he messsed up in my opinion. What a jerk. And please, mods, this is my honest opinion and I am entitled to it. No warnings, please. leave my post up if you are a democracy.
Saying this about Andy seems to me to be showing a complete disrespect for Susan. On this forum one common bond we have all shared is wanting the best for Susan. That has included having Andy as her manager. Susan obviously respects him and his handling of her and her career. I care about Susan's opinion first and foremost.
Mods, given the tone of this thread, is it possible to close this thread & start a new one dedicated to the fans who were there & their reports.
I too have expressed my feelings regarding this, however, I feel maybe it is time this thread is put to bed & we celebrate in the reports we will receive from those who were there. JMHO.
Quote:
Originally Posted by soothed
Why is it I don't feel like pick of the litter?...lol Come on , we might as well have fun with it all...
We can't have you feeling like that soothed! Here - now you ARE the pick of the litter!
http://i56.tinypic.com/2e4wvo6.jpg
:p:p
Thank you Trish. I so agree. We've got great news coming.:Its All Good::Ilovesusan:
Quote:
Originally Posted by CanadianBill
We can't have you feeling like that soothed! Here - now you ARE the pick of the litter!
http://i56.tinypic.com/2e4wvo6.jpg
:p:p
That may even be better than the Susa-Statue of Liberty CBill! big grin
There are 8 of us in a hotel room in NY and we are saddened by the derision on this thread. Please know that I considered it a great honor to be asked to organize this event, I was given very specific instructions, and I did it for Susan.
We had an absolutely wonderful afternoon - it ranks right up there with a wedding and/or the birth of a child!
Susan was in grand form, dressed in jeans and a purple top. Her hair was bobbed, tousled and darling. We welcomed her with a Hello, Susan version of Hello, Dolly and she danced her way into the room. Each fan had special one-on-one time with her. We presented her with flat Susan and an album of fan pictures with fS. We did a bit of line dancing to NY, NY. We were told that Susan WILL be on AGT 8/31! Andy is a gentleman and adores Susan (but you all already know that!)
Susan was relaxed, comfortable, loving and hilarious. If I had my fondest wish granted, it would be that each and all of you could have been there.
QUOTE=GritsT;559710]There are 8 of us in a hotel room in NY and we are saddened by the derision on this thread. Please know that I considered it a great honor to be asked to organize this event, I was given very specific instructions, and I did it for Susan.
We had an absolutely wonderful afternoon - it ranks right up there with a wedding and/or the birth of a child!
Susan was in grand form, dressed in jeans and a purple top. Her hair was bobbed, tousled and darling. We welcomed her with a Hello, Susan version of Hello, Dolly and she danced her way into the room. Each fan had special one-on-one time with her. We presented her with flat Susan and an album of fan pictures with fS. We did a bit of line dancing to NY, NY. We were told that Susan WILL be on AGT 8/31! Andy is a gentleman and adores Susan (but you all already know that!)
Susan was relaxed, comfortable, loving and hilarious. If I had my fondest wish granted, it would be that each and all of you could have been there.[/QUOTE]
Thanks for the report GritsT. I am so glad to hear it was a spectacular experience for all!
:Ilovesusan::susanrocks:[
Quote:
Originally Posted by CanadianBill
We can't have you feeling like that soothed! Here - now you ARE the pick of the litter!
http://i56.tinypic.com/2e4wvo6.jpg
:p:p
HAHAHAHAHA....Okay, who is the guy? You? lol
Quote:
Originally Posted by GritsT
There are 8 of us in a hotel room in NY and we are saddened by the derision on this thread. Please know that I considered it a great honor to be asked to organize this event, I was given very specific instructions, and I did it for Susan.
We had an absolutely wonderful afternoon - it ranks right up there with a wedding and/or the birth of a child!
Susan was in grand form, dressed in jeans and a purple top. Her hair was bobbed, tousled and darling. We welcomed her with a Hello, Susan version of Hello, Dolly and she danced her way into the room. Each fan had special one-on-one time with her. We presented her with flat Susan and an album of fan pictures with fS. We did a bit of line dancing to NY, NY. We were told that Susan WILL be on AGT 8/31! Andy is a gentleman and adores Susan (but you all already know that!)
Susan was relaxed, comfortable, loving and hilarious. If I had my fondest wish granted, it would be that each and all of you could have been there.
Wonderful!!!!!! Can't wait to hear more! I am so thrilled that you all were there to meet Susan!
http://i35.photobucket.com/albums/d1...255Fwaving.gifGRITST, RANDMA !!
Please http://i683.photobucket.com/albums/v.../praying-1.gif pics .. or ....ANYTHING http://i683.photobucket.com/albums/v...ileys/pray.gif
Ok I see Grits have posted. Thank you !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! :thankyou::kisses::bighug:
Boy, I have been insulted BIG TIME....but I can take it..
Quote:
Originally Posted by soothed
HAHAHAHAHA....Okay, who is the guy? You? lol
No, just a googled image to make you 'ha ha':biggrin:
:
Quote:
Originally Posted by soothed
Why is it I don't feel like pick of the litter?...lol Come on , we might as well have fun with it all...
Quote:
Originally Posted by CanadianBill
We can't have you feeling like that soothed! Here - now you ARE the pick of the litter!
http://i56.tinypic.com/2e4wvo6.jpg
:p:p
:rofl::rofl::rofl: Thanks Soothed and CB.
Quote:
Originally Posted by GritsT
There are 8 of us in a hotel room in NY and we are saddened by the derision on this thread. Please know that I considered it a great honor to be asked to organize this event, I was given very specific instructions, and I did it for Susan.
We had an absolutely wonderful afternoon - it ranks right up there with a wedding and/or the birth of a child!
Susan was in grand form, dressed in jeans and a purple top. Her hair was bobbed, tousled and darling. We welcomed her with a Hello, Susan version of Hello, Dolly and she danced her way into the room. Each fan had special one-on-one time with her. We presented her with flat Susan and an album of fan pictures with fS. We did a bit of line dancing to NY, NY. We were told that Susan WILL be on AGT 8/31! Andy is a gentleman and adores Susan (but you all already know that!)
Susan was relaxed, comfortable, loving and hilarious. If I had my fondest wish granted, it would be that each and all of you could have been there.
Great fun, Grits!! So glad to hear Susan has plans for AGT. Hopefully that means we'll have something from the new album. Whatever you can share, please do. Whatever you can't, well there is always a reason. So glad you had the time together. Time now for show and tell!:biggrin:
Calling all Lucky 20 from the M&G! I am sitting here waiting patiently for your reports. I HAVE to ask, "Did any of you find out what kind of perfume Susan wears? Is her favorite color still at this moment PINK? Did your breath catch when she walked into the room? How long was it before you could breath again? Please give us a report of your emotions on how you felt when you saw her....Please dont leave out any details!... :D Im waiting for your report! And while your writing it all up and giving us all the details you can remember I will just amuse myself by doing this :fan_too_fast:
Grits, since this function was held in New York, did you make any effort to invite people from that area? If I were from that area, I would feel really excluded if I were not invited?
If anyone is wondering where Susan is now, there is this tweet=
Got chance to chat with Susan Boyle over afternoon tea in JFK airport , very humble, nice and inspiring lady
2 hours ago
Apparently Susan has left NYC. East or west?
Quote:
Originally Posted by skye
If anyone is wondering where Susan is now, there is this tweet=
Got chance to chat with Susan Boyle over afternoon tea in JFK airport , very humble, nice and inspiring lady
2 hours ago
Apparently Susan has left NYC. East or west?
Hey, North would be nice! :biggrin:
GritsT, Thank you for helping make this a great time for Susan in NYC. Your time and effort is much appreciated.
I think I pretty much speak for all of us on that. Susan feels a special connection to us as fans because of wonderful fans like yourself. Thanks again. PS Glad "Flat Susan" came out of retirement. Wouldn't be the same without her.:biggrin:
Quote:
Originally Posted by GritsT
There are 8 of us in a hotel room in NY and we are saddened by the derision on this thread. Please know that I considered it a great honor to be asked to organize this event, I was given very specific instructions, and I did it for Susan.
We had an absolutely wonderful afternoon - it ranks right up there with a wedding and/or the birth of a child!
Susan was in grand form, dressed in jeans and a purple top. Her hair was bobbed, tousled and darling. We welcomed her with a Hello, Susan version of Hello, Dolly and she danced her way into the room. Each fan had special one-on-one time with her. We presented her with flat Susan and an album of fan pictures with fS. We did a bit of line dancing to NY, NY. We were told that Susan WILL be on AGT 8/31! Andy is a gentleman and adores Susan (but you all already know that!)
Susan was relaxed, comfortable, loving and hilarious. If I had my fondest wish granted, it would be that each and all of you could have been there.
Grits I am sure you and you friends understand why some fans who love Susan dearly are upset..?
It is always easier to be on the inside than looking in.
Thank you for your little report. I am happy for you that your dream has come true .
I am happy for all of you..:love2:
Andy, Susan and Andy Stephens are joined at the hip, at least as far as business is concerned. They are the co-Directors of her LLC and their incomes depend on each other. More than that, personally, they have been through the stressful early months of Susan's career when she was still finding her feet in a tumultuous new world. Andy may or may not make mistakes, even experienced people do, but I would lay bets that nothing will separate them during Susan's career. They have been forged in the fire.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Little Lulu
I am glad Susan takes the time to connect with her fans. I feel lucky just to be involved long distance. Isn't it wonderful that our Fan Site has wonderful ladies that Susan likes enough to want to see them again and again. That says a lot about those fans and our Fan site as a whole. I thank my lucky stars that I joined and feel apart of it all. You have to remember that they do it the best way possible for Susan not us.
This is how I feel about this too. Thank you Lulu for saying it so well. I hope everyone had a wonderful time.
Quote:
Originally Posted by trennie
Andy, Susan and Andy Stephens are joined at the hip, at least as far as business is concerned. They are the co-Directors of her LLC and their incomes depend on each other. More than that, personally, they have been through the stressful early months of Susan's career when she was still finding her feet in a tumultuous new world. Andy may or may not make mistakes, even experienced people do, but I would lay bets that nothing will separate them during Susan's career. They have been forged in the fire.
I know all that Trennie, and as of today I have zero respect for Andy. Just sayin. I haven't lost my interest in Susan.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Little Lulu
Yes, this whole thing may have been dictated by "higher ups" and Susan and Andy hadn't much say. Except for asking for some familiar faces for Susan, to help with those other unfamiliar faces. I say it looks like Susan is getting PROMOTION and THAT is something WE ALL have been wanting. So, :Its All Good:
I think you've got it right, LuLu.
Hi Grits and all you other :potofgold::devilcostume: :biggrin:
Is the AGT going to be performed LIVE by Susan on 8/31?!!
Thank you, Grits...it was very kind of you to report to us.
Quote:
Originally Posted by GritsT
There are 8 of us in a hotel room in NY and we are saddened by the derision on this thread. Please know that I considered it a great honor to be asked to organize this event, I was given very specific instructions, and I did it for Susan.
We had an absolutely wonderful afternoon - it ranks right up there with a wedding and/or the birth of a child!
Susan was in grand form, dressed in jeans and a purple top. Her hair was bobbed, tousled and darling. We welcomed her with a Hello, Susan version of Hello, Dolly and she danced her way into the room. Each fan had special one-on-one time with her. We presented her with flat Susan and an album of fan pictures with fS. We did a bit of line dancing to NY, NY. We were told that Susan WILL be on AGT 8/31! Andy is a gentleman and adores Susan (but you all already know that!)
Susan was relaxed, comfortable, loving and hilarious. If I had my fondest wish granted, it would be that each and all of you could have been there.
Quote:
Originally Posted by andyp
I know all that Trennie, and as of today I have zero respect for Andy. Just sayin. I haven't lost my interest in Susan.
Well, Andy, that's the main thing. Susan counts. This other stuff doesn't.
Quote:
Originally Posted by GritsT
There are 8 of us in a hotel room in NY and we are saddened by the derision on this thread. Please know that I considered it a great honor to be asked to organize this event, I was given very specific instructions, and I did it for Susan.
We had an absolutely wonderful afternoon - it ranks right up there with a wedding and/or the birth of a child!
Susan was in grand form, dressed in jeans and a purple top. Her hair was bobbed, tousled and darling. We welcomed her with a Hello, Susan version of Hello, Dolly and she danced her way into the room. Each fan had special one-on-one time with her. We presented her with flat Susan and an album of fan pictures with fS. We did a bit of line dancing to NY, NY. We were told that Susan WILL be on AGT 8/31! Andy is a gentleman and adores Susan (but you all already know that!)
Susan was relaxed, comfortable, loving and hilarious. If I had my fondest wish granted, it would be that each and all of you could have been there.
I don't think it is derision jeanine- it is the fact that this is a forum of fans and it has been real quiet in a month since China, and something like this was going on behind the scenes- if you were in their shoes- those who faithfully click here daily ( not me as i have been almost AWOL for the month with this wicked injury from my fall)
And then they are kind of surprised- they are expressing why. That is not derision-I am glad to hear Miss B was in good form, and of course, we know Andy adores her- that goes without saying.
What songs besides "Hello Dolly"did she sing?
P.S when i used the word "bodies" i meant fans- fans to show up in NYC quickly for something that was not a normal M & G. I think folks are confused thiking they were left out of a normal M & g, which this does not sound like it was.....
Quote:
Originally Posted by jclar
I am wondering that too.
Me too!
Quote:
Originally Posted by Pickled Tink
I can think of 20 folk right now who on reading this thread will be getting that kick in the stomach feeling and quite frankly they should not be!!!
They ABSOLUTELY should NOT BE, you are so correct, Pickled Tink!!!
And, to the FORTUNATE 20, I urge you to share your joy freely, for there will always be those who try to discount and rob someone else of their JOY, as they focus upon the negatives and try to dump unearned GUILT upon the shoulders of those who have JOY TO SHARE. It's the old "I'm not feeling OK, so don't want you to feel OK either!" syndrome.
Each of us has a choice...to be ruled by jealousy or bitterness, or to celebrate the JOY OTHERS EXPERIENCED WITH SUSAN, and SHE EXPERIENCED WITH THEM. Let's not forget to focus upon that. This was Susan's need...and Susan's request. Let's show our love for Susan by honoring that.
Reflect back to those BGT TOUR video clips we treasured so deeply. Were they professional films? NO...but did we wait eagerly for each precious contribution??? YOU BET WE DID, and I still enjoy those video clips from long ago. Did we, in those days complain about those who lived in the region, and were fortunate to attend those BGT TOUR CONCERTS? Not that I can recall. We just thrilled that Susan had an audience who loved her, and with whom she so lovingly interacted as she performed.
Rather than focusing upon ourselves, let's focus upon the joy that Susan experienced, in having one more opportunity to spend a few moments of quality time with fans she had never met before. How special it is, that her heart cares to personally bond with her fans. And, rejoice with those who were blessed by personal moments with her.
At the beginning, we fans freely shared our memories and photos from fan gatherings, and those who were blessed to travel abroad, to Susan's events, also shared their photos and memories. If we want that joy to continue, we must not attack those who share with us. Whatever happened to the concepts of "graciousness" and "gratitude"? Love knows how to rejoice in another's joy. And, if we lose sight of that, we will all be losers...including our beloved Susan.
Thanks for the report GritsT - I do love the visual of the fans singing Susan into the room! In fact one of my favorite past fan memories is when fans sang her out of the airport in Nov/2010 singing 'New York, New York' - that was such a great sight and Susan seemed to really enjoy it! Glad you all had a grand time!
Quote:
Originally Posted by Pasett1
Thank you, Grits...it was very kind of you to report to us.
Did anybody get a pic of the "bobbed, tousled hair? That sounds like something new.
Thank you Trish. Well I'm now going to bed because it seems nobody else is going to report back to us and I'm not surprised. So sad.
Quote:
Originally Posted by jclar
I wish that her management could arrange a meet and greet that is not secret. There was a mention of scheduling one once, but it was in Las Vegas, and I think there was not enough interest although that is hard to imagine. Or course, her management does what they think is best for Susan, and her time in the US is valuable. Glad she got to do something fun.
WEll, jclar, maybe Susan will come to NYC again this fall and be on theToday show again... and maybe she will come to the brunch this time ... and maybe some of us will get the opportunity then to at least have the opportunity to meet her. We can hope so, anyway.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Trish (Pat Pierce)
They ABSOLUTELY should NOT BE, you are so correct, Pickled Tink!!!
And, to the FORTUNATE 20, I urge you to share your joy freely, for there will always be those who try to discount and rob someone else of their JOY, as they focus upon the negatives and try to dump unearned GUILT upon the shoulders of those who have JOY TO SHARE. It's the old "I'm not feeling OK, so don't want you to feel OK either!" syndrome.
Each of us has a choice...to be ruled by jealousy or bitterness, or to celebrate the JOY OTHERS EXPERIENCED WITH SUSAN, and SHE EXPERIENCED WITH THEM. Let's not forget to focus upon that. This was Susan's need...and Susan's request. Let's show our love for Susan by honoring that.
Reflect back to those BGT TOUR video clips we treasured so deeply. Were they professional films? NO...but did we wait eagerly for each precious contribution??? YOU BET WE DID, and I still enjoy those video clips from long ago. Did we, in those days complain about those who lived in the region, and were fortunate to attend those BGT TOUR CONCERTS? Not that I can recall. We just thrilled that Susan had an audience who loved her, and with whom she so lovingly interacted as she performed.
Rather than focusing upon ourselves, let's focus upon the joy that Susan experienced, in having one more opportunity to spend a few moments of quality time with fans she had never met before. How special it is, that her heart cares to personally bond with her fans. And, rejoice with those who were blessed by personal moments with her.
At the beginning, we fans freely shared our memories and photos from fan gatherings, and those who were blessed to travel abroad, to Susan's events, also shared their photos and memories. If we want that joy to continue, we must not attack those who share with us. Whatever happened to the concepts of "graciousness" and "gratitude"? Love knows how to rejoice in another's joy. And, of we lose sight of that, we will all be losers...including our beloved Susan.
I think, Trish, that's what we're waiting for, to be shared with about Susan. It's nice to hear this first report from Grits, but I hope more is forthcoming from the others, who were privileged to be there.
Quote:
Originally Posted by CanadianBill
Thanks for the report GritsT - I do love the visual of the fans singing Susan into the room! In fact one of my favorite past fan memories is when fans sang her out of the airport in Nov/2010 singing 'New York, New York' - that was such a great sight and Susan seemed to really enjoy it! Glad you all had a grand time!
That was a lot of fun. Like an old movie...made the news, too.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Trish (Pat Pierce)
They ABSOLUTELY should NOT BE, you are so correct, Pickled Tink!!!
And, to the FORTUNATE 20, I urge you to share your joy freely, for there will always be those who try to discount and rob someone else of their JOY, as they focus upon the negatives and try to dump unearned GUILT upon the shoulders of those who have JOY TO SHARE. It's the old "I'm not feeling OK, so don't want you to feel OK either!" syndrome.
Each of us has a choice...to be ruled by jealousy or bitterness, or to celebrate the JOY OTHERS EXPERIENCED WITH SUSAN, and SHE EXPERIENCED WITH THEM. Let's not forget to focus upon that. This was Susan's need...and Susan's request. Let's show our love for Susan by honoring that.
Reflect back to those BGT TOUR video clips we treasured so deeply. Were they professional films? NO...but did we wait eagerly for each precious contribution??? YOU BET WE DID, and I still enjoy those video clips from long ago. Did we, in those days complain about those who lived in the region, and were fortunate to attend those BGT TOUR CONCERTS? Not that I can recall. We just thrilled that Susan had an audience who loved her, and with whom she so lovingly interacted as she performed.
Rather than focusing upon ourselves, let's focus upon the joy that Susan experienced, in having one more opportunity to spend a few moments of quality time with fans she had never met before. How special it is, that her heart cares to personally bond with her fans. And, rejoice with those who were blessed by personal moments with her.
At the beginning, we fans freely shared our memories and photos from fan gatherings, and those who were blessed to travel abroad, to Susan's events, also shared their photos and memories. If we want that joy to continue, we must not attack those who share with us. Whatever happened to the concepts of "graciousness" and "gratitude"? Love knows how to rejoice in another's joy. And, of we lose sight of that, we will all be losers...including our beloved Susan.
So well said Trish! None of this devisiveness has accomplished anything but a deep sadness on the forum at a time when we should be jumping for joy with news of Susan! Let us embrace those who were fortunate to be at the M & G today and welcome any information as we all did at the beginning of Susan's journey! Be happy for Susan who has been on a whirlwind for the past two years.. accomplishing things she could only dream about. This forum has one primary purpose: to support Susan!! Thank goodness for the fans who are able to bring us the news we so fervently seek!:grouphug:
Quote:
Originally Posted by Helen101
And my post was for those who were disappointed. I feel very sorry for them. For those who were invited it would have been absolutely wonderful.
Disappointment is part of life. If we were fans of anyone except Susan noone would ever have a chance to meet her. It's because of Susan and her team that so many fans have had that opportunity. It can't be easy for Susan and her team to manage that but they do. We have no idea what it is like to be in their shoes and we just have to trust they are doing the best they can even if it isn't done the way WE would do it. So let's all put on our big girl (boy) panties and act like grown ups and celebrate all things Susan!!!!!!!! Especially her new up and coming CD!!! Whoop, whoop!!!!!!!!
<<from Grits: Susan was relaxed, comfortable, loving and hilarious. If I had my fondest wish granted, it would be that each and all of you could have been there.>>
Great description of Susan, especially "loving and hilarious"! I often think of Susan that way and feel that is part of her charm. And your wish is taken in by many of us I'm sure... :love:
I'm at work and read the first post awhile ago and then came back and read through just now.
First of all, kudos to Randma, GritsT, and Janna for whatever organizational role they played. I'm delighted for all who got to attend. I'm excited to learn of the purpose of the M&G. I would love to hear more from those who attended (whatever they're allowed to say).
I also think it would be good idea to start a new, positive thread for attendees who are willing to share.
I just have to put my oar in the water and say that I am delighted for those who got to go. One said it was like the day of giving birth or a wedding. I totally get that. That's how I felt when I saw Susan sing in New York last Nov. from the front row. What a thrill. As long as I live it will be one of the highlights of my life. So be blessed my Susan-fan friends and enjoy your wonderful memories. :cloud: I love the part about Susan dancing into the room as they sang her in. I love her spirit. I think it's great that Susan and Andy and whoever else decided, that fans were even included inthis way - at all. If we get too cranky and devisive such things could not happen in the future if they determine that it causes problems. So I say :party: I am so happy for all of you who got to go and had a chance to show Susan by your love just how special she is. :Ilovesusan: I could never begrudge anyone such joy.
Quote:
Originally Posted by trennie
...it's a mistake to give the impression, wrongly I'm sure, that there is an "inner circle" of select fans, privy to secret information.
It would help if the folks, who were there, would get on the stick and report. As chosen representatives of Subo Fandom they are privileged but timely reporting is also the responsibility.
Yes!
Quote:
Originally Posted by GritsT
There are 8 of us in a hotel room in NY and we are saddened by the derision on this thread. Please know that I considered it a great honor to be asked to organize this event, I was given very specific instructions, and I did it for Susan.
We had an absolutely wonderful afternoon - it ranks right up there with a wedding and/or the birth of a child!
Susan was in grand form, dressed in jeans and a purple top. Her hair was bobbed, tousled and darling. We welcomed her with a Hello, Susan version of Hello, Dolly and she danced her way into the room. Each fan had special one-on-one time with her. We presented her with flat Susan and an album of fan pictures with fS. We did a bit of line dancing to NY, NY. We were told that Susan WILL be on AGT 8/31! Andy is a gentleman and adores Susan (but you all already know that!)
Susan was relaxed, comfortable, loving and hilarious. If I had my fondest wish granted, it would be that each and all of you could have been there.
Hugs to you, Grits, for taking the time to share such wonderful details with our eager hearts. You surely must be exhausted, and yet TOOK THE TIME TO SAY HELLO AND SHARE THE JOY YOU EXPERIENCED WITH SUSAN. Love, Trish
Thanks Trish. You said it all.
Thanks GritsT for the first report. So happy that the M&G was wonderful. I am so happy for you.
Quote:
Originally Posted by kathymc
Me too.
I can surely understand why the news is slow in coming. If I had been one of the twenty, I wouldn't want anyone here to know. Sure wouldn't want them jealous of me. However, maybe you can get past it and share more with us that you experienced in that wonderful meeting with Susan and her team. Most of us would be ashamed to admit we were disappointed or jealous, ( if we were) but a few folks seem to have to jump up and down and act like little children.
Please let part of this thread run like water off a duck's back, as most of us are so happy you represented us and helped Susan do what she is here to do.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Pickled Tink
Whilst I understand that everyone wants to know how or why the people who attended got to go. Can I make the following points. This was not a forum meet and greet, there may be a lot of things we are not privy to and which they do not yet want us to know, they have their reasons, and we should respect them. So, maybe some of the comments and questions are perhaps not helpful. It is understandable that everyone wants to be there etc... .However, Susan has MILLIONS of fans and if there was a meet and greet every single day for the next ten years she could not meet them all. It's just not practicable. Yes of course everyone wants to meet her. Some of us have been very very lucky and we know that. Some have not been and I so wish that more folk had been. I also know that more folk will be in the future.
But can I ask you for for a few minutes to put yourselves in the shoes of those who have met Susan today. They have just had the time of their lives; they will be excited, over the moon, and just itching to share their news. They will come to the forum and what will they see? Posts which quite frankly seem a little resentful that some were chosen and they were not. How would you feel if that were you? There will always be someone who will be disappointed whatever criteria are used. But surely it is not too much to be happy that others got this opportunity and that they are willing to share it with you?
Amen to that. I think it's impossible to have Susan in a large mob of people. There are security issues and it could be very daunting (as the Brits say), to have a whole swarm of people wanting her time. So they did what they could and they didn't have to do any of it. I am THRILLED for those who attended and will be further THRILLED to hear about it. Wonderful - just wonderful.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Kalua
Calling the fans bodies is insulting, and I do not think Andy decided they needed bodies.
I would like to assume that some of the fans present there were chosen by Susan.
Frankly I'm appaled with this kind of vocabulary, this is not animal farm it is a fansite!!!
"All animals are equal, but some animals are more equal than others." George Orwell, Animal Farm
Since words fail me right now, I'll let George Orwell speak for me.
I am SO happy for the 20 that got to go to the Meet and Greet with Susan:) I know all of you have got to be on cloud 9 and thanks so much to GritsT for your report:) As all of you know Susan is such a special lady, she deserves the very best:D I can't get enough of her singing and wanting to know more about her!!! Can't wait for her third CD to come out!!! Can't wait for AGT appearance:D:D:D
Quote:
Originally Posted by Linda Sharon
I just have to put my oar in the water and say that I am delighted for those who got to go. One said it was like the day of giving birth or a wedding. I totally get that. That's how I felt when I saw Susan sing in New York last Nov. from the front row. What a thrill. As long as I live it will be one of the highlights of my life. So be blessed my Susan-fan friends and enjoy your wonderful memories. :cloud: I love the part about Susan dancing into the room as they sang her in. I love her spirit. I think it's great that Susan and Andy and whoever else decided, that fans were even included inthis way - at all. If we get too cranky and devisive such things could not happen in the future if they determine that it causes problems. So I say :party: I am so happy for all of you who got to go and had a chance to show Susan by your love just how special she is. :Ilovesusan: I could never begrudge anyone such joy.
I am with you in your feelings Linda Sharon. I hope the lucky 20 are on cloud nine right now and when they come back down to earth I hope we hear more details and get pictures.
What exciting news to hear that Susan was able to meet fans in New York. I'm sure this must have been a special highlight for Susan of her visit to New York. I can't wait to hear all the reports.
I was thinking as I looked at the photograph of Susan taken at the restaurant, how extraordinary that a lady who has lived her life in a small village in Scotland would be recognized by so many as she walked down the street in New York. It is amazing how much has taken place in her life in a little over two years and I hope she is enjoying it tremendously.
As far as I can see, He only lost one.:p
Quote:
Originally Posted by retiredgran
I am with you in your feelings Linda Sharon. I hope the lucky 20 are on cloud nine right now and when they come back down to earth I hope we hear more details and get pictures.
Thanks hon. Hope to see you soon at one of our T.O. get togethers. hugs...
Quote:
Originally Posted by TxTammy
I feel sorry for those living in New York and are great fans of Susan. They must be hurting "just a little."
I would guess more than "a little."
I'm thrilled that Susan undoubtedly had a great time. I doubt she met anyone she hadn't met before. I'm glad it went well and I congratulate everyone who put this together for what seems like a successful event.
Quote:
Originally Posted by sugar puddin
As far as I can see, He only lost one.:p
:laught2:
Quote:
Originally Posted by Linda Sharon
I just have to put my oar in the water and say that I am delighted for those who got to go. One said it was like the day of giving birth or a wedding. I totally get that. That's how I felt when I saw Susan sing in New York last Nov. from the front row. What a thrill. As long as I live it will be one of the highlights of my life. So be blessed my Susan-fan friends and enjoy your wonderful memories. :cloud: I love the part about Susan dancing into the room as they sang her in. I love her spirit. I think it's great that Susan and Andy and whoever else decided, that fans were even included inthis way - at all. If we get too cranky and devisive such things could not happen in the future if they determine that it causes problems. So I say :party: I am so happy for all of you who got to go and had a chance to show Susan by your love just how special she is. :Ilovesusan: I could never begrudge anyone such joy.
Beautifully said, Linda. I also loved what Grits reported about Susan dancing into the room as they sang. Shows that she was relaxed and enjoying herself. That's what we all want for Susan. It matters not (to me) who got to go, as long as this fansite was represented.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Henny
I can surely understand why the news is slow in coming. If I had been one of the twenty, I wouldn't want anyone here to know. Sure wouldn't want them jealous of me. However, maybe you can get past it and share more with us that you experienced in that wonderful meeting with Susan and her team. Most of us would be ashamed to admit we were disappointed or jealous, ( if we were) but a few folks seem to have to jump up and down and act like little children.
Please let part of this thread run like water off a duck's back, as most of us are so happy you represented us and helped Susan do what she is here to do.
Agree so much. Please don't punish the 98% of us who are thrilled for you and desperate to hear what happened and see pictures, because thre are 2% who are childish and jealous and want to spoil the fun.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Retired In Kalifornia
Bern, TRUST ME, if I could had been able to "share my slot" after declinging the offer to attend the first person I'd ask to go would be SusaFan Lorias as she's my Fans For Susan Boyle Websites "boss" and a good friend. Lori has number of disabilities, I'd do anything short of carrying her on my back to NYC from Indiana for her to see Susan. I'll glady give up my "slot" for anybody else, including transporting any fan between Cameron Park to CBS Television City within reasonable distance from California State Route 99 to see Susan perform on AGT - if she indeed does - late this month or next for free, including paying for overnight lodging if we couldn't make it a day trip. I'd offered last year to do something like this to see Susan at AGT & DWTS BTW.
You are one gentleman, RIK!
Quote:
Originally Posted by lcmdom
Disappointment is part of life. If we were fans of anyone except Susan noone would ever have a chance to meet her. It's because of Susan and her team that so many fans have had that opportunity. It can't be easy for Susan and her team to manage that but they do. We have no idea what it is like to be in their shoes and we just have to trust they are doing the best they can even if it isn't done the way WE would do it. So let's all put on our big girl (boy) panties and act like grown ups and celebrate all things Susan!!!!!!!! Especially her new up and coming CD!!! Whoop, whoop!!!!!!!!
Just a little hard to do when we have been treated like children.
RIK Will Susan Be Taped BEFORE AGT Or Live?
Quote:
Originally Posted by GritsT
There are 8 of us in a hotel room in NY and we are saddened by the derision on this thread. Please know that I considered it a great honor to be asked to organize this event, I was given very specific instructions, and I did it for Susan.
We had an absolutely wonderful afternoon - it ranks right up there with a wedding and/or the birth of a child!
Susan was in grand form, dressed in jeans and a purple top. Her hair was bobbed, tousled and darling. We welcomed her with a Hello, Susan version of Hello, Dolly and she danced her way into the room. Each fan had special one-on-one time with her. We presented her with flat Susan and an album of fan pictures with fS. We did a bit of line dancing to NY, NY. We were told that Susan WILL be on AGT 8/31! Andy is a gentleman and adores Susan (but you all already know that!)
Susan was relaxed, comfortable, loving and hilarious. If I had my fondest wish granted, it would be that each and all of you could have been there.
If she will be taped I'll likely have to leave Cameron Park around 11:30 p.m. the 30th IF there is A.M. taping, haven't done all-night drive in years - ugh!
RIK Awww...
Quote:
Originally Posted by Marie Jean
You are one gentleman, RIK!
:love2:
Well said Linda, my feelings exactly so happy for the very lucky people who got to meet Susan and delighted that Susan enjoyed herself and had fun.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Linda Sharon
I just have to put my oar in the water and say that I am delighted for those who got to go. One said it was like the day of giving birth or a wedding. I totally get that. That's how I felt when I saw Susan sing in New York last Nov. from the front row. What a thrill. As long as I live it will be one of the highlights of my life. So be blessed my Susan-fan friends and enjoy your wonderful memories. :cloud: I love the part about Susan dancing into the room as they sang her in. I love her spirit. I think it's great that Susan and Andy and whoever else decided, that fans were even included inthis way - at all. If we get too cranky and devisive such things could not happen in the future if they determine that it causes problems. So I say :party: I am so happy for all of you who got to go and had a chance to show Susan by your love just how special she is. :Ilovesusan: I could never begrudge anyone such joy.
Grits can you tell us who the lucky 20 were today?
Quote:
Originally Posted by Marie Jean
You are one gentleman, RIK!
He certainly is isnt he? :D
Grits, I see you are on here now. Please give us a little more info if you can. You can see there are 91 on this thread, and almost all are waiting hopefully for a bit more info.
I am dying to hear about the new songs Susan sang,are you allowed to share any details?
Quote:
Originally Posted by andyp
Andy may have been in the business for a long time, but he sure knows how to lose Susafans. This is the second time that he messsed up in my opinion. What a jerk. And please, mods, this is my honest opinion and I am entitled to it. No warnings, please. leave my post up if you are a democracy.
I find this post to be quite offensive on so many levels. You are of course entitled to your opinion, however, name calling is never appropriate. Stating that this forum is not a democracy if your rude comment is removed, is certainly threatening. Susan and her team have every right to do what they want and how they want, what the motives of their actions are, is quite frankly none of our business.
You have asked that you not be given warnings, I am sorry that I will not be able to comply with your request. You will be getting a PM from me shortly. You have violated Rule1 by not showing respect for Susan and her team and have violated and rule 2.
Thanks Grits sounds like yall had a great time with Susan. What were the songs yall heard from the CD?
Even though I doubt I could hop on a plane and get to NYC if it was an open invitation (and I am hardly ever jelous of others' good fortune), I do feel alienated from those who were able to pick and choose their acquaintances to go to this exclusive M&G. That said it was Susan and her management's decision and those involved made the best of it. I just don't like those who know Susan quite well telling me how I should view this M&G. Of course, I will be looking for all the reports and photos but wish the M&G had not been so very exclusive.
Quote:
Originally Posted by andyp
The Susan team are not doing themselves any favourites. They are alienating fans.
Does anyone know of any other female star that arranges these meet and greets with fans? I think Susan and her team are absolutely wonderful for accomodating these gatherings. Susan is a unique artist with a unique relationship with her fans. I wrote Susan a letter a while back and told her that it is simply love that binds all of us to her.:love2:
Thanks so much for the report Grits .Sounds like it was a blast.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Anniev
I find this post to be quite offensive on so many levels. You are of course entitled to your opinion, however, name calling is never appropriate. Stating that this forum is not a democracy if your rude comment is removed, is certainly threatening. Susan and her team have every right to do what they want and how they want, what the motives of their actions are, is quite frankly none of our business.
You have asked that you not be given warnings, I am sorry that I will not be able to comply with your request. You will be getting a PM from me shortly. You have violated Rule1 by not showing respect for Susan and her team and have violated and rule 2.
Should not this post have been done by PM? " 1. First warning - No sanctions, but a PM reminder of the rules and notification of warning." This quote comes directly from the Rules for Forum Sanctions.
Whew! I’m sure you all realize that no one who was there would post until they had read through all 24 pages of this thread first, and that takes time. Besides which I’ve been out for a family obligation and just got home.
I was one of the lucky, lucky, lucky ones! From the moment I got the message about it I have alternated between complete delirium/excitement and serious misgivings and worry about how the news would eventually be received on the forum. I know very well that if I had not been so fortunate this time I would have felt at least a twinge of envy and asked “why not me?” But then I would have to know that it appeared to be random, as I haven’t done anything to curry favor with anybody. So in the end, coming up with 20 people out of – gosh, how many are we in all? – was bound to cause disappointment among the remaining hundreds of fans. But believe me, we all had anxiety about how everyone else would feel. Then there were the many close friendships between some of the 20 and others on the forum. The first thing we would want to do is to share our news, but not one of us did, to my knowledge, because a promise is a promise. I absolutely believe Susan’s team – and it might have even come from beyond her team, although I’m not privy to all the information – had strong reasons for imposing a “gag” order about this. They are actually very conscient of Susan’s fans, believe it or not. Having seen Andy today, I’m more admiring of him than ever!
Having said that, I’ll say that GritsT’s initial description captures the essence of the event very well. Susan had been somewhere else this morning – and again, I have no idea where, nor did we ask – so we weren’t sure exactly when she would arrive. NYC traffic is unpredictable. So we ate quickly and waited. I have to admit to having a little trouble breathing when they said she was coming up the stairs. When you have seen her so many times on videos, the prospect of being in the same room is, well, kind of unreal. And what others have said in the past is true: seeing her in person is different. She has an aura that draws people to her; you can feel it. She was pretty casually dressed, and her hair was in her natural tousled curls. But it’s hard to focus on anything but her personality, as she hams it up, laughs and gives us all her energy. All the facial expressions we have seen over time come out in rapid succession. So fast that when you think you’re taking a picture of one, by the time the flash goes off, she’s on to another. She loves to clown.
We were all told we would have 3 minutes to sit with her one-on-one. But unbeknownst to us, she had not yet had lunch, so we waited while she ordered and gulped down a quick bite, along with Andy, Joanne, and others with her. As a result, I’m not sure, but I think in the end our time was shortened to 2 minutes. I say I’m not sure, because in the moment, things become a bit of a blur, and I’m not really sure about anything. Anyhow, while each person was with her, dozens of others were watching and taking pictures. Whatever I might have thought I would say to her, I pretty much forgot it when the moment came, but I guess I said something, and she was, of course, sweet and gracious. I can’t imagine how she can hold up under meeting with so many people she doesn’t know.
Then Andy gave us the extreme joy of hearing a sample from the new album (no, Susan did not sing for us), although he emphasized that it was still a work in progress and had not had the mixing completed. We were actually able to give our reaction to one song, which was: absolutely beautiful, but we want less orchestra and more Susan!! Sound familiar? He assured us that would still be adjusted. Unfortunately, and this will probably cause more cataclysmic reactions, Sony insists absolutely that the title not be revealed until they put it out officially. But you will know one quite soon, because Susan is going to sing it on AGT.
OK, I rushed to write some of this now, since I know you’re wanting to hear more about what went on. Some of those attending are on their way home and can't post yet. Some don't have access to computers yet. I know there will be pictures, but I'm not proficient at that.
I sincerely thank those of you who are being understanding of this event. If you are thinking it’s daunting to post about it after reading some bitterness, you are right. I feel like hiding under a couch. In addition, I will need some serious time to decompress. I know for sure if there is another occasion, it will be another group entirely, and you’ll have your turn. To anyone feeling really bad, I understand, but I hope you can wait, as PT advised, until more is known about the purpose of the event and the reasons behind it before jumping to negative conclusions. Susan is an absolute angel, and she has the strongest defender in the world in Andy. That makes me very happy.
Hello, folks, I am not at my usual computer but am at my son's place in NY, after being "1 of the 20" who shared a spectacular time with Susan today. I have lots of photos, but haven't had a chance to download and upload my downloads! I'll do that when I return on the 26th.
In the spirit of love and joy I want to share with you the extraordinary graciousness extended to all of us by Andy and Susan, Joanna and others who came with them to New York. The rooms were very small in St. Andrews Restaurant. When I went to check out the place Friday evening, I had to ask several people where the "private reserved room" was. Nobody had a clue that Susan was coming. Not the bartender; not the waitress; not even the manager. The manager knew that someone "important" was coming but they did not know who. Let me explain that this restaurant had a door as well as a huge double door which was fully open to the sidewalk. It was almost as if pedestrians could walk right through the open space with only tables and a chair blocking the path. When I saw how vulnerable the restaurant was to pedestrian traffic not for one moment did I question the "secrecy" request which was a burden of trust put upon us not to let a word get out about this event. Unfortunately in today's world such news could jeopardize the life and/or safety of the "famous" folk such as Susan herself.
What I learned from today's Meet and Greet was that it turned out to be an enormous success because Susan enjoys small groups and relishes spending individual time with each. This event would not have been possible if 200 or more people had attended. Susan is one of the few singers who offer such "fan time" in the first place. Her comfort and her requirements were our top priorities. If word had gotten out in NYC that Susan would be physically present at St. Andrews for lunch for a M & G, the general public and local passersby might have mobbed the place which would have necessitated cancelling the entire event in order to insure the safely of Susan and others. Please also remember that if somebody had informed "Page 6" of the New York Post of the event, either deliberately or inadvertently, it could well have mushroomed into additional media coverage and the little restaurant could have been packed with curious onlookers who only want to see a celebrity while they are in NYC. Susan's management and Grits made all of the right decisions in the best interests of Susan and in the best interest of insuring that the event would be successful.
Meeting other fans the night before and sharing dinner was a great thrill, just to be able to meet flesh and blood after cyperspacing words with each other for 2 1/2 years. Everyone was kind and considerate and wonderful to be near.
Today Susan herself breezed in with Andy and her entourage. We immediately began signing "Hello, Susan!" to the tune of "Hello, Dolly!" She smiled ear to ear and then began mingling into the crowd with a hug and greeting for each of us. Then we all sat down and she had her lunch with us. When she was finished, she got up, gave a big hello to Flat Susan and we all had a chance to take as many photos as we wanted. And then she sat down in a chair with an emtpy chair beside her and we all took turns by numbers to sit with her for our "3 minutes" of one to one time. She was encouraging us to bring her all sorts of things to sign. I belive it was Graysea who had the back of her T-shirt signed. For me she signed two books and I had the great honor on behalf of HAPPY and all the Golden Girls to gift Susan with her own autographed copy of Catching the Dream. Susan seemed thrilled, as well as touched by the gift. I also read to her the dedication page and she gave another big hug in thanks to all of us who wrote poems for her.
Andy then announced that in appreciation of the fact that people had traveled long distances to be here with Susan, he and Susan wanted to share with us FOUR recordings which in all probability will be included in her next CD. Andy indicated that Sony wanted all of us to turn in our cameras and cellphones in order to insure that no recordings of the songs we were about to hear would leave the room. We were asked to place such items in the provided envelopes with our names on them. The Sony sound man played the recordings and we were sworn not to disclose the titles of any of the songs because a few of them are well known classics. He did give us permission, however, to let you know that Susan will sing one of the songs on the season finale of AGT. We listened to the songs and gave him feedback on each song.
The grand finale was a performance of a Texas line-dance performed to the tune of "New York, New York." Susan and Andy got a big kick out of that little number!
Susan was not in a rush to leave! She said goodbyes to each and all and gave even more hugs. This lady is well on her way to feeling totally comfortable with her fans and fame. And we truly loved the experience of being with Susan.
At first. I did feel like I was in kindergarten, but I got my pacifier and I am okay now....lol
Quote:
Originally Posted by pardonmeboy
Just a little hard to do when we have been treated like children.
Puh-leez, people. This is NOT a private forum. Anyone using any name and any email address can register here. We surely know that paps, bloggers, and competing label research arms monitor here looking for any tidbits about what Susan is up to. The recording industry is hugely competitve which is why there is great secrecy about release dates, track lists and promotion plans. The pseudo M&G apparently was put together as some part of the overall promotion plan for Susan's CD. There is no way that it could have been announced on this forum because, again, this forum is in no way private, and who knows who would have shown up for purposes not in Susan's best interests. This was clearly a business arrangement and not a case of Susan just wanting to kick back with some fans. I don't want those who agreed to go to NY at their own expense to reveal song titles or anything else surrounding CD #3 that will put Susan at a competitive disadvantage.
Amber,
Thank you SSOOOOO much for your report! What an absolutely wonderful experience you had to meet Susan. She is very very lucky to have Andy on her team!!! Now, get some much needed rest!!!:thanks::excellent:
Thanks, Amber. After reading your post, I feel a little better. I was a sad little camper for a while there. Thank you for sharing your wonderful experience today. I can only imagine.
Thank you so much, Amber Duke, for your wonderful report. So glad you were there and were willing to share with us who were waiting for more news. Sounds like a fantastic event.
Quote:
Originally Posted by ReynieCarroll
Puh-leez, people. This is NOT a private forum. Anyone using any name and any email address can register here. We surely know that paps, bloggers, and competing label research arms monitor here looking for any tidbits about what Susan is up to. The recording industry is hugely competitve which is why there is great secrecy about release dates, track lists and promotion plans. The pseudo M&G apparently was put together as some part of the overall promotion plan for Susan's CD. There is no way that it could have been announced on this forum because, again, this forum is in no way private, and who knows who would have shown up for purposes not in Susan's best interests. This was clearly a business arrangement and not a case of Susan just wanting to kick back with some fans. I don't want those who agreed to go to NY at their own expense to reveal song titles or anything else surrounding CD #3 that will put Susan at a competitive disadvantage.
This sounds like a good explanation .:excellent:
Quote:
Originally Posted by sunandroses
Hello, folks, I am not at my usual computer but am at my son's place in NY, after being "1 of the 20" who shared a spectacular time with Susan today. I have lots of photos, but haven't had a chance to download and upload my downloads! I'll do that when I return on the 26th.
In the spirit of love and joy I want to share with you the extraordinary graciousness extended to all of us by Andy and Susan, Joanna and others who came with them to New York. The rooms were very small in St. Andrews Restaurant. When I went to check out the place Friday evening, I had to ask several people where the "private reserved room" was. Nobody had a clue that Susan was coming. Not the bartender; not the waitress; not even the manager. The manager knew that someone "important" was coming but they did not know who. Let me explain that this restaurant had a door as well as a huge double door which was fully open to the sidewalk. It was almost as if pedestrians could walk right through the open space with only tables and a chair blocking the path. When I saw how vulnerable the restaurant was to pedestrian traffic not for one moment did I question the "secrecy" request which was a burden of trust put upon us not to let a word get out about this event. Unfortunately in today's world such news could jeopardize the life and/or safety of the "famous" folk such as Susan herself.
What I learned from today's Meet and Greet was that it turned out to be an enormous success because Susan enjoys small groups and relishes spending individual time with each. This event would not have been possible if 200 or more people had attended. Susan is one of the few singers who offer such "fan time" in the first place. Her comfort and her requirements were our top priorities. If word had gotten out in NYC that Susan would be physically present at St. Andrews for lunch for a M & G, the general public and local passersby might have mobbed the place which would have necessitated cancelling the entire event in order to insure the safely of Susan and others. Please also remember that if somebody had informed "Page 6" of the New York Post of the event, either deliberately or inadvertently, it could well have mushroomed into additional media coverage and the little restaurant could have been packed with curious onlookers who only want to see a celebrity while they are in NYC. Susan's management and Grits made all of the right decisions in the best interests of Susan and in the best interest of insuring that the event would be successful.
Meeting other fans the night before and sharing dinner was a great thrill, just to be able to meet flesh and blood after cyperspacing words with each other for 2 1/2 years. Everyone was kind and considerate and wonderful to be near.
Today Susan herself breezed in with Andy and her entourage. We immediately began signing "Hello, Susan!" to the tune of "Hello, Dolly!" She smiled ear to ear and then began mingling into the crowd with a hug and greeting for each of us. Then we all sat down and she had her lunch with us. When she was finished, she got up, gave a big hello to Flat Susan and we all had a chance to take as many photos as we wanted. And then she sat down in a chair with an emtpy chair beside her and we all took turns by numbers to sit with her for our "3 minutes" of one to one time. She was encouraging us to bring her all sorts of things to sign. I belive it was Graysea who had the back of her T-shirt signed. For me she signed two books and I had the great honor on behalf of HAPPY and all the Golden Girls to gift Susan with her own autographed copy of Catching the Dream. Susan seemed thrilled, as well as touched by the gift. I also read to her the dedication page and she gave another big hug in thanks to all of us who wrote poems for her.
Andy then announced that in appreciation of the fact that people had traveled long distances to be here with Susan, he and Susan wanted to share with us FOUR recordings which in all probability will be included in her next CD. Andy indicated that Sony wanted all of us to turn in our cameras and cellphones in order to insure that no recordings of the songs we were about to hear would leave the room. We were asked to place such items in the provided envelopes with our names on them. The Sony sound man played the recordings and we were sworn not to disclose the titles of any of the songs because a few of them are well known classics. He did give us permission, however, to let you know that Susan will sing one of the songs on the season finale of AGT. We listened to the songs and gave him feedback on each song.
The grand finale was a performance of a Texas line-dance performed to the tune of "New York, New York." Susan and Andy got a big kick out of that little number!
Susan was not in a rush to leave! She said goodbyes to each and all and gave even more hugs. This lady is well on her way to feeling totally comfortable with her fans and fame. And we truly loved the experience of being with Susan.
That was a fine report, S&R. Thanks. Are you allowed to tell us if there was one song the majority liked best and if so, was it a new one? Also what about their tempo.
Thank you, thank you, thank you, Amber Duke and sunandroses. I appreciate so much your taking the time to give us some idea of what went on today. Obviously a fantastic time. Can't wait for pictures.
Great reports sunandroses and Amber Duke. Thank you so much for filling us in. Glad the M&G was such a great success and Susan enjoyed herself. I am off to :zzz: now and will have happy dreams about your great party. :goodnight:
Quote:
Originally Posted by ReynieCarroll
Puh-leez, people. This is NOT a private forum. Anyone using any name and any email address can register here. We surely know that paps, bloggers, and competing label research arms monitor here looking for any tidbits about what Susan is up to. The recording industry is hugely competitve which is why there is great secrecy about release dates, track lists and promotion plans. The pseudo M&G apparently was put together as some part of the overall promotion plan for Susan's CD. There is no way that it could have been announced on this forum because, again, this forum is in no way private, and who knows who would have shown up for purposes not in Susan's best interests. This was clearly a business arrangement and not a case of Susan just wanting to kick back with some fans. I don't want those who agreed to go to NY at their own expense to reveal song titles or anything else surrounding CD #3 that will put Susan at a competitive disadvantage.
Thank you, RC and others who have pointed these things out, that is exactly right. New York City is not West Lothian, by a long shot, so there is no comparison with the lovely local m&g's there. Sunandroses also expressed very well the situation that could very well have arisen, and very likely would have, had any word gotten out. They would simply have canceled it. This forum is not just "us," folks, and we all know that.
Amberduke & Sunandroses thank you so much for the reports! :D It sounds like a rousing success! :dance: Susan's safety & that of her team & fans are of the utmost importance!
Can't wait to see AGT! :Ilovesusan::susanrocks:
THANK YOUAmber duke and sunandroses !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Much appreciated and very happy for you :love::love:
C::thankyou::kisses::hug::hug::hug:
Thanks Amber Duke and Sunandroses for the great reports. It sounds like Susan had as much fun as her fans.
sunandroses, Thank you!!! Susan is such a gift to all of us... actually meeting small groups of fans and giving them her time and attention! I can see why there had to be such secrecy about this M & G. Susan is known worldwide now and a leak could have created a media storm that would have messed up everything that was planned. Susan really does love meeting her fans!! I know we all can't wait to see her perform on AGT! Thank you again.
Quote:
Originally Posted by chocolate eyes
"All animals are equal, but some animals are more equal than others." George Orwell, Animal Farm
Since words fail me right now, I'll let George Orwell speak for me.
After reading this, if I had been lucky enough to have been asked to attend, I would not be sharing my experience with anyone. A few of you have managed to spoil what was I am sure a very exciting a happy experience for those in attendance. Think about what you have posted and how those in NY may feel when they those posts.
Thank you also, sunandroses, for your nice report about the M & G today in NY.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Amber Duke
Whew! I’m sure you all realize that no one who was there would post until they had read through all 24 pages of this thread first, and that takes time. Besides which I’ve been out for a family obligation and just got home.
I was one of the lucky, lucky, lucky ones! From the moment I got the message about it I have alternated between complete delirium/excitement and serious misgivings and worry about how the news would eventually be received on the forum. I know very well that if I had not been so fortunate this time I would have felt at least a twinge of envy and asked “why not me?” But then I would have to know that it appeared to be random, as I haven’t done anything to curry favor with anybody. So in the end, coming up with 20 people out of – gosh, how many are we in all? – was bound to cause disappointment among the remaining hundreds of fans. But believe me, we all had anxiety about how everyone else would feel. Then there were the many close friendships between some of the 20 and others on the forum. The first thing we would want to do is to share our news, but not one of us did, to my knowledge, because a promise is a promise. I absolutely believe Susan’s team – and it might have even come from beyond her team, although I’m not privy to all the information – had strong reasons for imposing a “gag” order about this. They are actually very conscient of Susan’s fans, believe it or not. Having seen Andy today, I’m more admiring of him than ever!
Having said that, I’ll say that GritsT’s initial description captures the essence of the event very well. Susan had been somewhere else this morning – and again, I have no idea where, nor did we ask – so we weren’t sure exactly when she would arrive. NYC traffic is unpredictable. So we ate quickly and waited. I have to admit to having a little trouble breathing when they said she was coming up the stairs. When you have seen her so many times on videos, the prospect of being in the same room is, well, kind of unreal. And what others have said in the past is true: seeing her in person is different. She has an aura that draws people to her; you can feel it. She was pretty casually dressed, and her hair was in her natural tousled curls. But it’s hard to focus on anything but her personality, as she hams it up, laughs and gives us all her energy. All the facial expressions we have seen over time come out in rapid succession. So fast that when you think you’re taking a picture of one, by the time the flash goes off, she’s on to another. She loves to clown.
We were all told we would have 3 minutes to sit with her one-on-one. But unbeknownst to us, she had not yet had lunch, so we waited while she ordered and gulped down a quick bite, along with Andy, Joanne, and others with her. As a result, I’m not sure, but I think in the end our time was shortened to 2 minutes. I say I’m not sure, because in the moment, things become a bit of a blur, and I’m not really sure about anything. Anyhow, while each person was with her, dozens of others were watching and taking pictures. Whatever I might have thought I would say to her, I pretty much forgot it when the moment came, but I guess I said something, and she was, of course, sweet and gracious. I can’t imagine how she can hold up under meeting with so many people she doesn’t know.
Then Andy gave us the extreme joy of hearing a sample from the new album (no, Susan did not sing for us), although he emphasized that it was still a work in progress and had not had the mixing completed. We were actually able to give our reaction to one song, which was: absolutely beautiful, but we want less orchestra and more Susan!! Sound familiar? He assured us that would still be adjusted. Unfortunately, and this will probably cause more cataclysmic reactions, Sony insists absolutely that the title not be revealed until they put it out officially. But you will know one quite soon, because Susan is going to sing it on AGT.
OK, I rushed to write some of this now, since I know you’re wanting to hear more about what went on. Some of those attending are on their way home and can't post yet. Some don't have access to computers yet. I know there will be pictures, but I'm not proficient at that.
I sincerely thank those of you who are being understanding of this event. If you are thinking it’s daunting to post about it after reading some bitterness, you are right. I feel like hiding under a couch. In addition, I will need some serious time to decompress. I know for sure if there is another occasion, it will be another group entirely, and you’ll have your turn. To anyone feeling really bad, I understand, but I hope you can wait, as PT advised, until more is known about the purpose of the event and the reasons behind it before jumping to negative conclusions. Susan is an absolute angel, and she has the strongest defender in the world in Andy. That makes me very happy.
Loved this, Amber. Glad Susan has the stalwart Andy by her side. Thanks for feeding us hungry beasts. Glad you guys got in that bit about pulling back on the orchestra.
Quote:
Originally Posted by southernfan
Thanks Amber Duke and Sunandroses for the great reports. It sounds like Susan had as much fun as her fans.
What she said!!!!
08-21-2011, 04:38 AM
CzechLadyUSA
sunandroses, Thank you!!! Susan is such a gift to all of us... actually meeting small groups of fans and giving them her time and attention! I can see why there had to be such secrecy about this M & G. Susan is known worldwide now and a leak could have created a media storm that would have messed up everything that was planned. Susan really does love meeting her fans!! I know we all can't wait to see her perform on AGT! Thank you again.
08-21-2011, 04:39 AM
Anniev
Quote:
Originally Posted by chocolate eyes
"All animals are equal, but some animals are more equal than others." George Orwell, Animal Farm
Since words fail me right now, I'll let George Orwell speak for me.
After reading this, if I had been lucky enough to have been asked to attend, I would not be sharing my experience with anyone. A few of you have managed to spoil what was I am sure a very exciting a happy experience for those in attendance. Think about what you have posted and how those in NY may feel when they those posts.
08-21-2011, 04:40 AM
antique
Thank you also, sunandroses, for your nice report about the M & G today in NY.
08-21-2011, 04:41 AM
trennie
Quote:
Originally Posted by Amber Duke
Whew! I’m sure you all realize that no one who was there would post until they had read through all 24 pages of this thread first, and that takes time. Besides which I’ve been out for a family obligation and just got home.
I was one of the lucky, lucky, lucky ones! From the moment I got the message about it I have alternated between complete delirium/excitement and serious misgivings and worry about how the news would eventually be received on the forum. I know very well that if I had not been so fortunate this time I would have felt at least a twinge of envy and asked “why not me?” But then I would have to know that it appeared to be random, as I haven’t done anything to curry favor with anybody. So in the end, coming up with 20 people out of – gosh, how many are we in all? – was bound to cause disappointment among the remaining hundreds of fans. But believe me, we all had anxiety about how everyone else would feel. Then there were the many close friendships between some of the 20 and others on the forum. The first thing we would want to do is to share our news, but not one of us did, to my knowledge, because a promise is a promise. I absolutely believe Susan’s team – and it might have even come from beyond her team, although I’m not privy to all the information – had strong reasons for imposing a “gag” order about this. They are actually very conscient of Susan’s fans, believe it or not. Having seen Andy today, I’m more admiring of him than ever!
Having said that, I’ll say that GritsT’s initial description captures the essence of the event very well. Susan had been somewhere else this morning – and again, I have no idea where, nor did we ask – so we weren’t sure exactly when she would arrive. NYC traffic is unpredictable. So we ate quickly and waited. I have to admit to having a little trouble breathing when they said she was coming up the stairs. When you have seen her so many times on videos, the prospect of being in the same room is, well, kind of unreal. And what others have said in the past is true: seeing her in person is different. She has an aura that draws people to her; you can feel it. She was pretty casually dressed, and her hair was in her natural tousled curls. But it’s hard to focus on anything but her personality, as she hams it up, laughs and gives us all her energy. All the facial expressions we have seen over time come out in rapid succession. So fast that when you think you’re taking a picture of one, by the time the flash goes off, she’s on to another. She loves to clown.
We were all told we would have 3 minutes to sit with her one-on-one. But unbeknownst to us, she had not yet had lunch, so we waited while she ordered and gulped down a quick bite, along with Andy, Joanne, and others with her. As a result, I’m not sure, but I think in the end our time was shortened to 2 minutes. I say I’m not sure, because in the moment, things become a bit of a blur, and I’m not really sure about anything. Anyhow, while each person was with her, dozens of others were watching and taking pictures. Whatever I might have thought I would say to her, I pretty much forgot it when the moment came, but I guess I said something, and she was, of course, sweet and gracious. I can’t imagine how she can hold up under meeting with so many people she doesn’t know.
Then Andy gave us the extreme joy of hearing a sample from the new album (no, Susan did not sing for us), although he emphasized that it was still a work in progress and had not had the mixing completed. We were actually able to give our reaction to one song, which was: absolutely beautiful, but we want less orchestra and more Susan!! Sound familiar? He assured us that would still be adjusted. Unfortunately, and this will probably cause more cataclysmic reactions, Sony insists absolutely that the title not be revealed until they put it out officially. But you will know one quite soon, because Susan is going to sing it on AGT.
OK, I rushed to write some of this now, since I know you’re wanting to hear more about what went on. Some of those attending are on their way home and can't post yet. Some don't have access to computers yet. I know there will be pictures, but I'm not proficient at that.
I sincerely thank those of you who are being understanding of this event. If you are thinking it’s daunting to post about it after reading some bitterness, you are right. I feel like hiding under a couch. In addition, I will need some serious time to decompress. I know for sure if there is another occasion, it will be another group entirely, and you’ll have your turn. To anyone feeling really bad, I understand, but I hope you can wait, as PT advised, until more is known about the purpose of the event and the reasons behind it before jumping to negative conclusions. Susan is an absolute angel, and she has the strongest defender in the world in Andy. That makes me very happy.
Loved this, Amber. Glad Susan has the stalwart Andy by her side. Thanks for feeding us hungry beasts. Happy you guys got in that bit about pulling back on the orchestra. Can you tell us if the "absolutely beautiful" song was an original and also, what was your reaction to the other 3? Just anything you feel you can disclose.
08-21-2011, 04:41 AM
Henny
Quote:
Originally Posted by southernfan
Thanks Amber Duke and Sunandroses for the great reports. It sounds like Susan had as much fun as her fans.
What she said!!!!
08-21-2011, 04:43 AM
Thornton
I should like to know how you get to be on the A list! There are probably many of us who buy multiple copies of Subo's CD's but do not have the time to devote hours every day to following everything she does. We are no less fans! It is not really important to me whether I meet her or not but I feel somewhat disappointed by all of this.
08-21-2011, 04:47 AM
bunnyohare
All I can say is Wow!!!! Congratulations to the 20 chosen ones. I can't even imagine what it would have felt like to get a message inviting me to meet Susan. I am enjoying reading some of the comments from those who attended.
Rik, you are such a dear man to have been willing to give your chance to meet Susan to Lori. I know that must have meant a lot to her.
As for me, I once dreamed Susan was showing me around her kitchen and making a pot of tea for us to drink. I'll just keep waiting patiently until that dream comes true. After all, it would be my first trip to Scotland and I'd have more than 3 minutes to talk to her. :biggrin:;)
Okay, now that I've given my 2 cents worth, come on you 20. I want to hear more of your wonderful day in New York!!!!
Frannie
08-21-2011, 04:47 AM
JudyMcKinn
Quote:
Originally Posted by Anniev
After reading this, if I had been lucky enough to have been asked to attend, I would not be sharing my experience with anyone. A few of you have managed to spoil what was I am sure a very exciting a happy experience for those in attendance. Think about what you have posted and how those in NY may feel when they those posts.
I can't help but feel, Anniev, that most are mature enough to not pay too much attention to the few who are attempting to ruin this for all the rest of us. Please don't hesitate to post, NY 20, and know that the great majority are tickled to death for you, and waiting for reports and pictures. There are always a few--please don't let them ruin it for the rest of us.
08-21-2011, 04:49 AM
Amber Duke
Quote:
Originally Posted by trennie
Loved this, Amber. Glad Susan has the stalwart Andy by her side. Thanks for feeding us hungry beasts. Glad you guys got in that bit about pulling back on the orchestra.
LOL! It was a funny moment, actually, because practically everybody in the room was yelling the same thing. "Orchestra too loud!" By the way, Susan, was sitting sort of apart from us while the songs were playing, looking embarrassed, but pleased when we applauded. At one point she got very teary. So did we, in fact. For the last song she disappeared entirely.
Another sweet thing: Andy stood talking to us about the album, etc., with his arm around Susan. And she, in her style, kept mimicking him behind his back, making funny faces. Of course he knows her so well, and he realized it and chuckled. But she kept on doing it. In the end she gave him a big hug. She just melts your heart. I got a tear just now thinking of how loving she is.
08-21-2011, 04:51 AM
Linda Sharon
Quote:
Originally Posted by bunnyohare
All I can say is Wow!!!! Congratulations to the 20 chosen ones. I can't even imagine what it would have felt like to get a message inviting me to meet Susan. I am enjoying reading some of the comments from those who attended.
Rik, you are such a dear man to have been willing to give your chance to meet Susan to Lori. I know that must have meant a lot to her.
As for me, I once dreamed Susan was showing me around her kitchen and making a pot of tea for us to drink. I'll just keep waiting patiently until that dream comes true. After all, it would be my first trip to Scotland and I'd have more than 3 minutes to talk to her. :biggrin:;)
Okay, now that I've given my 2 cents worth, come on you 20. I want to hear more of your wonderful day in New York!!!!
Frannie
Love your dream. I also like the twitter report of someone who dreamed a dragon was coming for them and Susan banished it by singing at it. :overjoyed: That's pretty funny... now on to read about all this...so exciting...
08-21-2011, 04:52 AM
trennie
Quote:
Originally Posted by Robert the Bruce
I completely agree. It was most considerate of them to include dedicated fans in their tight schedule and to make an effort to have folks that haven't met her their focus.
Well done!
Hey, RTB. Your in box is full.
08-21-2011, 04:52 AM
Revel
Quote:
Originally Posted by Anniev
After reading this, if I had been lucky enough to have been asked to attend, I would not be sharing my experience with anyone. A few of you have managed to spoil what was I am sure a very exciting a happy experience for those in attendance. Think about what you have posted and how those in NY may feel when they those posts.
Oh, AnnieV, surely no amount of jealousy and complaining could compete with the joyful sunshine of time spent with Susan. :grouphug:
Thank you, Amber, for understanding any disappointment, and for sharing your thoughts, feelings and experience. And thank you, Sunandroses, for your report. So fun to hear the different details that different people remember. It's like filling in a picture with more and more points of light. Thanks again to both of you for your for your thoughtful reports!:grouphug:
P.S. I'm so very happy to read about some classic titles . . .:biggrin:
08-21-2011, 04:53 AM
Linda Sharon
Quote:
Originally Posted by JudyMcKinn
I can't help but feel, Anniev, that most are mature enough to not pay too much attention to the few who are attempting to ruin this for all the rest of us. Please don't hesitate to post, NY 20, and know that the great majority are tickled to death for you, and waiting for reports and pictures. There are always a few--please don't let them ruin it for the rest of us.
That's right - don't let ANYBODY rain on your parade. Enjoy your :cloud: Life dishes out a lot of awful things but this round honey - life dished out something wonderful for you. Savour the experience! -while we cheer you on.
08-21-2011, 04:53 AM
Amber Duke
Quote:
Originally Posted by Thornton
I should like to know how you get to be on the A list! There are probably many of us who buy multiple copies of Subo's CD's but do not have the time to devote hours every day to following everything she does. We are no less fans! It is not really important to me whether I meet her or not but I feel somewhat disappointed by all of this.
I don't believe there was an "A-list." I don't have any special connections that I know of, and there are plenty of more devoted forum posters than me, or than many of the ones who went, some of whom post only seldom. I just wonder, if confronted by the request to assemble 20 fans, how would you suggest? As I said, it sure looked random to me.
08-21-2011, 04:57 AM
Joan M for Susan
Thank you Amber Duke for your wonderful report. I loved reading your adventure and time with Susan.
08-21-2011, 04:58 AM
JudyMcKinn
Says there are currently 100 users on this thread. we haven't had this kind of interest and excitment for a while!
08-21-2011, 04:58 AM
gcy1
Quote:
Originally Posted by Amber Duke
Whew! I’m sure you all realize that no one who was there would post until they had read through all 24 pages of this thread first, and that takes time. Besides which I’ve been out for a family obligation and just got home.
I was one of the lucky, lucky, lucky ones! From the moment I got the message about it I have alternated between complete delirium/excitement and serious misgivings and worry about how the news would eventually be received on the forum. I know very well that if I had not been so fortunate this time I would have felt at least a twinge of envy and asked “why not me?” But then I would have to know that it appeared to be random, as I haven’t done anything to curry favor with anybody. So in the end, coming up with 20 people out of – gosh, how many are we in all? – was bound to cause disappointment among the remaining hundreds of fans. But believe me, we all had anxiety about how everyone else would feel. Then there were the many close friendships between some of the 20 and others on the forum. The first thing we would want to do is to share our news, but not one of us did, to my knowledge, because a promise is a promise. I absolutely believe Susan’s team – and it might have even come from beyond her team, although I’m not privy to all the information – had strong reasons for imposing a “gag” order about this. They are actually very conscient of Susan’s fans, believe it or not. Having seen Andy today, I’m more admiring of him than ever!
Having said that, I’ll say that GritsT’s initial description captures the essence of the event very well. Susan had been somewhere else this morning – and again, I have no idea where, nor did we ask – so we weren’t sure exactly when she would arrive. NYC traffic is unpredictable. So we ate quickly and waited. I have to admit to having a little trouble breathing when they said she was coming up the stairs. When you have seen her so many times on videos, the prospect of being in the same room is, well, kind of unreal. And what others have said in the past is true: seeing her in person is different. She has an aura that draws people to her; you can feel it. She was pretty casually dressed, and her hair was in her natural tousled curls. But it’s hard to focus on anything but her personality, as she hams it up, laughs and gives us all her energy. All the facial expressions we have seen over time come out in rapid succession. So fast that when you think you’re taking a picture of one, by the time the flash goes off, she’s on to another. She loves to clown.
We were all told we would have 3 minutes to sit with her one-on-one. But unbeknownst to us, she had not yet had lunch, so we waited while she ordered and gulped down a quick bite, along with Andy, Joanne, and others with her. As a result, I’m not sure, but I think in the end our time was shortened to 2 minutes. I say I’m not sure, because in the moment, things become a bit of a blur, and I’m not really sure about anything. Anyhow, while each person was with her, dozens of others were watching and taking pictures. Whatever I might have thought I would say to her, I pretty much forgot it when the moment came, but I guess I said something, and she was, of course, sweet and gracious. I can’t imagine how she can hold up under meeting with so many people she doesn’t know.
Then Andy gave us the extreme joy of hearing a sample from the new album (no, Susan did not sing for us), although he emphasized that it was still a work in progress and had not had the mixing completed. We were actually able to give our reaction to one song, which was: absolutely beautiful, but we want less orchestra and more Susan!! Sound familiar? He assured us that would still be adjusted. Unfortunately, and this will probably cause more cataclysmic reactions, Sony insists absolutely that the title not be revealed until they put it out officially. But you will know one quite soon, because Susan is going to sing it on AGT.
OK, I rushed to write some of this now, since I know you’re wanting to hear more about what went on. Some of those attending are on their way home and can't post yet. Some don't have access to computers yet. I know there will be pictures, but I'm not proficient at that.
I sincerely thank those of you who are being understanding of this event. If you are thinking it’s daunting to post about it after reading some bitterness, you are right. I feel like hiding under a couch. In addition, I will need some serious time to decompress. I know for sure if there is another occasion, it will be another group entirely, and you’ll have your turn. To anyone feeling really bad, I understand, but I hope you can wait, as PT advised, until more is known about the purpose of the event and the reasons behind it before jumping to negative conclusions. Susan is an absolute angel, and she has the strongest defender in the world in Andy. That makes me very happy.
I am disappointed I was not invited since I live in midtown NYC.
However, I am very happy for all of you who were invited and grateful for sharing your experience and excitement with us. This is the beginning of promotion for Susan's 3rd album, the real test for the longivity of her career.
08-21-2011, 04:59 AM
Joan M for Susan
Thank you very much sunandroses for your sharing of your time with Susan and the fans. I loved reading your post.
08-21-2011, 04:59 AM
kat d
Thankyou both for your reports,great to hear about the songs,and all the other little details.Now it is going to feel like a long wait before we hear them!
08-21-2011, 05:02 AM
Clemmie
Quote:
Originally Posted by Amber Duke
Whew! I’m sure you all realize that no one who was there would post until they had read through all 24 pages of this thread first, and that takes time. Besides which I’ve been out for a family obligation and just got home.
I was one of the lucky, lucky, lucky ones! From the moment I got the message about it I have alternated between complete delirium/excitement and serious misgivings and worry about how the news would eventually be received on the forum. I know very well that if I had not been so fortunate this time I would have felt at least a twinge of envy and asked “why not me?” But then I would have to know that it appeared to be random, as I haven’t done anything to curry favor with anybody. So in the end, coming up with 20 people out of – gosh, how many are we in all? – was bound to cause disappointment among the remaining hundreds of fans. But believe me, we all had anxiety about how everyone else would feel. Then there were the many close friendships between some of the 20 and others on the forum. The first thing we would want to do is to share our news, but not one of us did, to my knowledge, because a promise is a promise. I absolutely believe Susan’s team – and it might have even come from beyond her team, although I’m not privy to all the information – had strong reasons for imposing a “gag” order about this. They are actually very conscient of Susan’s fans, believe it or not. Having seen Andy today, I’m more admiring of him than ever!
Having said that, I’ll say that GritsT’s initial description captures the essence of the event very well. Susan had been somewhere else this morning – and again, I have no idea where, nor did we ask – so we weren’t sure exactly when she would arrive. NYC traffic is unpredictable. So we ate quickly and waited. I have to admit to having a little trouble breathing when they said she was coming up the stairs. When you have seen her so many times on videos, the prospect of being in the same room is, well, kind of unreal. And what others have said in the past is true: seeing her in person is different. She has an aura that draws people to her; you can feel it. She was pretty casually dressed, and her hair was in her natural tousled curls. But it’s hard to focus on anything but her personality, as she hams it up, laughs and gives us all her energy. All the facial expressions we have seen over time come out in rapid succession. So fast that when you think you’re taking a picture of one, by the time the flash goes off, she’s on to another. She loves to clown.
We were all told we would have 3 minutes to sit with her one-on-one. But unbeknownst to us, she had not yet had lunch, so we waited while she ordered and gulped down a quick bite, along with Andy, Joanne, and others with her. As a result, I’m not sure, but I think in the end our time was shortened to 2 minutes. I say I’m not sure, because in the moment, things become a bit of a blur, and I’m not really sure about anything. Anyhow, while each person was with her, dozens of others were watching and taking pictures. Whatever I might have thought I would say to her, I pretty much forgot it when the moment came, but I guess I said something, and she was, of course, sweet and gracious. I can’t imagine how she can hold up under meeting with so many people she doesn’t know.
Then Andy gave us the extreme joy of hearing a sample from the new album (no, Susan did not sing for us), although he emphasized that it was still a work in progress and had not had the mixing completed. We were actually able to give our reaction to one song, which was: absolutely beautiful, but we want less orchestra and more Susan!! Sound familiar? He assured us that would still be adjusted. Unfortunately, and this will probably cause more cataclysmic reactions, Sony insists absolutely that the title not be revealed until they put it out officially. But you will know one quite soon, because Susan is going to sing it on AGT.
OK, I rushed to write some of this now, since I know you’re wanting to hear more about what went on. Some of those attending are on their way home and can't post yet. Some don't have access to computers yet. I know there will be pictures, but I'm not proficient at that.
I sincerely thank those of you who are being understanding of this event. If you are thinking it’s daunting to post about it after reading some bitterness, you are right. I feel like hiding under a couch. In addition, I will need some serious time to decompress. I know for sure if there is another occasion, it will be another group entirely, and you’ll have your turn. To anyone feeling really bad, I understand, but I hope you can wait, as PT advised, until more is known about the purpose of the event and the reasons behind it before jumping to negative conclusions. Susan is an absolute angel, and she has the strongest defender in the world in Andy. That makes me very happy.
Thank you Grits, Amber Duke and Sunandroses for your wonderful comments which I ditto. I too have been both hiding under the couch, decompressing and at the same time preparing for a big event. Therefore I am not able to write at length at this time, but want to say that I too was there and I wish everyone could have been there. Susan is a dear and precious woman with a heart of gold. Her talent is without measure. We are all so lucky to have her in our lives.
08-21-2011, 05:02 AM
soothed
Thank you for the reports. I just am anxious for RIK to get his song. Hope it is on there.
08-21-2011, 05:03 AM
Lisa Pully
Quote:
Originally Posted by Amber Duke
LOL! It was a funny moment, actually, because practically everybody in the room was yelling the same thing. "Orchestra too loud!" By the way, Susan, was sitting sort of apart from us while the songs were playing, looking embarrassed, but pleased when we applauded. At one point she got very teary. So did we, in fact. For the last song she disappeared entirely.
Another sweet thing: Andy stood talking to us about the album, etc., with his arm around Susan. And she, in her style, kept mimicking him behind his back, making funny faces. Of course he knows her so well, and he realized it and chuckled. But she kept on doing it. In the end she gave him a big hug. She just melts your heart. I got a tear just now thinking of how loving she is.
First thank you to GritsT, sunandroses and Amber Duke for the recap of todays splended event! Please Blessed 20, please the rest of you give us your story.
And Amber Duke?? I so cannot see Susan doing the high lighted words ....:laught2:
08-21-2011, 05:04 AM
trennie
Quote:
Originally Posted by Amber Duke
LOL! It was a funny moment, actually, because practically everybody in the room was yelling the same thing. "Orchestra too loud!" By the way, Susan, was sitting sort of apart from us while the songs were playing, looking embarrassed, but pleased when we applauded. At one point she got very teary. So did we, in fact. For the last song she disappeared entirely.
Another sweet thing: Andy stood talking to us about the album, etc., with his arm around Susan. And she, in her style, kept mimicking him behind his back, making funny faces. Of course he knows her so well, and he realized it and chuckled. But she kept on doing it. In the end she gave him a big hug. She just melts your heart. I got a tear just now thinking of how loving she is.
Do you mean she got teary at a song, Amber?
08-21-2011, 05:04 AM
irisheyes
So happy to hear your reports!! I love all the descriptions... We're all so lucky to be able to share this time...this Susan Boyle time in history...
Thanks for posting, Clemmie. Looking forward to more of your thoughts, when you feel up to it. Everyone there sort of saw the same things, but all will have different feelings and thoughts, so please don't hesitate to post, everyone, just because others of the lucky 20 have already posted. We look forward to everyone's thoughts and comments.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Kalua
Ok folks sometimes you simply do not realize when to stop, if you really would read all that was said carefully
you would have understood that is is the documentary that the team wanted to keep under wraps. By mentioning it over and over again you are killing something that Subo Team wanted to be secret
Now all posts talking about it will be deleted by the staff and mine also once it has been read.
Thank you for your understanding
I have run ahead and read thru what starts to be page 26 of notes tonight. I understand all the opinions expressed here and particularly appreciate that three of the attendees have given us the thumbnail sketch of today's M&G. As much as we 'nosey Susan lovers' want to see and hear More and More and More, there are times when we really need LESS.
I'm pleased that RIK was asked and saddened that he and LisaP couldn't put feet or wings to any plans to attend. I hope at least one other male fan was included; sometimes it seems a tad lopsided when it is just SusaSisters, though I love a hen fest as much as anyone.
There is something that is a tiny spec in the note above from our Leader and apparently alluded in other posts ..... dealing with the 'doc' word .... I hope that the SONY team has a careful knowledge of where their 'doc' is going IF they Are going to add today's (or any other day's) M&G footage to their 'doc in progress'. The flip side of that, whether dvd or tv or what, is Susan's FUTURE SAFETY. Just saying .... I hope it is edited and presented in a way so we as forum and fansites are not deluged with even more trolls in the future. And where you find trolls you find paps, etc. and vice versa and maybe other strange events we have seen intrude upon Susan.
After reading this full day's dialogue I have a thought I'll toss out for Leadership's consideration. Kalua has alluded to all 'doc' posts being deleted when the thread dies down. I would take it a step further: There are not more than a dozen really good posts in this thread, most are from the attendees. Rather than let this entire thread fuminate in our archives, I would rather those really good posts be culled, harvested and put into a future thread in coming days for all the reports of the attendees --- and the rest of this entire thread be vanquished to the ether. We keep saying we want more members to come to the forum, but when they get inside the doors and start reading discussions like this one with so much negative dialog, I would rather it be deep-sixed altogether, gone at Midnight EST along with the rest of Cinderella's mice and coach. So that's my request, Skipper -- our Captain K. --- would request to tie an anchor on the thread and deep-six it at 23:59, Sir.
(PS It WAS Lovely to have seen such a nice turnout today. Looking forward to seeing everyone again in a day or two when the 20 attendees can finish updating us, although I must admit, I think we know more than we need to already. AGT confirmation is plenty for me.)
:grouphug: :Ilovesusan:
I agree, Zasu, I'd like a thread with just reports.
(And a big thanks to GritsT, sunandroses, and Amber Duke for the reports so far.)
Quote:
Originally Posted by gcy1
I am disappointed I was not invited since I live in midtown NYC.
However, I am very happy for all of you who were invited and grateful for sharing your experience and excitement with us. This is the beginning of promotion for Susan's 3rd album, the real test for the longivity of her career.
GCY, your last sentence is so true (I'd bold it if I'd learned). You're right, what was really important about today was not all this other stuff, but that it was the beginning of Phase II of her career. And I'd really love to hear more reaction to the 4 songs.
I don't think the folks who have expressed disappointment are necessarily trying to steal the joy of those who were fortunate enough to have been chosen. I believe their feelings were genuinely hurt, especially if they've felt overlooked in the past. But since at least 3 of the fans who were with Susan have kindly shared their stories of their time with her, I think it's becoming clearer that security was paramount, folks who had never met her were selected fairly randomly and personal slights were never intended. Folks who haven't met her yet may well be able to enjoy a similar experience in the future. Thank you, Grits, Amber Duke and S & R for sharing your special time with Susan. These are moments to treasure. :) I hope you've jotted them all down for posterity!
Quote:
Originally Posted by JudyMcKinn
I can't help but feel, Anniev, that most are mature enough to not pay too much attention to the few who are attempting to ruin this for all the rest of us. Please don't hesitate to post, NY 20, and know that the great majority are tickled to death for you, and waiting for reports and pictures. There are always a few--please don't let them ruin it for the rest of us.
No one is attempting to ruin anything - a number of fans are simply sharing their feelings.
May I add my thanks to GritsT, Amber Duke and sunandroses for your wonderful reports. AD, I could almost imagine I was one of the twenty and "remembering" that marvellous experience rather than reading about your experience :) And S&R, thank you for describing so well the environment of the gathering and how important it was not to attract attention from outsiders. You have explained very clearly why it needed to be kept a secret. I loved to read that Susan was happy and relaxed and funny and enjoying herself. Can't wait to see some photos.
Also looking forward to detailed reports from Clemmie and from the other members of the NY20 when they have finally floated down to earth. :biggrin:
Quote:
Originally Posted by trennie
Do you mean she got teary at a song, Amber?
Trennie, I believe she got teary at our response. I'm sure she was anxious about it.
I don't agree ZaSu. I guess I'm a purist. i don't think this thread should be edited to keep some posts. It's organic and it's just my opinion that threads should not be tampered with. I feel this is a historical account of Susan's journey through the fans point of view and should not be altered.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Anniev
I find this post to be quite offensive on so many levels. You are of course entitled to your opinion, however, name calling is never appropriate. Stating that this forum is not a democracy if your rude comment is removed, is certainly threatening. Susan and her team have every right to do what they want and how they want, what the motives of their actions are, is quite frankly none of our business.
You have asked that you not be given warnings, I am sorry that I will not be able to comply with your request. You will be getting a PM from me shortly. You have violated Rule1 by not showing respect for Susan and her team and have violated and rule 2.
While"What a Jerk" is perhaps not the most diplomatic of descriptions to use, we are adults and should be treated as such. This "naughty step" business, I find troubling and I agree with another post that it would have been better protocol to deal with any matter which caused concern in a private way.
08-21-2011, 05:40 AM
trennie
Quote:
Originally Posted by Amber Duke
Trennie, I believe she got teary at our response. I'm sure she was anxious about it.
That's so interesting. So she sat through two songs looking somewhat embarrassed got teary, at the third(?) and left at the 4th. Did Joanne or Andy go with her? And did she return later?
08-21-2011, 05:41 AM
diane wheldrake
Thank you Grits, Amber and Sunandroses for your wonderful reports, now I shall go to bed happy and dream of Susan.
08-21-2011, 05:49 AM
Linda Sharon
Quote:
Originally Posted by trennie
That's so interesting. So she sat through two songs looking somewhat embarrassed got teary, at the third(?) and left at the 4th. Did Joanne or Andy go with her? And did she return later?
Well here's the thing (as Mr. Monk says), I write poems/songs etc.and if someone else is reading them I feel really squirmy and a little self conscious til I see if they like them or not. Maybe it was something like that. So her reaction makes perfect sense to me. You feel really vulnerable when someone is critiquing your work.
08-21-2011, 05:49 AM
fanfromgeorgia
A new thread has been created for all current and additional reports from the M&G with Susan.
http://forum.susan-boyle.com/threads...usan-8-20-2011
Current reports will be moved over shortly..
08-21-2011, 05:50 AM
Glo
Quote:
Originally Posted by MollBobbers
May I add my thanks to GritsT, Amber Duke and sunandroses for your wonderful reports. AD, I could almost imagine I was one of the twenty and "remembering" that marvellous experience rather than reading about your experience :) And S&R, thank you for describing so well the environment of the gathering and how important it was not to attract attention from outsiders. You have explained very clearly why it needed to be kept a secret. I loved to read that Susan was happy and relaxed and funny and enjoying herself. Can't wait to see some photos.
Also looking forward to detailed reports from Clemmie and from the other members of the NY20 when they have finally floated down to earth. :biggrin:
What she said!
08-21-2011, 05:52 AM
GritsT
Others took lots more pictures than I did, but here's a picture of Susan "hamming it up!"
Now I'm going to bed - early flight back to TX in the morning!
http://i52.tinypic.com/10xdp9c.jpg
08-21-2011, 05:56 AM
trennie
Quote:
Originally Posted by Linda Sharon
Well here's the thing (as Mr. Monk says), I write poems/songs etc.and if someone else is reading them I feel really squirmy and a little self conscious til I see if they like them or not. Maybe it was something like that. So her reaction makes perfect sense to me. You feel really vulnerable when someone is critiquing your work.
I think you're probably right, Linda and she left for the last one, because it was just getting a little too much.
08-21-2011, 05:57 AM
Lisa Pully
Quote:
Originally Posted by GritsT
Others took lots more pictures than I did, but here's a picture of Susan "hamming it up!"
Now I'm going to bed - early flight back to TX in the morning!
http://i52.tinypic.com/10xdp9c.jpg
Thank you so much GritsT, This woman sure knows how to crack me up!! :D I LOVE the sun visor LOL
08-21-2011, 05:57 AM
Glo
Thank you, GritsT - that's a lovely photo Susan.
08-21-2011, 05:57 AM
Linda Sharon
Quote:
Originally Posted by GritsT
Others took lots more pictures than I did, but here's a picture of Susan "hamming it up!"
Now I'm going to bed - early flight back to TX in the morning!
http://i52.tinypic.com/10xdp9c.jpg
\
Great stuff. Susan 'hamming it up' is one of her most endearing qualities.
In New York last Nov as well, she cracked me up swishing the tales of her coat back and forth and making muscle man motions with her arms. Part of her wonderful charm. Can't wait for more of these pics.
08-21-2011, 05:58 AM
Retired In Kalifornia
Quote:
Originally Posted by GritsT
Others took lots more pictures than I did, but here's a picture of Susan "hamming it up!"
Now I'm going to bed - early flight back to TX in the morning!
http://i52.tinypic.com/10xdp9c.jpg
:dance::clap::dance:
08-21-2011, 05:58 AM
chocolate eyes
Quote:
Originally Posted by Anniev
After reading this, if I had been lucky enough to have been asked to attend, I would not be sharing my experience with anyone. A few of you have managed to spoil what was I am sure a very exciting a happy experience for those in attendance. Think about what you have posted and how those in NY may feel when they those posts.
Annie, with all due respect, I said nothing in my post to cast any aspersions upon those fans fortunate enough to attend. I am very glad that they had the privilege and joy of meeting Susan, Andy, Joanne and the rest of the entourage. They are very kind to share their experiences and their happiness.
Believe me, I thought VERY carefully about what I posted before I posted it. Lest there be any further misunderstanding, my post was NOT directed at those lucky fans. My statement concerned the interesting, shall we say, manner in which the encounter was planned and executed. But, I will say no more.
08-21-2011, 05:59 AM
MollBobbers
Others took lots more pictures than I did, but here's a picture of Susan "hamming it up!"
Thank you GritsT. That pic is precious. Awwwww. :)
08-21-2011, 06:04 AM
gaylefromva
I am so happy to hear all of the reports. It sounds as though you had a wonderful time. I think the old saying holds true: "You can please some of the people some of the time, but you can't please all of the people all of the time." I think that soon, we will be able to see the whole picture and know why these decisions were made. I think all of Susan's fans are important to her. I can't wait to hear her new song on AGT.
08-21-2011, 06:05 AM
MollBobbers
Quote:
Originally Posted by fanfromgeorgia
A new thread has been created for all current and additional reports from the M&G with Susan.
http://forum.susan-boyle.com/threads...usan-8-20-2011
Current reports will be moved over shortly..
Thank you FFG. I take it that all photos will be moved over there also? That would be great. :)
08-21-2011, 06:13 AM
Trish (Pat Pierce)
Quote:
Originally Posted by Retired In Kalifornia
If she will be taped I'll likely have to leave Cameron Park around 11:30 p.m. the 30th IF there is A.M. taping, haven't done all-night drive in years - ugh!
Richard...if Susan WILL be on AGT on 8/31, wouldn't she surely be taping on 8/30? I plan to go down on AMTRAK on 8/29 th, to leave a bit of a cushion, since AMTRAK doesn't always run on schedule. Hope to see you and many more Susafriends there at AGT...YIPPEEE... We stood in line for four hours last year, then Susan wasn't allowed to sing. Hope we're successful this time, so Richard, I suggest that you get your name on that waiting list for tickets for the 30th, as well, until we get definite word just when the TAPING will occur.
08-21-2011, 06:14 AM
pardonmeboy
Quote:
Originally Posted by riseandshine
I don't agree ZaSu. I guess I'm a purist. i don't think this thread should be edited to keep some posts. It's organic and it's just my opinion that threads should not be tampered with. I feel this is a historical account of Susan's journey through the fans point of view and should not be altered.
I agree.
08-21-2011, 06:16 AM
Trish (Pat Pierce)
Quote:
Originally Posted by Lisa Pully
He certainly is isnt he? :D
YES, RIK is a compassionate gentleman and DEVOUT SUSAFAN! And, Lisa, I'M glad to hear you received an invitation, at least, for all you have contributed through the months past. Hugs to you! ~Trish
08-21-2011, 06:18 AM
downfaw
Quote:
Originally Posted by Muey
I don't think the folks who have expressed disappointment are necessarily trying to steal the joy of those who were fortunate enough to have been chosen. I believe their feelings were genuinely hurt, especially if they've felt overlooked in the past. But since at least 3 of the fans who were with Susan have kindly shared their stories of their time with her, I think it's becoming clearer that security was paramount, folks who had never met her were selected fairly randomly and personal slights were never intended. Fans who have not yet met Susan may well be able to enjoy a similar experience in the future. Thank you, Grits, Amber Duke and S & R for sharing your special time with Susan. These are moments to treasure. :) I hope you've jotted all your favorite memories down for posterity!
I agree totally.
08-21-2011, 06:20 AM
cac1936
Great report, AD. Please don't spend another minute behind that couch!!!:biggrin: I know it was a magical moment for you and am so happy for you and the others who were able to experience being up close to the charismatic and amazing Susan Boyle. I can't imagine how it could have been planned or executed differently or better.
08-21-2011, 06:21 AM
Lisa Pully
Quote:
Originally Posted by Trish (Pat Pierce)
YES, RIK is a compassionate gentleman and DEVOUT SUSAFAN! And, Lisa, I'M glad to hear you received an invitation, at least, for all you have contributed through the months past. Hugs to you! ~Trish
Trish, you are such a dear, I just hope that if the offer ever comes back up that I will be asked maybe once again. Until I will love and enjoy the visit through the eyes of the Blessed 20 :D
08-21-2011, 06:25 AM
Retired In Kalifornia
Quote:
Originally Posted by Trish (Pat Pierce)
Richard...if Susan WILL be on AGT on 8/31, wouldn't she surely be taping on 8/30? I plan to go down on AMTRAK on 8/29 th, to leave a bit of a cushion, since AMTRAK doesn't always run on schedule. Hope to see you and many more Susafriends there at AGT...YIPPEEE... We stood in line for four hours last year, then Susan wasn't allowed to sing. Hope we're successful this time, so Richard, I suggest that you get your name on that waiting list for tickets for the 30th, as well, until we get definite word just when the TAPING will occur.
Trish "best info" I have it will be August 31st and I now have doubts that I'll make it as am on the Waiting List so my odds aren't good.
08-21-2011, 06:25 AM
Trish (Pat Pierce)
Thank you, Amber, for sharing your memories and emotions so transparently. WE LOVE YOU, and are so thrilled that you had the honor and joy of meeting Susan and Andy in person! And, you surely needed more decompression time, but cared enough to make it to your keyboard to touch base with us...and WE THANK YOU FOR YOUR THOUGHTFULNESS! HUGS! ~Trish
08-21-2011, 06:26 AM
ksdust
I'm glad fans got to be with Susan and report back to us. thank you!
now here are the most important things to me:
1. they heard songs from the new cd and thought they were good! I know Susan is good big grin but I have been a little worried about how they'd have her sing, I don't like much of today's pop music.
2. we will all hear a new song when she sings it on AGT. and that is soon. lots closer than November!
3. Susan is getting publicity in the U.S.!
and always the most important thing is that Susan is happy!
08-21-2011, 06:32 AM
cac1936
I'm not sure I think the question of security should even have had to be explained, S&R, but you did it perfectly. Thanks for the great report. Am so happy for you that you had such a wonderful day and hope you will feel free to share pix and any other thoughts about things you can discuss.
08-21-2011, 06:39 AM
fanfromgeorgia
as posted previously, all future reports from the M&G and all photos are to be put on this thread:
http://forum.susan-boyle.com/threads...863#post559863
Thank you!
08-21-2011, 06:43 AM
tweek
Amber,
Thank you for the wonderful report...and after having met you last fall in New York, I am so glad you had this opportunity to take part in this wonderful Meet & Greet. I sense from all your posts that you are a great Susan fan and rightfully deserved this chance.
I think what people have to realize here Susan did not personally make the choice of who was there. Susan is most relaxed when in smaller groups so even if more people could have been invited, it would have been too stressful for her. Susan also realizes that each one of her fans is important to her. She is where she is today, not only because she is extremely talented, but because of the support she gets from each and every one of us... in whatever small way it is. We are all important to Susan and feeling hurt or left out...is not the answer.
I have met Susan only once and it was not at a Meet and Greet...if I am never able to meet her again...then that's the way it will go down. Will I feel bad? No! I feel in my heart I am just as important to Susan as each and everyone else is. She appreciates all of us. And, that's what you all need to remember. We all love Susan, and her music has given each of us something special. That will not change. Am I a better fan than you, No I am not.... have I done more for Susan than you... No I have not. We all make up Susan's fan base whether we contribute a great deal or something small. She loves all of us...whether we be in her physical presence or not. Maybe she will never get to meet each and every one of us...but be grateful for what she has given to all of us.
I think some of you have expressed yourself better than myself but I wanted to at least say a few words and I am also happy for those who had their chance today.
tweekie
08-21-2011, 06:52 AM
entropydecides
Soothed, Thanks so much for your humor throughout this thread.
Feelings of disappointment are not childish, but understandable given the level of excitement that a visit with Susan generates.
Those selected to participate could have easily been any one of us, it's just hard to accept that fact given the
required secrecy. I hope to hear more stories soon. All who participate on this forum should congratulate themselves on the level of support that they have provided to Susan over the years. I feel those selected and those not selected are on equal footing in their admiration and enthusiasm for Susan.
Amber Duke, Thanks so much for your excellent recollection of events. (I always forget everything that happened) I'm glad you all expressed a shared desire to tone down the orchestra. Grits T. has shown herself to be a woman of action and had very little time to pull this off.
08-21-2011, 06:55 AM
Amber Duke
Quote:
Originally Posted by trennie
That's so interesting. So she sat through two songs looking somewhat embarrassed got teary, at the third(?) and left at the 4th. Did Joanne or Andy go with her? And did she return later?
Sorry, I probably didn't report that quite right. There were 2 rooms with a connecting wide doorway. We were sitting in one, and she was sitting in the other at that moment, but in view of some of us. For the last song, she just moved to another side of that room where we didn't see her. For whatever reason, and I don't want to overdo with speculation. I felt maybe she didn't want to be observed at that moment. But of course there may have been another reason. Joanne was also over there. She came back when we burst into applause. What I am sure of is that it's a little traumatic for anyone to have recorded something new and sit while your fans hear it for the first time. I would have been anxious if it had been me. I can tell you, though, that after the first song, we were the ones in tears.
08-21-2011, 07:02 AM
fantine
On the "Susan In New York" thread I responded to a picture of Susan by saying that it was nice to see her enjoying a pleasant summer afternoon in New York. Well, it appears Susan had a very pleasant time with her adoring fans, too! Thanks to all the attendees for extending a warm welcome to Susan. The few reports already posted are great! Going to the new thread and looking forward to more news of the exciting event.
Thank you for the heads up about AGT on Aug. 31!
Quote:
Originally Posted by entropydecides
Soothed, Thanks so much for your humor throughout this thread.
Feelings of disappointment are not childish, but understandable given the level of excitement that a visit with Susan generates.
Those selected to participate could have easily been any one of us, it's just hard to accept that fact given the
required secrecy. I hope to hear more stories soon. All who participate on this forum should congratulate themselves on the level of support that they have provided to Susan over the years. I feel those selected and those not selected are on equal footing in their admiration and enthusiasm for Susan.
Amber Duke, Thanks so much for your excellent recollection of events. (I always forget everything that happened) I'm glad you all expressed a shared desire to tone down the orchestra. Grits T. has shown herself to be a woman of action and had very little time to pull this off.
I completely agree with you, entropydecides. The fact is that GritsT was given very little time to pull something together, and she did so admirably, in spite of the fact that she was more than inundated with her personal life at the same time. I doubt that she ever got to sleep! Somebody has to organize, and she, Randma and Janna stepped up to the plate and did a fantastic job. I thank them all, as well as others who helped them in many ways.
Tweek, you said it beautifully.
And Lisa and RIK (also several others who were approached and couldn't make it), I'm so sorry you weren't there. Although, come to think of it, maybe that's why I got to go! :biggrin: Who knows?
Thank you, sunandroses, for your marvelous, detailed report. Yes, I agree, that Susan's safety and privacy is of utmost importance. Susan will forever cherish that lovely poetry book. Thank you for taking the time to type out such wonderful details for us to enjoy, for I know you all must be so very weary.
How did those who had never flown to NYC previously manage to find their way from the airport to the hotel? Did Andy provide transportation and an escort for those who needed assistance, if they were inexperienced travelers in a enormous city? Isn't Andy just the epitome of thoughtfulness! He is absolutely the perfect manager and business partner for Susan. And, yes, what joy it is to see Susan enjoying gatherings with small groups of her fans. She has a tender heart for people, such a key component of her amazing character and personality.
I'm hoping to be able to get AMTRAK tickets to L.A., for Susan's AGT studio recording, but we are all unsure if it will be recorded on the 30th or the 31st. It seems as though she would need to record the previous day, if her performance was broadcast on August 31st. Are any of you allowed to provide some clear guidelines for those of us wanting to make train reservations, etc. plans to be there to support Susan in person at the Burbank CBS Recording Studio? Love, Trish
Quote:
Originally Posted by fanfromgeorgia
as posted previously, all future reports from the M&G and all photos are to be put on this thread:
http://forum.susan-boyle.com/threads...863#post559863
Thank you!
I'm bumping this one up, for this is the first time I've noticed this post. THANKS, fanfromgeorgia!
Quote:
Originally Posted by pardonmeboy
No one is attempting to ruin anything - a number of fans are simply sharing their feelings.
Some fans have simply expressed their compassion to those who were not invited. I had always thought to have concern for others less fortunate was a pretty commendable quality. For some apparently it is, for others apparently not.
Quote:
Originally Posted by entropydecides
Soothed, Thanks so much for your humor throughout this thread.
Feelings of disappointment are not childish, but understandable given the level of excitement that a visit with Susan generates.
Those selected to participate could have easily been any one of us, it's just hard to accept that fact given the
required secrecy. I hope to hear more stories soon. All who participate on this forum should congratulate themselves on the level of support that they have provided to Susan over the years. I feel those selected and those not selected are on equal footing in their admiration and enthusiasm for Susan.
Amber Duke, Thanks so much for your excellent recollection of events. (I always forget everything that happened) I'm glad you all expressed a shared desire to tone down the orchestra. Grits T. has shown herself to be a woman of action and had very little time to pull this off.
Entropydecides, thank you. I went to bed and couldn't sleep. Mixed emotions. Worried about everyone, but for anyone who comes here and thinks we don't care about each other, they are wrong. We are a combined force, united by our love for Susan and nothing is going to change that. Now that I have seen the great photos of our lovely lady slumber will come easily. Thank you all for the reports and have a good night.
08-21-2011, 08:36 AM
pmweber1
Quote:
Originally Posted by Susan43212
I'm happy for the fans who were a part of this M&G especially the first timers. I'm looking forward to sharing the experience through reading their stories. How exciting!! I hope we hear from them soon.
:Ilovesusan:
:excellent: I wholeheartedly second my friend, Susan43212's post, thoughts and sentiments! I, too, hope -- one day -- to meet Miss Susan Boyle in person and to hear her sing in a live performance! If it is meant to be; it will happen! Until and if then, I'm so happy for EVERYONE who was able to meet, greet and hear Miss Boyle sing in person on Saturday! Thank you, most of all, dear Susa-Friends, for generously sharing your excitment, recollections and photos with ALL of us!
:Ilovesusan::susanrocks:
:love: to ALL!
Patty
08-21-2011, 08:50 AM
Misti in Seattle
Quote:
Originally Posted by Amber Duke
Whew! I’m sure you all realize that no one who was there would post until they had read through all 24 pages of this thread first, and that takes time. Besides which I’ve been out for a family obligation and just got home.
I was one of the lucky, lucky, lucky ones! From the moment I got the message about it I have alternated between complete delirium/excitement and serious misgivings and worry about how the news would eventually be received on the forum. I know very well that if I had not been so fortunate this time I would have felt at least a twinge of envy and asked “why not me?” But then I would have to know that it appeared to be random, as I haven’t done anything to curry favor with anybody. So in the end, coming up with 20 people out of – gosh, how many are we in all? – was bound to cause disappointment among the remaining hundreds of fans. But believe me, we all had anxiety about how everyone else would feel. Then there were the many close friendships between some of the 20 and others on the forum. The first thing we would want to do is to share our news, but not one of us did, to my knowledge, because a promise is a promise. I absolutely believe Susan’s team – and it might have even come from beyond her team, although I’m not privy to all the information – had strong reasons for imposing a “gag” order about this. They are actually very conscient of Susan’s fans, believe it or not. Having seen Andy today, I’m more admiring of him than ever!
Having said that, I’ll say that GritsT’s initial description captures the essence of the event very well. Susan had been somewhere else this morning – and again, I have no idea where, nor did we ask – so we weren’t sure exactly when she would arrive. NYC traffic is unpredictable. So we ate quickly and waited. I have to admit to having a little trouble breathing when they said she was coming up the stairs. When you have seen her so many times on videos, the prospect of being in the same room is, well, kind of unreal. And what others have said in the past is true: seeing her in person is different. She has an aura that draws people to her; you can feel it. She was pretty casually dressed, and her hair was in her natural tousled curls. But it’s hard to focus on anything but her personality, as she hams it up, laughs and gives us all her energy. All the facial expressions we have seen over time come out in rapid succession. So fast that when you think you’re taking a picture of one, by the time the flash goes off, she’s on to another. She loves to clown.
We were all told we would have 3 minutes to sit with her one-on-one. But unbeknownst to us, she had not yet had lunch, so we waited while she ordered and gulped down a quick bite, along with Andy, Joanne, and others with her. As a result, I’m not sure, but I think in the end our time was shortened to 2 minutes. I say I’m not sure, because in the moment, things become a bit of a blur, and I’m not really sure about anything. Anyhow, while each person was with her, dozens of others were watching and taking pictures. Whatever I might have thought I would say to her, I pretty much forgot it when the moment came, but I guess I said something, and she was, of course, sweet and gracious. I can’t imagine how she can hold up under meeting with so many people she doesn’t know.
Then Andy gave us the extreme joy of hearing a sample from the new album (no, Susan did not sing for us), although he emphasized that it was still a work in progress and had not had the mixing completed. We were actually able to give our reaction to one song, which was: absolutely beautiful, but we want less orchestra and more Susan!! Sound familiar? He assured us that would still be adjusted. Unfortunately, and this will probably cause more cataclysmic reactions, Sony insists absolutely that the title not be revealed until they put it out officially. But you will know one quite soon, because Susan is going to sing it on AGT.
OK, I rushed to write some of this now, since I know you’re wanting to hear more about what went on. Some of those attending are on their way home and can't post yet. Some don't have access to computers yet. I know there will be pictures, but I'm not proficient at that.
I sincerely thank those of you who are being understanding of this event. If you are thinking it’s daunting to post about it after reading some bitterness, you are right. I feel like hiding under a couch. In addition, I will need some serious time to decompress. I know for sure if there is another occasion, it will be another group entirely, and you’ll have your turn. To anyone feeling really bad, I understand, but I hope you can wait, as PT advised, until more is known about the purpose of the event and the reasons behind it before jumping to negative conclusions. Susan is an absolute angel, and she has the strongest defender in the world in Andy. That makes me very happy.
WHHAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAATT???? LOL you got invited! How super! And yes, you were able to keep it a super secret!! I never had a clue! :) Good for you!!!! So happy for you.
And personally I think they were very wise to keep it quiet. After all, a lady should be able to plan a little party without half the world expecting to be invited or, worse yet, crashing it. :)
08-21-2011, 08:57 AM
AngelPrecious
Quote:
Originally Posted by pmweber1
:excellent: I wholeheartedly second my friend, Susan43212's post, thoughts and sentiments! I, too, hope -- one day -- to meet Miss Susan Boyle in person and to hear her sing in a live performance! If it is meant to be; it will happen! Until and if then, I'm so happy for EVERYONE who was able to meet, greet and hear Miss Boyle sing in person on Saturday! Thank you, most of all, dear Susa-Friends, for generously sharing your excitment, recollections and photos with ALL of us!
:Ilovesusan::susanrocks:
:love: to ALL!
Patty
:excellent:
Although I can somewhat understand the sadness of some fans that were not invited, I think its best to trust that the ones chosen were meant to meet Susan at this time. I am very happy that 20 of Susan's fans could share in this experience!!! I hope that all that attended will feel free to share this wonderful experience with the forum! I can't wait to find out about the songs that you people heard and I am very, very excited that Susan will be on the finals of AGT!!!
:Ilovesusan:
08-21-2011, 08:58 AM
Amber Duke
Quote:
Originally Posted by Misti in Seattle
WHHAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAATT???? LOL you got invited! How super! And yes, you were able to keep it a super secret!! I never had a clue! :) Good for you!!!! So happy for you.
And personally I think they were very wise to keep it quiet. After all, a lady should be able to plan a little party without half the world expecting to be invited or, worse yet, crashing it. :)
Thanks, Sue. Yep, it was pretty durn hard to keep the secret from good friends! Sorry. :'(
Aren't those the cutest pictures? Many thanks to Sandi for posting them!
08-21-2011, 09:04 AM
Amber Duke
Quote:
Originally Posted by pmweber1
:excellent: I wholeheartedly second my friend, Susan43212's post, thoughts and sentiments! I, too, hope -- one day -- to meet Miss Susan Boyle in person and to hear her sing in a live performance! If it is meant to be; it will happen! Until and if then, I'm so happy for EVERYONE who was able to meet, greet and hear Miss Boyle sing in person on Saturday! Thank you, most of all, dear Susa-Friends, for generously sharing your excitment, recollections and photos with ALL of us!
:Ilovesusan::susanrocks:
:love: to ALL!
Patty
Oh, don't I wish we had heard her sing in person! It was recordings they played for us, and they weren't the finished product. Still, Susan's voice . . . ! :cloud: Well, actually, we did hear her in person for one split second. As she was about to leave, we sang the first lines of "Perfect Day," and she chimed in on just a couple of words/notes. But it went by too fast!
08-21-2011, 09:13 AM
UKSusanfanAnn
Just finished reading the whole thread, wow, and just wanted to say thankyou to Grits, sunandroses, and AmberDuke, great reports and now over to the other thread, :)
08-21-2011, 09:13 AM
bgad
:Its All Good::thankyou: for all the good reporting from the Dream Meet. To one and all: :Peace: and :love2:
08-21-2011, 09:23 AM
Jenny Wren
Quote:
Originally Posted by Maya
I'm thrilled that Susan undoubtedly had a great time. I doubt she met anyone she hadn't met before. I'm glad it went well and I congratulate everyone who put this together for what seems like a successful event.
Are you saying that PT and Grits T are lying and that Susan has met all these fans before? If so that is a very serious allegation, and you need to be very sure of your facts and to have evidence to back it up!
Quote:
Originally Posted by pardonmeboy
Just a little hard to do when we have been treated like children.
If the cap fits as the saying goes!
I left this site a year a ago as the behavior of many fans was just dreadful. I came back and thought it had improved. I see now that I was wrong. The same few people remain self indulgent and think it is all about them. I showed this thread to my children and asked them what they thought. My ten year old said that she did not want to be a grown up if grown ups behaved like this, and both my teenagers said that they could not believe that grown women were being so selfish. They both go to pop concerts and would be ecstatic if their friends got to meet their favourite star. Their would be none of this its not fair, I wanna go, let's throw a hissy fit and spit the dummy out of the pram mentality. As one said, "they behave like little kids who want an ice cream and can't have one and are throwing a tantrum in the supermarket". You should all be ashamed. I feel so bad for the fans who went and for the majority who I have seen watching who are desperate for more news from other fans and whose hopes could be dashed because some people behave like spoiled kids.
08-21-2011, 09:32 AM
Kalua
Seeing the way this thread is going and as I gave my word of honor that some of the elements of the M&G would remain confidential I'm closing this thread.
Please move to the reports threads so we all can enjoy what was said and done in New York.
- 08-20-2011, 10:45 PM
Meet And Greet 20th August 2011, Susan In New York.
Meet and Greet in New York, News On Susan In New York
Well, at last we can tell you what has been going on. We gave our word to Susan and to Andy that we would not say a word until now , and we are sure that you all understand that we could not break the trust which was placed in us.
As you know Susan has been in New York this week end. Knowing that Susan was going to be travelling to New York on business they decided that it would be a good opportunity to combine business with pleasure. They decided to arrange a meet and greet with some of of Susan’s fans and of course Susan was to be the guest of honour. Originally this was going to be a small group of 4/5 fans but about 2/3 weeks ago they decided to make it a much bigger occasion and go all out for a meet and greet with 20 or more fans. They don’t do things by halves do team Subo!
Now obviously some people will immediately want to know why this was not made public, why didn't everyonel know about it , why they were not invited, who decided who was going to go and how this all went down? That's a normal human reaction, and this is Susan we are talking about. We were not involved in deciding who went , and it is understood that team Subo have focused on folk whom Susan has never actually met. However Susan does like to have familiar faces present at these occasions so they contacted Grits T directly and asked that she and Randma would be involved. Andy Stephens suggested them because Susan knows, likes and gets on well with these ladies, and they were personally asked to attend and to liaise with the fans who would be attending and to organise the fun and games. Team Subo are in touch with fans from many places.
This event was set up at very short notice and we are amazed that Grits managed to pull it all together so quickly , so well done to her. She had about 24 hours in which to get every one organized and confirmed. Everyone then had to make their own travel arrangements. We understand that Team Subo provided hotel accommodation for all those attending and also the meal at the restaurant for the meet and greet. For some folk it was their first time in the big apple! We gather that it was all quite a mad scramble but that it all came together.
Grits enlisted some help from Janna55, (who unbeknown to us was going to be going along and like all of the attendees was sworn to secrecy), in organising the sequence of events and all of the ensuing fun. The fans all met at the St Andrews restaurant in New York, and they had exclusive use of two rooms for several hours. Fans with good memories may remember that in 2009 a large group of Susafans met there for an evening meal and that it is a well known Scottish themed restaurant in New York. There were several tables with ample room for all the Susan posters, Susan faces, and of course flat Susan was there as well. After the meal Susan went from table to table talking to all of the fans, also stopping for a wee chat with flat Susan along the way. As you might expect she made sure that everyone had the opportunity to talk to her. I am sure that many are looking forward to sharing their accounts of the occasion with you and relaying what Susan said to them. Susan was presented with some very special gifts and I am sure that, having contained the secret for what must seem like an eternity to them they will now all be bursting to tell you all about it. By all accounts Susan had an amazing time and so did those attending. They have till know been unable to share this with you at Susan and Andy's request, but they have now been given the green light to do so. We know that you will all want to share their joy with them and also Susan's joy as she so loves meeting with her fans; and to join together in celebrating the fact that so many were able to enjoy this wonderful and unique opportunity. Please be patient - they are currently on the way back to their hotel so we may have to wait a wee while for the first hand accounts..
- 08-20-2011, 10:47 PM
RIK Thanks!
Lots to digest here...
- 08-20-2011, 10:49 PM
Great! Waiting to hear accounts (and hopefully see pictures)
- 08-20-2011, 10:52 PM
Thank you Pickled Tink for this exciting news for Susan and about 20 fans. Waiting to hear from the fans in attendance. Lovely news.
- 08-20-2011, 10:52 PM
Awesome! :cool:
- 08-20-2011, 10:52 PM
:thanks: PT, I am looking forward to hearing every tidbit and Congrats to those in attendance, :fantastic:
- 08-20-2011, 10:52 PM
:popcorn:
Sure hope there's pictures - lots and lots of pictures!
- 08-20-2011, 10:54 PM
Thanks, PT. Pictures and accounts should be forthcoming soon. Know all had a wonderful time.
- 08-20-2011, 10:56 PM
RIK Full Disclosure Statement
"For The Record" I was asked via e-mail by GritsT to attend the M&G some weeks ago, was asked then to keep this confidential. I had to decline because of time contraints & economics. Congratulations to all those who did attend the event. Richard
- 08-20-2011, 11:00 PM
I wish that some of the rest of us could be invited sometimes.
I had figured out that one of the fans was going, and when Susan said on FB that she was going to meet some wonderful people thought there might be a fan meet. I'm glad that everyone who was invited got to see Susan though.
Please invite me next time. (I'm not selfish, am I? LOL) I was left out of the quilt presentation and went to LA the time Susan didn't get to perform. Surely hope to meet her one day.
Please everybody who went, post pictures and tell us all about it.
- 08-20-2011, 11:02 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by cac1936
Thanks, PT. Pictures and accounts should be forthcoming soon. Know all had a wonderful time.
Great news. Glad they had a big group, so we'll have lots of reports. And big cheers to Grits, Randma and Janna for being able to get it all organized on short notice. Never a dull moment in Subo fandom (or at least not for very long).
- 08-20-2011, 11:05 PM
Thanks PT and it’s already 11PM. I’m just wondering if I will be able to sleep. Great (and very hot) Sunday ahead! :smiley-bounce:
- 08-20-2011, 11:07 PM
I hope someday be invited as well. Congrats to all. Its wonderful. Waiting for pictures.
- 08-20-2011, 11:08 PM
wow, let's hear all about it you lucky fans
:popcorn::popcorn::popcorn:
- 08-20-2011, 11:12 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by jclar
I wish that some of the rest of us could be invited sometimes.
I had figured out that one of the fans was going, and when Susan said on FB that she was going to meet some wonderful people thought there might be a fan meet.
It is my understanding that with the exception of Grits T and Randma, who were specifically asked to attend for by Team Subo, not one single person attending has ever met Susan before. We understand that was a pre requisite of this event. I think we all wish that everyone could have been invited but I am sure that we also all realise that's just not possible. Team Subo has contact with fans who are not just members here and are free to invite whomsoever they wish. I think that we should just be happy for those that did get invited.
- 08-20-2011, 11:12 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Retired In Kalifornia
"For The Record" I was asked via e-mail by GritsT to attend the M&G some weeks ago, was asked then to keep this confidential. I had to decline because of time contraints & economics. Congratulations to all those who did attend the event. Richard
So sorry RIK, that you could not make it to NY.
- 08-20-2011, 11:15 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Pickled Tink
It is my understanding that with the exception of Grits T and Randma, who were specifically asked to attend for by Team Subo, not one single person attending has ever met Susan before. We understand that was a pre requisite of this event. I think we all wish that everyone could have been invited but I am sure that we also all realise that's just not possible. Team Subo has contact with fans who are not just members here and are free to invite whomsoever they wish. I think that we should just be happy for those that did get invited.
Absolutely.
- 08-20-2011, 11:29 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Pickled Tink
It is my understanding that with the exception of Grits T and Randma, who were specifically asked to attend for by Team Subo, not one single person attending has ever met Susan before. We understand that was a pre requisite of this event. I think we all wish that everyone could have been invited but I am sure that we also all realise that's just not possible. Team Subo has contact with fans who are not just members here and are free to invite whomsoever they wish. I think that we should just be happy for those that did get invited.
Good grief, I would hope Team Subo would invite people from other fan sites to the M&Gs. We're all united in the same purpose. In fact, I had been a little worried that perhaps this site was getting all the attention, because it was the first and is still the largest. I shouldn't have worried. No flies on Team Subo.
- 08-20-2011, 11:29 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Pickled Tink
It is my understanding that with the exception of Grits T and Randma, who were specifically asked to attend for by Team Subo, not one single person attending has ever met Susan before. We understand that was a pre requisite of this event. I think we all wish that everyone could have been invited but I am sure that we also all realise that's just not possible. Team Subo has contact with fans who are not just members here and are free to invite whomsoever they wish. I think that we should just be happy for those that did get invited.
That is just marvelous. Everybody who has never met Susan needs to. She is just such a joy. Congratulations to all who were there.:biggrin:
- 08-20-2011, 11:38 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by soothed
Makes me feel like a damn fool, but that's okay...not the first time.
Why on earth, would you feel like a damn fool, Soothed. Much as she loves us, Susan didn't fly to NY to just M&G with 20 fans. There's more to the story, which I'm sure will begin to unfold over the coming weeks. For openers, Susan had photogs with her in Tribeca. I'd be surprised if there weren't cameras at the M&G. Stay tuned.
- 08-20-2011, 11:38 PM
Just had an update.
All of the fans got to spend time with Susan in the second room, they took it in turns adn everyone had some one on one time with her. She was wearing a purple blouse and slacks. She arrived at 1.00 and left at 3.45.
She will sing one of her new songs on AGT :)
And........ THE LUCKY fans were asked to give up their cell phones, cameras etc.... and then they heard a couple of her new songs.... and now actually I think I hate them all..... :( ..... they said WOW WOW WOW ......
- 08-20-2011, 11:40 PM
I live in NYC (Manhattan) and met some wonderful fans from this site this summer at a Meet and Greet Lunch. I was so excited to hear that Susan is in the City and would have loved to be part of today's events.
- 08-20-2011, 11:42 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Pickled Tink
It is my understanding that with the exception of Grits T and Randma, who were specifically asked to attend for by Team Subo, not one single person attending has ever met Susan before. We understand that was a pre requisite of this event. I think we all wish that everyone could have been invited but I am sure that we also all realise that's just not possible. Team Subo has contact with fans who are not just members here and are free to invite whomsoever they wish. I think that we should just be happy for those that did get invited.
It's wonderful that fans that haven't met Susan before were invited to meet her this time. I'm wondering how other people who haven't met Susan can let her team know that they would also love to meet her someday.
- 08-20-2011, 11:44 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by antique
It's wonderful that fans that haven't met Susan before were invited to meet her this time. I'm wondering how other people who haven't met Susan can let her team know that they would also love to meet her someday.
I am wondering that too.
- 08-20-2011, 11:45 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Pickled Tink
Just had an update.
All of the fans got to spend time with Susan in the second room, they took it in turns adn everyone had some one on one time with her. She was wearing a purple blouse and slacks. She arrived at 1.00 and left at 3.45.
She will sing one of her new songs on AGT :)
And........ THE LUCKY fans were asked to give up their cell phones, cameras etc.... and then they heard a couple of her new songs.... and now actually I think I hate them all..... :( ..... they said WOW WOW WOW ......
PRIVATE CONCERT !!?!! AWESOME !! Good on them !! :clappinghands:
- 08-20-2011, 11:45 PM
May I ask what the criteria was for attending this M&G?
- 08-20-2011, 11:46 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Pickled Tink
Just had an update.
All of the fans got to spend time with Susan in the second room, they took it in turns adn everyone had some one on one time with her. She was wearing a purple blouse and slacks. She arrived at 1.00 and left at 3.45.
She will sing one of her new songs on AGT :)
And........ THE LUCKY fans were asked to give up their cell phones, cameras etc.... and then they heard a couple of her new songs.... and now actually I think I hate them all..... :( ..... they said WOW WOW WOW ......
WOW and WOW again PT. Everyone had a chance of a one to one with Susan? :shocked:
And do you mean she sangs two songs for the fans? Acapella? :happydancing::happydancing::happydancing:
:dance::smiley-bounce::dance::smiley-bounce::dance::smiley-bounce::dance::smiley-bounce::dance:
- 08-20-2011, 11:47 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Pickled Tink
Just had an update.
All of the fans got to spend time with Susan in the second room, they took it in turns adn everyone had some one on one time with her. She was wearing a purple blouse and slacks. She arrived at 1.00 and left at 3.45.
She will sing one of her new songs on AGT :)
And........ THE LUCKY fans were asked to give up their cell phones, cameras etc.... and then they heard a couple of her new songs.... and now actually I think I hate them all..... :( ..... they said WOW WOW WOW ......
Heard a couple of new songs? Live or recorded? Wow, now I wonder how they can keep quiet about what they heard. Hard to keep all that under your hat for over 2 months.
I laughed PT when you said "and now actually I think I hate them all".
Joan M
- 08-20-2011, 11:47 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Pickled Tink
Just had an update.
All of the fans got to spend time with Susan in the second room, they took it in turns adn everyone had some one on one time with her. She was wearing a purple blouse and slacks. She arrived at 1.00 and left at 3.45.
She will sing one of her new songs on AGT :)
And........ THE LUCKY fans were asked to give up their cell phones, cameras etc.... and then they heard a couple of her new songs.... and now actually I think I hate them all..... :( ..... they said WOW WOW WOW ......
Wonderful - but what is the date for AGT for sure :puzzled:
- 08-20-2011, 11:47 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by ZaSu
PRIVATE CONCERT !!?!! AWESOME !! Good on them !! :clappinghands:
I think I may know why it will be a while before we hear from them - on their way back to the hotel, they are probably walking on air!:laught2:
- 08-20-2011, 11:48 PM
WOW WOW WOW is this NEWS , NEWS , NEWS !!!:pompom::dance::clap::smiley-bounce:
Its like being splashed with a bucket of ice cold water to wake one up out of slumber so they are fully on alert from this time forth.
Okay .....I now see this is going to be a VERY 24/7 round the clock thread in the next 48 hours .
YIPPEE!! TWEET THE DETAILS FOR SURE !!!
- 08-20-2011, 11:48 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Pickled Tink
Just had an update.
All of the fans got to spend time with Susan in the second room, they took it in turns adn everyone had some one on one time with her. She was wearing a purple blouse and slacks. She arrived at 1.00 and left at 3.45.
She will sing one of her new songs on AGT :)
And........ THE LUCKY fans were asked to give up their cell phones, cameras etc.... and then they heard a couple of her new songs.... and now actually I think I hate them all..... :( ..... they said WOW WOW WOW ......
Holy Moly!!!! Wonder if the ones who were there can let us know what songs she sang??? I agree, PT, everyone there is now on my S list. LOL Just kidding, but am sure ready to get some news and pictures from the ones who were there.
- 08-20-2011, 11:49 PM
what date for AGT? so I can tape
- 08-20-2011, 11:50 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by trennie
Why on earth, would you feel like a damn fool, Soothed. Much as she loves us, Susan didn't fly to NY to just M&G with 20 fans. There's more to the story, which I'm sure will begin to unfold over the coming weeks. For openers, Susan had photogs with her in Tribeca. I'd be surprised if there weren't cameras at the M&G. Stay tuned.
I hope everyone had a wonderful time. I don't feel left out. I just don't like secrecy. How much more exciting if we had known that she was meeting fans and stories and pictures were coming soon, instead of wondering. I just like to have a good time here, and sometimes I may act childish, but I am not a child. I can handle the truth.I meant what I said on the other thread in a post to Lisa. I truly believe Susan loves us all, all over the world. I am more upset with myself for being so gullible. I won't make that mistake again.
- 08-20-2011, 11:50 PM
:yeewhooooo::fan_too_fast::beingfunny::bagpiper: I'm so excited I can't stand myself!
Hurry it up all you lucky people, we're waiting here with baited breath!!!!
- 08-20-2011, 11:51 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by bernicer
May I ask what the criteria was for attending this M&G?
As I pointed out this was not one of the forum meet and greets so we don't know. I would suggest that question is directed to Susan's management.
- 08-20-2011, 11:55 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Pickled Tink
Just had an update.
All of the fans got to spend time with Susan in the second room, they took it in turns adn everyone had some one on one time with her. She was wearing a purple blouse and slacks. She arrived at 1.00 and left at 3.45.
She will sing one of her new songs on AGT :)
And........ THE LUCKY fans were asked to give up their cell phones, cameras etc.... and then they heard a couple of her new songs.... and now actually I think I hate them all..... :( ..... they said WOW WOW WOW ......
Boy, is that good news. Particularly the review. WOW WOW WOW
- 08-20-2011, 11:57 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by blessdalotbysusan
WOW WOW WOW is this NEWS , NEWS , NEWS !!!:pompom::dance::clap::smiley-bounce:
Its like being splashed with a bucket of ice cold water to wake one up out of slumber so they are fully on alert from this time forth.
Okay .....I now see this is going to be a VERY 24/7 round the clock thread in the next 48 hours .
YIPPEE!! TWEET THE DETAILS FOR SURE !!!
I hope those guys aren't taking time to eat or any of that kind of stuff.
- 08-20-2011, 11:58 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Pickled Tink
As I pointed out this was not one of the forum meet and greets so we don't know. I would suggest that question is directed to Susan's management.
Thank you, will do.
- 08-21-2011, 12:00 AM
I feel sorry for those living in New York and are great fans of Susan. They must be hurting "just a little."
- 08-21-2011, 12:00 AM
I wish that her management could arrange a meet and greet that is not secret. There was a mention of scheduling one once, but it was in Las Vegas, and I think there was not enough interest although that is hard to imagine. Or course, her management does what they think is best for Susan, and her time in the US is valuable. Glad she got to do something fun.
- 08-21-2011, 12:04 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by soothed
I hope everyone had a wonderful time. I don't feel left out. I just don't like secrecy. How much more exciting if we had known that she was meeting fans and stories and pictures were coming soon, instead of wondering. I just like to have a good time here, and sometimes I may act childish, but I am not a child. I can handle the truth.I meant what I said on the other thread in a post to Lisa. I truly believe Susan loves us all, all over the world. I am more upset with myself for being so gullible. I won't make that mistake again.
Soothed, I don't understand why you say you were gullible? Because you didn't know this was going to happen? I don't think it was kept a secret in case we got too excited. But I seem to remember that it was explained some time ago when something similar had happened, that the reason for the secrecy was to ensure that the tabs and paps were kept out of the picture. As we know, we have people here who are on the lookout for any interesting news that might be passed on to the tabs as soon as they are aware of it. :smiley-rolleyes:
- 08-21-2011, 12:06 AM
:Ilovesusan::susanrocks:big grinI don't know why people get so upset. I am thrilled that many fans who had not met Susan got the chance. It's possible that her management could plan more of these meetings. How many celebrities even entertain the idea of meeting with their fans. Susan has a lot of fans, and not everyone is going to be chosen. Frankly, I am glad we get updates from those who attend these functions. I would certainly keep it a secret. I wouldn't want party crashers arriving to ruin the event. Can't wait to hear updates from the lucky 20 fans.
- 08-21-2011, 12:07 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by JudyMcKinn
I would imagine if it was announced, the place would be swarmed with hundreds of fans, and they couldn't have done anything as planned. I can understand completely why it needed to be kept quiet. I strongly suspect that this will be part of the documentary they are working on--Susan having a meet and greet with some of her fans. Wonder if some came from around the world, or just those close by? I wonder a lot of things--will you guys get busy sending us your stories and pictures, please? LOL
this reasoning makes sense to me, Judy
- 08-21-2011, 12:09 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Pickled Tink
As I pointed out this was not one of the forum meet and greets so we don't know. I would suggest that question is directed to Susan's management.
And how do we contact Susan's management?
- 08-21-2011, 12:10 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by skschulz43
:I don't know why people get so upset. I am thrilled that many fans who had not met Susan got the chance. ...I would certainly keep it a secret. I wouldn't want party crashers arriving to ruin the event. Can't wait to hear updates from the lucky 20 fans.
I completely agree. It was most considerate of them to include dedicated fans in their tight schedule and to make an effort to have folks that haven't met her their focus.
Well done!
- 08-21-2011, 12:11 AM
I am so happy for those who met Susan today and that they actually were able to hear two of Susan’s songs. I cannot wait to hear from them. I guess I can say I met Susan, though Susan didn’t know it. I still remember the hug I got at JFK airport. I can actually still feel it, let alone visualize it. WOW WOW WOW. I cannot wait to hear Susan’s new MUSIC.
- 08-21-2011, 12:11 AM
Whilst I understand that everyone wants to know how or why the people who attended got to go. Can I make the following points. This was not a forum meet and greet, there may be a lot of things we are not privy to and which they do not yet want us to know, they have their reasons, and we should respect them. So, maybe some of the comments and questions are perhaps not helpful. It is understandable that everyone wants to be there etc... .However, Susan has MILLIONS of fans and if there was a meet and greet every single day for the next ten years she could not meet them all. It's just not practicable. Yes of course everyone wants to meet her. Some of us have been very very lucky and we know that. Some have not been and I so wish that more folk had been. I also know that more folk will be in the future.
But can I ask you for for a few minutes to put yourselves in the shoes of those who have met Susan today. They have just had the time of their lives; they will be excited, over the moon, and just itching to share their news. They will come to the forum and what will they see? Posts which quite frankly seem a little resentful that some were chosen and they were not. How would you feel if that were you? There will always be someone who will be disappointed whatever criteria are used. But surely it is not too much to be happy that others got this opportunity and that they are willing to share it with you?
- 08-21-2011, 12:12 AM
I am glad Susan takes the time to connect with her fans. I feel lucky just to be involved long distance. Isn't it wonderful that our Fan Site has wonderful ladies that Susan likes enough to want to see them again and again. That says a lot about those fans and our Fan site as a whole. I thank my lucky stars that I joined and feel apart of it all. You have to remember that they do it the best way possible for Susan not us.
- 08-21-2011, 12:12 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by antique
It's wonderful that fans that haven't met Susan before were invited to meet her this time. I'm wondering how other people who haven't met Susan can let her team know that they would also love to meet her someday.
I think there must be a few million who fit the category of wanting to meet Susan! :biggrin:
- 08-21-2011, 12:13 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by UKSusanfanAnn
Apart from not having met Susan before, what is the criteria for being invited, I know its impossible to ask everyone. I am sure if it was announced on this closed thread and people were told that it was confidential and only a small gathering that we are all grown up enough to keep it to ourselves but would still then be able to enjoy the aniticipation, :(
JMHO, it sure would be nice to feel included instead of excluded.
- 08-21-2011, 12:19 AM
I'll say I'm shocked...to say the least. There are a lot of people right here on this Forum who have never met Susan. Am I delighted that there was a Meet and Greet (secret) in NY? No, not really. Not like this. Put myself in the shoes of people who attended? Can't bear to do it. Have I been negatively affected by this? Yes. There are fans, and then there are FANS.
- 08-21-2011, 12:20 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by bernicer
JMHO, it sure would be nice to feel included instead of excluded.
The Susan team are not doing themselves any favourites. They are alienating fans.
- 08-21-2011, 12:26 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by MollBobbers
Soothed, I don't understand why you say you were gullible? Because you didn't know this was going to happen? I don't think it was kept a secret in case we got too excited. But I seem to remember that it was explained some time ago when something similar had happened, that the reason for the secrecy was to ensure that the tabs and paps were kept out of the picture. As we know, we have people here who are on the lookout for any interesting news that might be passed on to the tabs as soon as they are aware of it. :smiley-rolleyes:
Why do I feel gullible? Because I should have picked up on it sooner. It is not the first time it has happened. I feel no animosity towards anyone who got to attend this fun event. I just had so much fun here yesterday that I didn't stop to think everything through as to what was going on. More power to them. Don't know really how to explain it, it is just kind of like a gotcha moment when you were not expecting it...lol
- 08-21-2011, 12:26 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Pickled Tink
, (excerpted)
But surely it is not too much to be happy that others got this opportunity and that they are willing to share it with you?
I, for one, (and surely there are others) am very happy for those who got to attend this M & G. As with so many other events before, there is a vicarious enjoyment, well-fleshed out by those who were there. Has it not always been our experience that those who attended any such event were gracious and generous with their time, stories, pictures, recollections, etc.? Can we not be equally gracious and generous with our appreciation for their good fortune and delight in being able to attend? I'm happy for them! :dance::Ilovesusan:
- 08-21-2011, 12:27 AM
I'm happy for the fans who were a part of this M&G especially the first timers. I'm looking forward to sharing the experience through reading their stories. How exciting!! I hope we hear from them soon.
:Ilovesusan:
- 08-21-2011, 12:28 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by andyp
Subo's team are doing all they can to alienate fans, for certain.
Well, I can certainly understand why there would be some "ruffled feathers" - this was handled poorly IMHO - no flames please.
- 08-21-2011, 12:28 AM
Im so happy for everyone that got to meet her. I hope one day Ill be able to make a trip to a meet and greet with her. :D
- 08-21-2011, 12:28 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by antique
And how do we contact Susan's management?
hahaha ... I think that's a secret. :D I wonder if MartyPA was one of the lucky members? I hope so. I notice she's not here commenting. hmmmmm? :p
- 08-21-2011, 12:29 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Retired In Kalifornia
"For The Record" I was asked via e-mail by GritsT to attend the M&G some weeks ago, was asked then to keep this confidential. I had to decline because of time contraints & economics. Congratulations to all those who did attend the event. Richard
"I too for the Record" was invited to attend this M&G some weeks ago, and was asked to keep this confidential as well. I had to heartbreakingly decline due to funding (as always-story of my life). I could not be more happy for those that could make it and meet the One and Only Miss Susan Boyle. Congratulations to you all. :D
- 08-21-2011, 12:31 AM
Well, I will probably never be able to meet Susan so I'm quite happy to see any pictures and read the reports of the lucky ones who get to meet with Susan. I'm just happy for those who had the opportunity. Get busy ladies - we are waiting.................
http://i717.photobucket.com/albums/w...s/32-thumb.gifhttp://i266.photobucket.com/albums/i...84runhappy.gifhttp://i717.photobucket.com/albums/w...s/32-thumb.gif
- 08-21-2011, 12:34 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by andyp
Subo's team are doing all they can to alienate fans, for certain.
Come on folks - it is a case of "damned if you do and damned if you don't" - let's be happy for those fortunates who attended, a day they will never forget - we can still speculate as to WHY she is in New York in the first instance and impatiently await AGT!
- 08-21-2011, 12:35 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Pickled Tink
Whilst I understand that everyone wants to know how or why the people who attended got to go. Can I make the following points. This was not a forum meet and greet, there may be a lot of things we are not privy to and which they do not yet want us to know, they have their reasons, and we should respect them. So, maybe some of the comments and questions are perhaps not helpful. It is understandable that everyone wants to be there etc... .However, Susan has MILLIONS of fans and if there was a meet and greet every single day for the next ten years she could not meet them all. It's just not practicable. Yes of course everyone wants to meet her. Some of us have been very very lucky and we know that. Some have not been and I so wish that more folk had been. I also know that more folk will be in the future.
But can I ask you for for a few minutes to put yourselves in the shoes of those who have met Susan today. They have just had the time of their lives; they will be excited, over the moon, and just itching to share their news. They will come to the forum and what will they see? Posts which quite frankly seem a little resentful that some were chosen and they were not. How would you feel if that were you? There will always be someone who will be disappointed whatever criteria are used. But surely it is not too much to be happy that others got this opportunity and that they are willing to share it with you?
I am very pleased for the fans, I just don't see the need for secrecy, it would have been the next best thing to have known about it and to have waited for posts with eager anticipation and I am sure if we were told that it was a small gathering the members would have respected that but felt involved. JMHO Sorry.
- 08-21-2011, 12:35 AM
:excellent:
Quote:
Originally Posted by MollBobbers
Soothed, I don't understand why you say you were gullible? Because you didn't know this was going to happen? I don't think it was kept a secret in case we got too excited. But I seem to remember that it was explained some time ago when something similar had happened, that the reason for the secrecy was to ensure that the tabs and paps were kept out of the picture. As we know, we have people here who are on the lookout for any interesting news that might be passed on to the tabs as soon as they are aware of it. :smiley-rolleyes:
- 08-21-2011, 12:37 AM
I regret to say I feel a little kicked in the gut. I am very happy for those who got to visit, but that does not quell my disappointment in how it all came about. JMHO.
- 08-21-2011, 12:37 AM
I may go down in history as the one fan she will never meet, but that is okay. I will always love her. She doesn't have to shake my hand to touch me. I do hope she is having fun.
- 08-21-2011, 12:39 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by bernicer
JMHO, it sure would be nice to feel included instead of excluded.
Was not going to post on this at all, as no doubt it will be another mark against me.
I am very happy for the fans who were there and would like to know who they are and what exciting things they have to say about the M&G. No resentment against them for being the chosen ones.
I would also like to request that perhaps Susan or Andy or Joanne or GritsT or Randma or whoever puts together the list of attendees would let everyone else know what the criteria are to be included in one of these exclusive events. Then maybe others could make themselves known to the right people. Since RIK was invited this was obviously nothing to do with proximity to NYC.
I am sure that I will never be invited, and I accept that, but it would be nice to give all the good people on this site a clue-and other sites as well.
All of this secrecy and exclusiveness is not what we would have expected from Susan, so it comes as a shock and a disappointment, I am not posting again on this, and I don't care what anyone thinks. I regret that the message will never get to Susan that people feel bad.
- 08-21-2011, 12:40 AM
Just because some dont see the need for secrecy does not mean that there was not a very good reason for tsecrecy on this occasion. We are not privy to everything. I have often been puzzled by things and thought "I really dont see why they do that" only for things to become clear further down the track. I suspect that this is one of those occasions. I am sure that things will be made clear all in good time.
- 08-21-2011, 12:40 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by UKSusanfanAnn
I am very pleased for the fans, I just don't see the need for secrecy, it would have been the next best thing to have known about it and to have waited for posts with eager anticipation and I am sure if we were told that it was a small gathering the members would have respected that but felt involved. JMHO Sorry.
Ann
While I understand your feelings, the secrecy was requested by Andy and there was nothing we could do.
- 08-21-2011, 12:42 AM
I'm sure ALL of us are disappointed that we weren't included, at least with the planning of it. But you know what, I'm a grown up and I can take it and I'm sure as heck not going to let it ruin my enjoyment of Susan's visit here. I don't care how it was planned, with Susan's best interest in mind, I'm sure. I'm just glad we now have SUSA NEWS, however it comes about.
- 08-21-2011, 12:42 AM
Mollbobbers, I felt gullible in that I should have picked up on the intrigue. I was having too much fun here yesterday, to notice. It has happened before and will probably happen again. No big thing in the scheme of things.
- 08-21-2011, 12:43 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by soothed
I may go down in history as the one fan she will never meet, but that is okay. I will always love her. She doesn't have to shake my hand to touch me. I do hope she is having fun.
Well said Soothed. I too will likely never meet Susan, but that does not change how much I love & admire her. Thanks for putting it into perspective.
- 08-21-2011, 12:43 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by soothed
Why do I feel gullible? Because I should have picked up on it sooner. It is not the first time it has happened. I feel no animosity towards anyone who got to attend this fun event. I just had so much fun here yesterday that I didn't stop to think everything through as to what was going on. More power to them. Don't know really how to explain it, it is just kind of like a gotcha moment when you were not expecting it...lol
Then we are all equally "gullible". Even though it has happened before, I don't think anyone picked up on it. Which I hope means that the tab spies didn't pick up on it either. That was the whole idea - and well done to them. The privacy of Susan and of her fans have been respected. And IMO it is even more exciting this way when we never guessed what was coming, to get such great news and to be able to look forward to twenty first-hand reports. Just can't wait. :happydancing::happydancing::happydancing:
- 08-21-2011, 12:44 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Retired In Kalifornia
"For The Record" I was asked via e-mail by GritsT to attend the M&G some weeks ago, was asked then to keep this confidential. I had to decline because of time contraints & economics. Congratulations to all those who did attend the event. Richard
"I also for the Record" was invited by GritsT to attend some weeks ago, but due to finacial reasons (as always with me), I had to heartbreakingly decline. I could not have been more happy and excited for those that got to go. I knew I was going to miss something great, and great it was I am sure! Congratulations to those that got to chat with The One, The Only, Miss Susan Boyle! :D
- 08-21-2011, 12:44 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Kalua
Ann
While I understand your feelings, the secrecy was requested by Andy and there was nothing we could do.
Thanks Kalua, I appreciate your reply and I appreciate your predicament, will say no more, except I look forward to member's reports, :thanks:
- 08-21-2011, 12:48 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by UKSusanfanAnn
I am very pleased for the fans, I just don't see the need for secrecy, it would have been the next best thing to have known about it and to have waited for posts with eager anticipation and I am sure if we were told that it was a small gathering the members would have respected that but felt involved. JMHO Sorry.
There seems to be a big lack of understanding that you can't whisper in the ear of people you want to know and do it on-line. If you want the whole world to know, just put it on-line. Can you imagine what would have happened if they put out the word in advance?
:eek2::eek:
- 08-21-2011, 12:49 AM
First I'd like to say I'm not the least bit concerned about not being invited because I would have declined anyway . But just an objective observation , I think the secrecy is a big mistake. It's not the part about not being invited that is insulting,it's keeping the meet and greet a secret. What's the point of it? Why all the scheming? Why did Tink say Grits had 24 hrs notice and RIK say he was invited weeks ago? It sends a message that they think Susan fans are dumb . Why does team Subo feel they have to manipulate Susan's fans to this extent? I'm merely curious.
- 08-21-2011, 12:51 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Henny
There seems to be a big lack of understanding that you can't whisper in the ear of people you want to know and do it on-line. If you want the whole world to know, just put it on-line. Can you imagine what would have happened if they put out the word in advance?
:eek2::eek:
http://www.villaspeople.com/images/r...bteaserimg.jpg
- 08-21-2011, 12:51 AM
It seems I'm not the only one with a kick in the stomach sort of feeling. Not a good ploy in my opinion, although it is wonderful that at least 20 fans had some pleasure.
- 08-21-2011, 12:52 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Henny
I think there must be a few million who fit the category of wanting to meet
Susan! :biggrin:
That's for sure. My thinking was since Susan is coming to LA for AGT that just in case there might be a M & G here, I wanted to let Susan's team know I haven't met her and would love to if they would be so kind as to invite me. I am so very happy for those who have met Susan today in NY and for everyone who has met her at any time before.
- 08-21-2011, 12:53 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Little Lulu
I'm sure ALL of us are disappointed that we weren't included, at least with the planning of it. But you know what, I'm a grown up and I can take it and I'm sure as heck not going to let it ruin my enjoyment of Susan's visit here. I don't care how it was planned, with Susan's best interest in mind, I'm sure. I'm just glad we now have SUSA NEWS, however it comes about.
:excellent::Ilovesusan::Its All Good:
- 08-21-2011, 12:53 AM
I can think of 20 folk right now who on reading this thread will be getting that kick in the stomach feeling and quite frankly they should not be!!!
- 08-21-2011, 12:53 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Henny
There seems to be a big lack of understanding that you can't whisper in the ear of people you want to know and do it on-line. If you want the whole world to know, just put it on-line. Can you imagine what would have happened if they put out the word in advance?
:eek2::eek:
Perhaps I am naive, but if I were told it was a small gathering I would not have gone and spoilt the party, not that I could have done anyway, being in the UK, I would have sat by my computer happily awaiting reports, as I will do for AGT.:)
- 08-21-2011, 12:55 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Robert the Bruce
http://www.villaspeople.com/images/r...bteaserimg.jpg
:rofl:<=3:overjoyed:
More truth than fiction!!!!
- 08-21-2011, 12:56 AM
:susanrocks:I am somewhat psychic. Lol I never get any tips on the stock market or what horse will win a race, but lots of my feelings about what is going on come true. I felt there was something different going on so I didn't post. I hope forum members,who were not invited-I wasn't invited either; will not get their knickers in a twist. I am sure that Susan's team did the best they could with the invites. I hope in the future Susan's website will keep us up to date better than they have.
:susanrocks::susanrocks: :biggrin:
- 08-21-2011, 12:57 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by bernicer
JMHO, it sure would be nice to feel included instead of excluded.
Bern, TRUST ME, if I could had been able to "share my slot" after declinging the offer to attend the first person I'd ask to go would be SusaFan Lorias as she's my Fans For Susan Boyle Websites "boss" and a good friend. Lori has number of disabilities, I'd do anything short of carrying her on my back to NYC from Indiana for her to see Susan. I'll glady give up my "slot" for anybody else, including transporting any fan between Cameron Park to CBS Television City within reasonable distance from California State Route 99 to see Susan perform on AGT - if she indeed does - late this month or next for free, including paying for overnight lodging if we couldn't make it a day trip. I'd offered last year to do something like this to see Susan at AGT & DWTS BTW.
- 08-21-2011, 12:58 AM
The one report I am most interested in is what we didn't get: info on what Susan is working on that took her to NY in the first place. This isn't info the m&g people would know, so the waiting will continue to find out what the heck Susan is up to.
- 08-21-2011, 12:59 AM
There will be other meet and greets everyone. Dont worry, be happy. :) Im sure no one on Susans team wanted us to get upset over this. They didnt mean for anyone to get mad.
- 08-21-2011, 01:00 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Henny
There seems to be a big lack of understanding that you can't whisper in the ear of people you want to know and do it on-line. If you want the whole world to know, just put it on-line. Can you imagine what would have happened if they put out the word in advance?
:eek2::eek:
But we did plan a very delightful, and open to anyone, dinner and brunch last year in NYC, to which Susan and Amber were invited. Right here on this forum. But there ARE reasons for what was planned this time, we just don't know what they were. In this day and age with I'm surprised they did it at all. I would feel horrible if something bad happened if the wrong people got wind of it. Just sayin.
- 08-21-2011, 01:01 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Lisa Pully
"I also for the Record" was invited by GritsT to attend some weeks ago, but due to finacial reasons (as always with me), I had to heartbreakingly decline. I could not have been more happy and excited for those that got to go. I knew I was going to miss something great, and great it was I am sure! Congratulations to those that got to chat with The One, The Only, Miss Susan Boyle! :D
Lisa, I'm heartbroken, let me know if such an opportunity comes up again I can help pay for the trip! Richard
- 08-21-2011, 01:01 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Pickled Tink
I can think of 20 folk right now who on reading this thread will be getting that kick in the stomach feeling and quite frankly they should not be!!!
PT, I am absolutely sure no one feels resentful of the members who have got to meet Susan, I am sure they are thrilled for them that is not the point. I personally am thrilled for everyone so please don't feel bad it is wonderful and good on them.:)
- 08-21-2011, 01:03 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Pickled Tink
I can think of 20 folk right now who on reading this thread will be getting that kick in the stomach feeling and quite frankly they should not be!!!
From my perspective, this unrest has nothing to do with the lucky 20 who got the privilege of meeting Susan. I am happy for them. I could not have gone even if invited, so it is not about me either. It is about treating us as if we are three and can't be trusted. I would have loved to have been informed and in on it, so to speak. My life needs all the excitement it can get, right at the moment. Also to make sure the invited were evenly represented from all fansites. JMHO
- 08-21-2011, 01:06 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Patriciasart
First I'd like to say I'm not the least bit concerned about not being invited because I would have declined anyway . But just an objective observation , I think the secrecy is a big mistake. It's not the part about not being invited that is insulting,it's keeping the meet and greet a secret. What's the point of it? Why all the scheming? Why did Tink say Grits had 24 hrs notice and RIK say he was invited weeks ago? It sends a message that they think Susan fans are dumb . Why does team Subo feel they have to manipulate Susan's fans to this extent? I'm merely curious.
You obviously misread or misunderstood what I said. RIK was contacted severl week ago. Grits had 24 hours notice to get them organised. In a 24 hours period 2/3 weeks ago Grits had to nail it all down so that everyone could make their travel arrangements.
The secrecy issue is something for which there is probably a very GOOD reason. When that reason is made public we may all understand. It is all too easy to jump to conclusions when we are not in the full possession of the facts. These people are professionals and they do not keep things secret just to annoy fans. Yes we are curious, and they understand that but they will reveal all when the time is right to do so. Their primary aim is to protect and support Susan and that should be ours as well. A little faith would not hurt now and again. I am not suggesting we all follow blindly, that would be naive in the extreme, but that that we actually wait and see for once and then if it turns out that the reasons dont stand up to scutiny - then and only then - do we start with the recriminations and what would be legitimate complaints.
- 08-21-2011, 01:06 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by ilovethesingingbird
:susanrocks:I am somewhat psychic. Lol I never get any tips on the stock market or what horse will win a race, but lots of my feelings about what is going on come true. I felt there was something different going on so I didn't post. I hope forum members,who were not invited-I wasn't invited either; will not get their knickers in a twist. I am sure that Susan's team did the best they could with the invites. I hope in the future Susan's website will keep us up to date better than they have.
:susanrocks::susanrocks: :biggrin:
So are you saying that if we keep in touch with you you will tell us? We do keep up to date, but this was done in secret, remember?
- 08-21-2011, 01:06 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by antique
And how do we contact Susan's management?
People from the northeast should have been invited first, IMHO- then Sony would have not had to pay expenses. I am puzzled by this, but i won't make any waves- I can get my questions answered in due time.
In the meantime, I have one- were the people there today filmed for use in the documentary? I am looking forward to reports from those fortunate enough to have been able to attend today.
- 08-21-2011, 01:06 AM
"I'm very excited to be in New York, it's so good to be back in this wonderful city. I've got a busy few days meeting some wonderful people and you'll be the first to hear my news when I can tell you." (Susan Boyle)
I am pleased that yet more fans got to meet with Susan "one to one" and that a good time was had by all. I also assume that, in the fullness of time, they will post their reports of this meet and greet to all of us here and on other sites so that we can share in their excitement and hopefully also get some idea of what transpired.
I, for one, look forward to that with great anticipation.
I am surmising that, on this occasion, the meet and greet involved such secrecy because it was more than just a meet and greet and that there may be other reasons, unknown to all of us at this moment, for such secrecy.
Maybe it would be prudent for us all to wait and hear from those in attendance and especially from Susan herself.
JMHO
- 08-21-2011, 01:08 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by andyp
The Susan team are not doing themselves any favourites. They are alienating fans.
Come on, Andy. You don't mean that. Look they're trying to launch Susan's all-important 3rd CD in the best way, possible. I'm sure the activities were filmed and some of that will be used for a later promotion. I understand that Susan needs a few familiar faces around her, because she is shy, but I think it's lovely she asked for the great proportion to be people she'd never met. And she got an audience to try out a couple of new songs on and got a great reaction. That must have been reassuring for her.
I don't know what the criteria were for choosing people to invite, but if it were me, I would have asked those who had volunteered the most time toward keeping the sites running.
I believe it had to be kept secret, because an awful lot of Susan fans live in and around NYC and they all would have wanted to go. And the group had to be kept small for the larger promotional purpose of the M&G. I understand some are offended by the knowledge that they weren't in on the secret and others were, but honestly, I don't see how it could have been done any other way.
The exciting times are just starting. The ones we've been waiting for all year. Let's not spoil it
- 08-21-2011, 01:13 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by donniecat
Well, I can certainly understand why there would be some "ruffled feathers" - this was handled poorly IMHO - no flames please.
I agree but there are fans who keep in constant contact with Susan's team- we are not one of them. I suppose they deserve to be the ones asked to put something like this together. It is just reality. I could not have gone to NY anyway with my back, had i been asked- but i am glad RIK was asked!!!!!!
- 08-21-2011, 01:15 AM
I am thrilled that these 20 people got to see Susan and hear her sing, can't wait for reports. I am also very disturbed by the negative and jealous comments by some of you.
- 08-21-2011, 01:15 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by soothed
I may go down in history as the one fan she will never meet, but that is okay. I will always love her. She doesn't have to shake my hand to touch me. I do hope she is having fun.
That goes for me too. Thanks for saying it so well. Also I just really want Susan to have that longevity,lots of it.
- 08-21-2011, 01:16 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by andyp
Andy may have been in the business for a long time, but he sure knows how to lose Susafans. This is the second time that he messsed up in my opinion. What a jerk. And please, mods, this is my honest opinion and I am entitled to it. No warnings, please. leave my post up if you are a democracy.
I believe Andy is a businessman and he takes the line of least resistance- if someone told him that they could guarantee a certain number of susan fans to show up at short notice, he took this person's assistance. It is not his fault- so do not blame him
- 08-21-2011, 01:17 AM
RIK On The Subject Of Who's Invited Or Not
Listen Carefully Folks:
- I was asked to attend the M&G.
- I wasn't told "critieria" why I was selected.
- I didn't ask as was told I need to reply immediately.
- There was no time to do e-mail ping-pong on this matter.
- GritsT HAD to work fast and I appreciated that!
- 08-21-2011, 01:18 AM
If Susan ever comes to Canada I'd love to meet her so take note Team Subo. Congratulations to the lucky 20 and where are you! We want details!!
- 08-21-2011, 01:24 AM
Don't want to make this a reply to anyone. Just wanted to say that if this or any other M&G or anything else "alienates" a Susan Boyle fan, then there is something mightily wrong, not with her management but with the fan themselves. If Andy decided secrecy was the way to go (and with the tabs being what they are) I can certainly understand it. If it was posted on the forum, you can bet your bottom dollar that it would have been posted elsewhere. Since it was limited to 20 people, how else does anything think it could have been handled differently? I am as avid a fan of Susan as anyone, but I don't have the need to meet her or even be invited to meet her to feel that way. I love her persona and I love her music. There seems to be an attitude that we should somehow be privileged to know everything she does or is doing and the reasons behind it. Wondering is fine. Speculation can be fun. But I do not think being loyal and supportive fans gives us any special "rights". I hope we will get pictures and news from those who were there. I can understand if we do not.
- 08-21-2011, 01:24 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by soothed
I may go down in history as the one fan she will never meet, but that is okay. I will always love her. She doesn't have to shake my hand to touch me. I do hope she is having fun.
No you won't, there are millions of us, lets be realistic. Susan can never meet us all. By meeting some and sharing time with them - knowing they will in turn share the experience with fans who were not there, is very generous of Susan and we're very lucky imo - those who do meet Susan, and those who get first hand accounts about it. Love your line, 'she doesn't have to shake my hand to touch me.' Eloquent and so very true :>)
- 08-21-2011, 01:24 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by diane wheldrake
I am thrilled that these 20 people got to see Susan and hear her sing, can't wait for reports. I am also very disturbed by the negative and jealous comments by some of you.
I suspect that's why no one has posted anything - in fear of being "flamed"
- 08-21-2011, 01:25 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by diane wheldrake
I am thrilled that these 20 people got to see Susan and hear her sing, can't wait for reports. I am also very disturbed by the negative and jealous comments by some of you.
Same here Diane, I am really sad to see all of this , and if I was one of the 20 and I was reading this thread I would not feel much like posting. Just listen to yourselves, ME ME ME.
- 08-21-2011, 01:25 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Clarissastarr
There will be other meet and greets everyone. Dont worry, be happy. :) Im sure no one on Susans team wanted us to get upset over this. They didnt mean for anyone to get mad.
You are so right. I am so surprised at some of the posts on here. I couldn't have gone if asked, and probably a lot of others couldn't have, either. And surely most of us realize why it couldn't be made public. Even tho this is a thread everyone can't read, we know there are some on here who are newspeople and or paps. If they had made it public, the whole thing would have been swarmed. I am so happy I am a member of this forum, so I can read about these meet and greets, and enjoy the pictures taken by those lucky enough to have gone.
I just hope the postings of some on this forum so far today doesn't turn Susan's people off from doing other meet and greets. If there are people keeping track of who might be good to invite next time, I would say a few have cooked their goose today. Please, everyone, let's enjoy the fun here, and enjoy Susan. We wouldn't know any of this if it wasn't for this forum.
- 08-21-2011, 01:25 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by cac1936
Don't want to make this a reply to anyone. Just wanted to say that if this or any other M&G or anything else "alienates" a Susan Boyle fan, then there is something mightily wrong, not with her management but with the fan themselves. If Andy decided secrecy was the way to go (and with the tabs being what they are) I can certainly understand it. If it was posted on the forum, you can bet your bottom dollar that it would have been posted elsewhere. Since it was limited to 20 people, how else does anything think it could have been handled differently? I am as avid a fan of Susan as anyone, but I don't have the need to meet her or even be invited to meet her to feel that way. I love her persona and I love her music. There seems to be an attitude that we should somehow be privileged to know everything she does or is doing and the reasons behind it. Wondering is fine. Speculation can be fun. But I do not think being loyal and supportive fans gives us any special "rights". I hope we will get pictures and news from those who were there. I can understand if we do not.
Bravo cac!
- 08-21-2011, 01:26 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by OGM45
I suspect that's why no one has posted anything - in fear of being "flamed"
I agree with you.
- 08-21-2011, 01:27 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by JudyMcKinn
You are so right. I am so surprised at some of the posts on here. I couldn't have gone if asked, and probably a lot of others couldn't have, either. And surely most of us realize why it couldn't be made public. Even tho this is a thread everyone can't read, we know there are some on here who are newspeople and or paps. If they had made it public, the whole thing would have been swarmed. I am so happy I am a member of this forum, so I can read about these meet and greets, and enjoy the pictures taken by those lucky enough to have gone.
I just hope the postings of some on this forum so far today doesn't turn Susan's people off from doing other meet and greets. If there are people keeping track of who might be good to invite next time, I would say a few have cooked their goose today. Please, everyone, let's enjoy the fun here, and enjoy Susan. We wouldn't know any of this if it wasn't for this forum.
Thank you Judy! Ditto
- 08-21-2011, 01:28 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by diane wheldrake
I am thrilled that these 20 people got to see Susan and hear her sing, can't wait for reports. I am also very disturbed by the negative and jealous comments by some of you.
Diane, I think I have proved myself to be a true and loyal fan of both Susan and the Forum, so I can assure you I am not the least bit jealous of the fans who were invited, I am truely pleased for them, I would have just liked to have kn own about it to enjoy the anticipation and feel involved but possibly as stevieboy has said there are reasons for the secrecy, I hope so. :)
- 08-21-2011, 01:29 AM
:excellent::excellent::excellent:
Quote:
Originally Posted by cac1936
Don't want to make this a reply to anyone. Just wanted to say that if this or any other M&G or anything else "alienates" a Susan Boyle fan, then there is something mightily wrong, not with her management but with the fan themselves. If Andy decided secrecy was the way to go (and with the tabs being what they are) I can certainly understand it. If it was posted on the forum, you can bet your bottom dollar that it would have been posted elsewhere. Since it was limited to 20 people, how else does anything think it could have been handled differently? I am as avid a fan of Susan as anyone, but I don't have the need to meet her or even be invited to meet her to feel that way. I love her persona and I love her music. There seems to be an attitude that we should somehow be privileged to know everything she does or is doing and the reasons behind it. Wondering is fine. Speculation can be fun. But I do not think being loyal and supportive fans gives us any special "rights". I hope we will get pictures and news from those who were there. I can understand if we do not.
- 08-21-2011, 01:29 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by terijay7
I believe this was something that was done for the documentary- the fact that several have come forward and said they were invited ( weeks ago) to be in NYC today, shows that they did not mention it either. So, it was secret, because the producers who wanted footage wanted it kept that way- still-- it does make some fans a little less trustful of the way it was kept secret- remnds me of the scene in the film "Guys and Dolls"- where the character says he can produce 20 qualified sinners in 24 hours- someone was contacted by Susans team and did just that. I do not think we should bash the person contacted, however. It was not their doing. This person- appears to be Grits-- arranged things and did so because she was asked to do so. No point in bashing her.
There's no point in bashing anyone, Teri. It is a shame if that is what happens.
- 08-21-2011, 01:31 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by ilovethesingingbird
:susanrocks:I am somewhat psychic. Lol I never get any tips on the stock market or what horse will win a race, but lots of my feelings about what is going on come true. I felt there was something different going on so I didn't post. I hope forum members,who were not invited-I wasn't invited either; will not get their knickers in a twist. I am sure that Susan's team did the best they could with the invites. I hope in the future Susan's website will keep us up to date better than they have.
:susanrocks::susanrocks: :biggrin:
Well, I wouldn't count on the website, but I do agree Susan's team has probably learned from this. Susan is not an ordinary global star and neither are her fans and it's a mistake to give the impression, wrongly I'm sure, that there is an "inner circle" of select fans, privy to secret information. There are other ways I believe to winnow the crowd. Maybe by lottery.
I'm not speaking personally. I don't care. I just want Susan to sell lots of CDs, make lots of money and live happily ever after. But obviously some do.
It would help if the folks, who were there, would get on the stick and report. As chosen representatives of Subo Fandom they are privileged but timely reporting is also the responsibility.
- 08-21-2011, 01:32 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by cac1936
Don't want to make this a reply to anyone. Just wanted to say that if this or any other M&G or anything else "alienates" a Susan Boyle fan, then there is something mightily wrong, not with her management but with the fan themselves. If Andy decided secrecy was the way to go (and with the tabs being what they are) I can certainly understand it. If it was posted on the forum, you can bet your bottom dollar that it would have been posted elsewhere. Since it was limited to 20 people, how else does anything think it could have been handled differently? I am as avid a fan of Susan as anyone, but I don't have the need to meet her or even be invited to meet her to feel that way. I love her persona and I love her music. There seems to be an attitude that we should somehow be privileged to know everything she does or is doing and the reasons behind it. Wondering is fine. Speculation can be fun. But I do not think being loyal and supportive fans gives us any special "rights". I hope we will get pictures and news from those who were there. I can understand if we do not.
:excellent: Of course, you speak great sense carol, it just would have been lovely to have it to look forward to but in the real world I guess it is not possible. Will delete some of my posts.:)
- 08-21-2011, 01:33 AM
I was invited with the criteria that I had NOT met Susan before. I had met Susan in NYC in 2009, so I relinguished my spot to someone who had not met Susan. I can assure you that I have no priviliege with Susan's team or administration of this website. I Believe I was chosen randomly. I do believe that those who met Susan today felt at the top of the world as I did in 2009, and it lives with me still.
- 08-21-2011, 01:33 AM
Ok all you lucky dogs, POST we love you and we love Susan. We are sittin here on the edge of ours seats. Except Teri, that is, she's got to be careful.
- 08-21-2011, 01:35 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Retired In Kalifornia
Lisa, I'm heartbroken, let me know if such an opportunity comes up again I can help pay for the trip! Richard
RIK my dear friend, you are making me cry this very moment. :'(:hug: I love you my friend. After last years trip to NYC to see Susan perform (which I am still over the moon over with) I really do not think I could accept, I do not think it would be right. I am not so desirving of your generious kindness. You mean more to me then you know. :hug-2:
- 08-21-2011, 01:35 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by trennie
Well, I wouldn't count on the website, but I do agree Susan's team has probably learned from this. Susan is not an ordinary global star and neither are her fans and it's a mistake to give the impression, wrongly I'm sure, that there is an "inner circle" of select fans, privy to secret information. There are other ways I believe to winnow the crowd. Maybe by lottery.
I'm not speaking personally. I don't care. I just want Susan to sell lots of CDs, make lots of money and live happily ever after. But obviously some do.
It would help if the folks, who were there, would get on the stick and report. As chosen representatives of Subo Fandom they are privileged but timely reporting is also the responsibility.
Why would they want to post here? They likely don't want to read all the negative they most probably would get
- 08-21-2011, 01:36 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Pickled Tink
You obviously misread or misunderstood what I said. RIK was contacted severl week ago. Grits had 24 hours notice to get them organised. In a 24 hours period 2/3 weeks ago Grits had to nail it all down so that everyone could make their travel arrangements.
The secrecy issue is something for which there is probably a very GOOD reason. When that reason is made public we may all understand. It is all too easy to jump to conclusions when we are not in the full possession of the facts. These people are professionals and they do not keep things secret just to annoy fans. Yes we are curious, and they understand that but they will reveal all when the time is right to do so. Their primary aim is to protect and support Susan and that should be ours as well. A little faith would not hurt now and again. I am not suggesting we all follow blindly, that would be naive in the extreme, but that that we actually wait and see for once and then if it turns out that the reasons dont stand up to scutiny - then and only then - do we start with the recriminations and what would be legitimate complaints.
Thank you PT for being the voice of reason.
- 08-21-2011, 01:37 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by cmenard23
I was invited with the criteria that I had NOT met Susan before. I had met Susan in NYC in 2009, so I relinguished my spot to someone who had not met Susan. I can assure you that I have no priviliege with Susan's team or administration of this website. I Believe I was chosen randomly. I do believe that those who met Susan today felt at the top of the world as I did in 2009, and it lives with me still.
YOU, are "true" Susan fan. It's something Susan would do. Thank you.
- 08-21-2011, 01:37 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by stevieboy49
"I'm very excited to be in New York, it's so good to be back in this wonderful city. I've got a busy few days meeting some wonderful people and you'll be the first to hear my news when I can tell you." (Susan Boyle)
I am pleased that yet more fans got to meet with Susan "one to one" and that a good time was had by all. I also assume that, in the fullness of time, they will post their reports of this meet and greet to all of us here and on other sites so that we can share in their excitement and hopefully also get some idea of what transpired.
I, for one, look forward to that with great anticipation.
I am surmising that, on this occasion, the meet and greet involved such secrecy because it was more than just a meet and greet and that there may be other reasons, unknown to all of us at this moment, for such secrecy.
Maybe it would be prudent for us all to wait and hear from those in attendance and especially from Susan herself.
JMHO
Well said, Stevieboy!
- 08-21-2011, 01:38 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by OGM45
Why would they want to post here? They likely don't want to hear all the negative they most likely would get
Hopefully they will post here because they understand that most of Susan's fans here are eagerly looking forward to hearing all about their adventure - what Susan said, what Susan did, how Susan looked.... and maybe a word or two about themselves. lol
Come on folks - as trennie fairly said - timely reporting is a responsibility and I have started timing you.:biggrin:
- 08-21-2011, 01:38 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by cac1936
There's no point in bashing anyone, Teri. It is a shame if that is what happens.
I agree- no point in bashing anyone. It is what it is....we are all Susan fans and want to hear about the times they had today-- i am just shooting off my first reactions- but- my reactions are not negative towards the lucky fans- not at all. I want that to be clear.
- 08-21-2011, 01:41 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by CanadianBill
Hopefully they will post here because they understand that most of Susan's fans here are eagerly looking forward to hearing all about their adventure - what Susan said, what Susan did, how Susan looked.... and maybe a word or two about themselves. lol
Come on folks - as trennie fairly said - timely reporting is a responsibility and I have started timing you.:biggrin:
Thanks Bill, we need some humor here. LOL
- 08-21-2011, 01:44 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by CanadianBill
Hopefully they will post here because they understand that most of Susan's fans here are eagerly looking forward to hearing all about their adventure - what Susan said, what Susan did, how Susan looked.... and maybe a word or two about themselves. lol
Come on folks - as trennie fairly said - timely reporting is a responsibility and I have started timing you.:biggrin:
I do hope they will post their exciting and unforgettable time. I'm looking forward to it, but if they don't I will understand
- 08-21-2011, 01:44 AM
I'm ready for the reports! :thirsty::popcorn::D
- 08-21-2011, 01:44 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Pickled Tink
You obviously misread or misunderstood what I said. RIK was contacted severl week ago. Grits had 24 hours notice to get them organised. In a 24 hours period 2/3 weeks ago Grits had to nail it all down so that everyone could make their travel arrangements. The secrecy issue is something for which there is probably a very GOOD reason. When that reason is made public we may all understand. It is all too easy to jump to conclusions when we are not in the full possession of the facts. These people are professionals and they do not keep things secret just to annoy fans. Yes we are curious, and they understand that but they will reveal all when the time is right to do so. Their primary aim is to protect and support Susan and that should be ours as well. A little faith would not hurt now and again. I am not suggesting we all follow blindly, that would be naive in the extreme, but that that we actually wait and see for once and then if it turns out that the reasons dont stand up to scutiny - then and only then - do we start with the recriminations and what would be legitimate complaints.
Thanx for explaining this misunderstanding,LOL! big grin I guess all the secrecy seems silly to me but maybe it is a PR ploy . Oh well,that's show biz big grin
- 08-21-2011, 01:44 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Lisa Pully
RIK my dear friend, you are making me cry this very moment. :'(:hug: I love you my friend. After last years trip to NYC to see Susan perform (which I am still over the moon over with) I really do not think I could accept, I do not think it would be right. I am not so desirving of your generious kindness. You mean more to me then you know. :hug-2:
Lisa, my regret is there was no time to let Lorias much less you or anybody else to be substituted for today's M&G. GritsT et.al. setting it up "from the fandom side" had to work fast as those putting on the M&G wanted those who could be there - there - and as many possible who never met Susan before and that so happened to include me. There WILL be other opportunities to meet with Susan, I'll settle seeing her on AGT IF she does appear on it next few weeks. I just envy those lucky SusaFans who got to her Susan sing not one but TWO new songs today - man how I just wish!
- 08-21-2011, 01:45 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Little Lulu
Ok all you lucky dogs, POST we love you and we love Susan. We are sittin here on the edge of ours seats. Except Teri, that is, she's got to be careful.
you got that right- i have to refill the hot water bottle and I am NOT kidding :'(:'(
- 08-21-2011, 01:47 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by time2live
I'm ready for the reports! :thirsty::popcorn::D
Yeah, me too. I already poured my beer. :biggrin:
- 08-21-2011, 01:48 AM
i would like to hear about the songs she sang- were they new ones? That i would love to know
- 08-21-2011, 01:48 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Cee
I'll say I'm shocked...to say the least. There are a lot of people right here on this Forum who have never met Susan. Am I delighted that there was a Meet and Greet (secret) in NY? No, not really. Not like this. Put myself in the shoes of people who attended? Can't bear to do it. Have I been negatively affected by this? Yes. There are fans, and then there are FANS.
Hopefully speaking from an objective viewpoint, being too far away to ever have been "invited" - the issue seems to be how some are worthy of being invited, and others are not. Huge disappointment for those who are relegated to the second category. The secrecy does seem hard to figure, because on other occasions they want a crowd for publicity purposes. Would it matter if the media knew about the meeting? The restaurant could have removed any obvious paparazzi. The World Fan Meeting was open to all fans, was wonderfully well organised and was not secret. As far as I am aware, there were no problems with intrusive media.
- 08-21-2011, 01:49 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by OGM45
Why would they want to post here? They likely don't want to read all the negative they most probably would get
Once we get news, I think we'll lose the negative comments. At the end of the day, we're all here for Susan and what we're interested in Susan's mood, what she says, what she sings (or if not that, at least whether they were good songs) and generally if the prospects for the Fall are bright.
- 08-21-2011, 01:49 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by terijay7
i would like to hear about the songs she sang- were they new ones? That i would love to know
Tink said they were Teri...and you gotta know WHICH one I'm praying for here!
- 08-21-2011, 01:49 AM
Ok folks if we want to know how that M&G went, better stop all this.
If I were one of the fans there, only by reading all that has been posted I would run away.
Whatever the reasons for the requested secrecy, what we have to do now is appreciate the reports
which I sincerely hope will be forthcoming.
I intend to enjoy them fully.
- 08-21-2011, 01:51 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Helen101
Hopefully speaking from an objective viewpoint, being too far away to ever have been "invited" - the issue seems to be how some are worthy of being invited, and others are not. Huge disappointment for those who are relegated to the second category. The secrecy does seem hard to figure, because on other occasions they want a crowd for publicity purposes. Would it matter if the media knew about the meeting? The restaurant could have removed any obvious paparazzi. The World Fan Meeting was open to all fans, was wonderfully well organised and was not secret. As far as I am aware, there were no problems with intrusive media.
As Tink has said, this was done by Susan's PR and Mgt Team contacting people-- beyond that, that is all i will say.
They needed bodies. I do not think they were thinking they were hurting anyone's feelings really. Just my take.
- 08-21-2011, 01:52 AM
I'm sitting at the edge of my seat waiting for some reports. PLEASE!!! :biggrin::biggrin:
Waiting, waiting, waiting......
:popcorn::popcorn:
- 08-21-2011, 01:53 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by trennie
Once we get news, I think we'll lose the negative comments. At the end of the day, we're all here for Susan and what we're interested in Susan's mood, what she says, what she sings (or if not that, at least whether they were good songs) and generally if the prospects for the Fall are bright.
Yes agree trennie, I apologise for my negativity, was just a bit disappointed but please please everybody post soon as it is getting very late here in the UK, LOL.:biggrin:
- 08-21-2011, 01:53 AM
I am so happy for the 20 fans who met Susan today. I can't wait to hear their reports!!! big grin
- 08-21-2011, 01:54 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Kalua
Ok folks if we want to know how that M&G went, better stop all this.
If I were one of the fans there, only by reading all that has been posted I would run away.
Whatever the reasons for the requested secrecy, what we have to do now is appreciate the reports
which I sincerely hope will be forthcoming.
I intend to enjoy them fully.
Hey, not all of us are b.....!!!!!!!!.
- 08-21-2011, 01:54 AM
I personally have no interest ever to meet Susan that does not make me less of a fan I hope...:hiding:
Secrecy bothers me and I do not trust people who engage in it no matter the reason.
I am happy for the 20 fans and I am sure they are having a great time.
Maybe we hear from them maybe we do not maybe that is secret too...Who knows....We see.:biggrin:
- 08-21-2011, 01:54 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Kalua
Ok folks if we want to know how that M&G went, better stop all this.
If I were one of the fans there, only by reading all that has been posted I would run away.
Whatever the reasons for the requested secrecy, what we have to do now is appreciate the reports
which I sincerely hope will be forthcoming.
I intend to enjoy them fully.
Me too, Kalua, but maybe in the morning now,:smiley-rolleyes:
- 08-21-2011, 01:55 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by terijay7
As Tink has said, this was done by Susan's PR and Mgt Team contacting people-- beyond that, that is all i will say.
They needed bodies. I do not think they were thinking they were hurting anyone's feelings really. Just my take.
Teri, that's the clearest statement of truth I've read so far today, thank you :love: Richard
- 08-21-2011, 01:57 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by UKSusanfanAnn
Yes agree trennie, I apologise for my negativity, was just a bit disappointed but please please everybody post soon as it is getting very late here in the UK, LOL.:biggrin:
You don't have anything to apologize for Ann. You do more for this Forum than many. Everybody has a right to express disappointment.
- 08-21-2011, 01:58 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Retired In Kalifornia
Teri, that's the clearest statement of truth I've read so far today, thank you :love: Richard
well it just seems true. this was not a regular meet and greet. It could have been done better though. But, I can take that up with a person that has nothing to do with this forum for the future.
- 08-21-2011, 01:58 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by terijay7
As Tink has said, this was done by Susan's PR and Mgt Team contacting people-- beyond that, that is all i will say.
They needed bodies. I do not think they were thinking they were hurting anyone's feelings really. Just my take.
I think you are right, but I also think they should have given more consideration to the feelings of her other fans. They have alienated a lot of fans, even though unintentionally, by the way they have handled this.
- 08-21-2011, 01:58 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by UKSusanfanAnn
Me too, Kalua, but maybe in the morning now,:smiley-rolleyes:
Well. it's only 8pm EST.
- 08-21-2011, 01:59 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by trennie
You don't have anything to apologize for Ann. You do more for this Forum than many. Everybody has a right to express disappointment.
:hug: and goodnight, looking forward to reports in the morning, :goodnight:
- 08-21-2011, 02:00 AM
MY HEART IS RACING, TEARS ARE FLOWING...WOW!!! WHAT GREAT NEWS!!! Our Susan and Andy are the absolute BEST, aren't they?! Imagine...faithful fans who had never had an opportunity to meet Susan in person, finally experienced that JOY of spending quality moments with her, and even had their hotel and meal arrangements comped! SPEAKING OF DREAMS COMING TRUE!
AND, YES, GRITS IS ABSOLUTELY THE BEST OF THE BEST ORGANIZER, AND DEVOUT SUSAFAN. IT WILL BE SO EXCITING TO HEARJUST WHO WAS ABLE TO BE INCLUDED IN THIS GLORIOUS EVENT.
THANKS, PT, FOR SHARING THE JOYOUS NEWS WITH OUR FORUM FAN FAMILY! Hugs, Trish
- 08-21-2011, 02:00 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by trennie
Well. it's only 8pm EST.
It's 1am in the UK trennie, I need my beauty sleep, I wish, lol
- 08-21-2011, 02:01 AM
Randma & GritsT, please post if you ladies can. I see you all are viewing this thread :D:D:D:D:D.
- 08-21-2011, 02:01 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by trennie
You don't have anything to apologize for Ann. You do more for this Forum than many. Everybody has a right to express disappointment.
And my post was for those who were disappointed. I feel very sorry for them. For those who were invited it would have been absolutely wonderful.
- 08-21-2011, 02:01 AM
hoping toreturn a bit later and hear what songs Miss Boyle was singing- my back is in spasms- so blows!!! even with the hot water bottle- sitting is the worst thing in the world for a compressed lumbar disk- makes me mad as a hatter, more so than i can say!
- 08-21-2011, 02:03 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Retired In Kalifornia
"For The Record" I was asked via e-mail by GritsT to attend the M&G some weeks ago, was asked then to keep this confidential. I had to decline because of time contraints & economics. Congratulations to all those who did attend the event. Richard
At least you, of all people should have been invited, and I'm thankful you were, Richard, for you do so much to ferret out Susanews for all of us to enjoy! Thanks for your service to Susan's fan family! We love you!
- 08-21-2011, 02:03 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by diane wheldrake
I am thrilled that these 20 people got to see Susan and hear her sing, can't wait for reports. I am also very disturbed by the negative and jealous comments by some of you.
Me too.
- 08-21-2011, 02:06 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by trennie
Great news. Glad they had a big group, so we'll have lots of reports. And big cheers to Grits, Randma and Janna for being able to get it all organized on short notice. Never a dull moment in Subo fandom (or at least not for very long).
Yes, I agree...with Grits, Carol, and Janna organizing the gathering, a great time would be guaranteed!
- 08-21-2011, 02:06 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Trish (Pat Pierce)
At least you, of all people should have been invited, and I'm thankful you were, Richard, for you do so much to ferret out Susanews for all of us to enjoy! Thanks for your service to Susan's fan family! We love you!
Me too RIK, I wish you could have gone.
- 08-21-2011, 02:06 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by terijay7
well it just seems true. this was not a regular meet and greet. It could have been done better though. But, I can take that up with a person that has nothing to do with this forum for the future.
Teri, I think that Tink and Kalua will also pass it on as well. And perhaps, members of other sites, who had reps there.
- 08-21-2011, 02:08 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by trennie
Yes, Teri, that's what they did and where their mistake lay. They treated fans as "bodies" and not as people. Producers may be able to get away with this with Bieber and Swift fans. It's dangerous with the "boomer" cohort.
Calling the fans bodies is insulting, and I do not think Andy decided they needed bodies.
I would like to assume that some of the fans present there were chosen by Susan.
Frankly I'm appaled with this kind of vocabulary, this is not animal farm it is a fansite!!!
- 08-21-2011, 02:08 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by kathymc
Me too.
What you both said. There is no reason at all for disappointment and jealousy.
- 08-21-2011, 02:08 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by trennie
Yes, Teri, that's what they did and where their mistake lay. They treated fans as "bodies" and not as people. Producers may be able to get away with this with Bieber and Swift fans. It's dangerous with the "boomer" cohort.
Yes, Susan fans are like no other fans. We're not fans of just Susan's music. We are fans of her magic, that has touched us all.
- 08-21-2011, 02:08 AM
RIK What A GREAT Friend!
Quote:
Originally Posted by bernicer
Me too RIK, I wish you could have gone.
:love2:
- 08-21-2011, 02:14 AM
Why is it I don't feel like pick of the litter?...lol Come on , we might as well have fun with it all...
- 08-21-2011, 02:16 AM
Dear Pickled Tink,
Thank you so much my dear Susafriend, for these great News.
I'm so happy for you all and for Susan.
I can't wait to hear more and to have some lovely and funny Pics.
I can imagine Susan talking to Flat Susan.....LOL
Susahugs xxxx :yeewhooooo::yeewhooooo::thanks::thanks::pompom::p ompom:
- 08-21-2011, 02:16 AM
:Its All Good:
Thanks, Kalua...and I intend to join you in celebration!!!
How blessed we are that those who were so fortunate to attend, will be willing to share their joys with the rest of us. We've been longing for something new and refreshing to celebrate, and now we have their moments to cherish...so let's get on board and enjoy their memories by celebrating with them!!!
AS YOU IMMERSE YOURSELF VICARIOUSLY IN THEIR JOY, SUSAFRIENDS, YOU WILL VICARIOUSLY EXPERIENCE THE JOY YOURSELVES!
- 08-21-2011, 02:18 AM
I for one, am anxiously awaiting any news about the M & G from Grits and Randma as well as any others who might have been in attendance!!! We have been in a drought for news for soooo long, and new news would "make my day". I will bask in the joy!
- 08-21-2011, 02:19 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by andyp
Andy may have been in the business for a long time, but he sure knows how to lose Susafans. This is the second time that he messsed up in my opinion. What a jerk. And please, mods, this is my honest opinion and I am entitled to it. No warnings, please. leave my post up if you are a democracy.
Saying this about Andy seems to me to be showing a complete disrespect for Susan. On this forum one common bond we have all shared is wanting the best for Susan. That has included having Andy as her manager. Susan obviously respects him and his handling of her and her career. I care about Susan's opinion first and foremost.
- 08-21-2011, 02:23 AM
Mods, given the tone of this thread, is it possible to close this thread & start a new one dedicated to the fans who were there & their reports.
I too have expressed my feelings regarding this, however, I feel maybe it is time this thread is put to bed & we celebrate in the reports we will receive from those who were there. JMHO.
- 08-21-2011, 02:24 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by soothed
Why is it I don't feel like pick of the litter?...lol Come on , we might as well have fun with it all...
We can't have you feeling like that soothed! Here - now you ARE the pick of the litter!
http://i56.tinypic.com/2e4wvo6.jpg
:p:p
- 08-21-2011, 02:24 AM
Thank you Trish. I so agree. We've got great news coming.:Its All Good::Ilovesusan:
- 08-21-2011, 02:25 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by CanadianBill
We can't have you feeling like that soothed! Here - now you ARE the pick of the litter!
http://i56.tinypic.com/2e4wvo6.jpg
:p:p
That may even be better than the Susa-Statue of Liberty CBill! big grin
- 08-21-2011, 02:25 AM
There are 8 of us in a hotel room in NY and we are saddened by the derision on this thread. Please know that I considered it a great honor to be asked to organize this event, I was given very specific instructions, and I did it for Susan.
We had an absolutely wonderful afternoon - it ranks right up there with a wedding and/or the birth of a child!
Susan was in grand form, dressed in jeans and a purple top. Her hair was bobbed, tousled and darling. We welcomed her with a Hello, Susan version of Hello, Dolly and she danced her way into the room. Each fan had special one-on-one time with her. We presented her with flat Susan and an album of fan pictures with fS. We did a bit of line dancing to NY, NY. We were told that Susan WILL be on AGT 8/31! Andy is a gentleman and adores Susan (but you all already know that!)
Susan was relaxed, comfortable, loving and hilarious. If I had my fondest wish granted, it would be that each and all of you could have been there.
- 08-21-2011, 02:28 AM
QUOTE=GritsT;559710]There are 8 of us in a hotel room in NY and we are saddened by the derision on this thread. Please know that I considered it a great honor to be asked to organize this event, I was given very specific instructions, and I did it for Susan.
We had an absolutely wonderful afternoon - it ranks right up there with a wedding and/or the birth of a child!
Susan was in grand form, dressed in jeans and a purple top. Her hair was bobbed, tousled and darling. We welcomed her with a Hello, Susan version of Hello, Dolly and she danced her way into the room. Each fan had special one-on-one time with her. We presented her with flat Susan and an album of fan pictures with fS. We did a bit of line dancing to NY, NY. We were told that Susan WILL be on AGT 8/31! Andy is a gentleman and adores Susan (but you all already know that!)
Susan was relaxed, comfortable, loving and hilarious. If I had my fondest wish granted, it would be that each and all of you could have been there.[/QUOTE]
Thanks for the report GritsT. I am so glad to hear it was a spectacular experience for all!
:Ilovesusan::susanrocks:[
- 08-21-2011, 02:28 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by CanadianBill
We can't have you feeling like that soothed! Here - now you ARE the pick of the litter!
http://i56.tinypic.com/2e4wvo6.jpg
:p:p
HAHAHAHAHA....Okay, who is the guy? You? lol
- 08-21-2011, 02:29 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by GritsT
There are 8 of us in a hotel room in NY and we are saddened by the derision on this thread. Please know that I considered it a great honor to be asked to organize this event, I was given very specific instructions, and I did it for Susan.
We had an absolutely wonderful afternoon - it ranks right up there with a wedding and/or the birth of a child!
Susan was in grand form, dressed in jeans and a purple top. Her hair was bobbed, tousled and darling. We welcomed her with a Hello, Susan version of Hello, Dolly and she danced her way into the room. Each fan had special one-on-one time with her. We presented her with flat Susan and an album of fan pictures with fS. We did a bit of line dancing to NY, NY. We were told that Susan WILL be on AGT 8/31! Andy is a gentleman and adores Susan (but you all already know that!)
Susan was relaxed, comfortable, loving and hilarious. If I had my fondest wish granted, it would be that each and all of you could have been there.
Wonderful!!!!!! Can't wait to hear more! I am so thrilled that you all were there to meet Susan!
- 08-21-2011, 02:29 AM
http://i35.photobucket.com/albums/d1...255Fwaving.gifGRITST, RANDMA !!
Please http://i683.photobucket.com/albums/v.../praying-1.gif pics .. or ....ANYTHING http://i683.photobucket.com/albums/v...ileys/pray.gif
Ok I see Grits have posted. Thank you !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! :thankyou::kisses::bighug:
- 08-21-2011, 02:29 AM
Boy, I have been insulted BIG TIME....but I can take it..
- 08-21-2011, 02:30 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by soothed
HAHAHAHAHA....Okay, who is the guy? You? lol
No, just a googled image to make you 'ha ha':biggrin:
- 08-21-2011, 02:31 AM
:
Quote:
Originally Posted by soothed
Why is it I don't feel like pick of the litter?...lol Come on , we might as well have fun with it all...
Quote:
Originally Posted by CanadianBill
We can't have you feeling like that soothed! Here - now you ARE the pick of the litter!
http://i56.tinypic.com/2e4wvo6.jpg
:p:p
:rofl::rofl::rofl: Thanks Soothed and CB.
- 08-21-2011, 02:33 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by GritsT
There are 8 of us in a hotel room in NY and we are saddened by the derision on this thread. Please know that I considered it a great honor to be asked to organize this event, I was given very specific instructions, and I did it for Susan.
We had an absolutely wonderful afternoon - it ranks right up there with a wedding and/or the birth of a child!
Susan was in grand form, dressed in jeans and a purple top. Her hair was bobbed, tousled and darling. We welcomed her with a Hello, Susan version of Hello, Dolly and she danced her way into the room. Each fan had special one-on-one time with her. We presented her with flat Susan and an album of fan pictures with fS. We did a bit of line dancing to NY, NY. We were told that Susan WILL be on AGT 8/31! Andy is a gentleman and adores Susan (but you all already know that!)
Susan was relaxed, comfortable, loving and hilarious. If I had my fondest wish granted, it would be that each and all of you could have been there.
Great fun, Grits!! So glad to hear Susan has plans for AGT. Hopefully that means we'll have something from the new album. Whatever you can share, please do. Whatever you can't, well there is always a reason. So glad you had the time together. Time now for show and tell!:biggrin:
- 08-21-2011, 02:39 AM
Calling all Lucky 20 from the M&G! I am sitting here waiting patiently for your reports. I HAVE to ask, "Did any of you find out what kind of perfume Susan wears? Is her favorite color still at this moment PINK? Did your breath catch when she walked into the room? How long was it before you could breath again? Please give us a report of your emotions on how you felt when you saw her....Please dont leave out any details!... :D Im waiting for your report! And while your writing it all up and giving us all the details you can remember I will just amuse myself by doing this :fan_too_fast:
- 08-21-2011, 02:40 AM
Grits, since this function was held in New York, did you make any effort to invite people from that area? If I were from that area, I would feel really excluded if I were not invited?
- 08-21-2011, 02:40 AM
If anyone is wondering where Susan is now, there is this tweet=
Got chance to chat with Susan Boyle over afternoon tea in JFK airport , very humble, nice and inspiring lady
2 hours ago
Apparently Susan has left NYC. East or west?
- 08-21-2011, 02:43 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by skye
If anyone is wondering where Susan is now, there is this tweet=
Got chance to chat with Susan Boyle over afternoon tea in JFK airport , very humble, nice and inspiring lady
2 hours ago
Apparently Susan has left NYC. East or west?
Hey, North would be nice! :biggrin:
- 08-21-2011, 02:43 AM
GritsT, Thank you for helping make this a great time for Susan in NYC. Your time and effort is much appreciated.
I think I pretty much speak for all of us on that. Susan feels a special connection to us as fans because of wonderful fans like yourself. Thanks again. PS Glad "Flat Susan" came out of retirement. Wouldn't be the same without her.:biggrin:
- 08-21-2011, 02:43 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by GritsT
There are 8 of us in a hotel room in NY and we are saddened by the derision on this thread. Please know that I considered it a great honor to be asked to organize this event, I was given very specific instructions, and I did it for Susan.
We had an absolutely wonderful afternoon - it ranks right up there with a wedding and/or the birth of a child!
Susan was in grand form, dressed in jeans and a purple top. Her hair was bobbed, tousled and darling. We welcomed her with a Hello, Susan version of Hello, Dolly and she danced her way into the room. Each fan had special one-on-one time with her. We presented her with flat Susan and an album of fan pictures with fS. We did a bit of line dancing to NY, NY. We were told that Susan WILL be on AGT 8/31! Andy is a gentleman and adores Susan (but you all already know that!)
Susan was relaxed, comfortable, loving and hilarious. If I had my fondest wish granted, it would be that each and all of you could have been there.
Grits I am sure you and you friends understand why some fans who love Susan dearly are upset..?
It is always easier to be on the inside than looking in.
Thank you for your little report. I am happy for you that your dream has come true .
I am happy for all of you..:love2:
- 08-21-2011, 02:43 AM
Andy, Susan and Andy Stephens are joined at the hip, at least as far as business is concerned. They are the co-Directors of her LLC and their incomes depend on each other. More than that, personally, they have been through the stressful early months of Susan's career when she was still finding her feet in a tumultuous new world. Andy may or may not make mistakes, even experienced people do, but I would lay bets that nothing will separate them during Susan's career. They have been forged in the fire.
- 08-21-2011, 02:47 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Little Lulu
I am glad Susan takes the time to connect with her fans. I feel lucky just to be involved long distance. Isn't it wonderful that our Fan Site has wonderful ladies that Susan likes enough to want to see them again and again. That says a lot about those fans and our Fan site as a whole. I thank my lucky stars that I joined and feel apart of it all. You have to remember that they do it the best way possible for Susan not us.
This is how I feel about this too. Thank you Lulu for saying it so well. I hope everyone had a wonderful time.
- 08-21-2011, 02:48 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by trennie
Andy, Susan and Andy Stephens are joined at the hip, at least as far as business is concerned. They are the co-Directors of her LLC and their incomes depend on each other. More than that, personally, they have been through the stressful early months of Susan's career when she was still finding her feet in a tumultuous new world. Andy may or may not make mistakes, even experienced people do, but I would lay bets that nothing will separate them during Susan's career. They have been forged in the fire.
I know all that Trennie, and as of today I have zero respect for Andy. Just sayin. I haven't lost my interest in Susan.
- 08-21-2011, 02:50 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Little Lulu
Yes, this whole thing may have been dictated by "higher ups" and Susan and Andy hadn't much say. Except for asking for some familiar faces for Susan, to help with those other unfamiliar faces. I say it looks like Susan is getting PROMOTION and THAT is something WE ALL have been wanting. So, :Its All Good:
I think you've got it right, LuLu.
- 08-21-2011, 02:52 AM
Hi Grits and all you other :potofgold::devilcostume: :biggrin:
Is the AGT going to be performed LIVE by Susan on 8/31?!!
- 08-21-2011, 02:52 AM
Thank you, Grits...it was very kind of you to report to us.
Quote:
Originally Posted by GritsT
There are 8 of us in a hotel room in NY and we are saddened by the derision on this thread. Please know that I considered it a great honor to be asked to organize this event, I was given very specific instructions, and I did it for Susan.
We had an absolutely wonderful afternoon - it ranks right up there with a wedding and/or the birth of a child!
Susan was in grand form, dressed in jeans and a purple top. Her hair was bobbed, tousled and darling. We welcomed her with a Hello, Susan version of Hello, Dolly and she danced her way into the room. Each fan had special one-on-one time with her. We presented her with flat Susan and an album of fan pictures with fS. We did a bit of line dancing to NY, NY. We were told that Susan WILL be on AGT 8/31! Andy is a gentleman and adores Susan (but you all already know that!)
Susan was relaxed, comfortable, loving and hilarious. If I had my fondest wish granted, it would be that each and all of you could have been there.
- 08-21-2011, 02:53 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by andyp
I know all that Trennie, and as of today I have zero respect for Andy. Just sayin. I haven't lost my interest in Susan.
Well, Andy, that's the main thing. Susan counts. This other stuff doesn't.
- 08-21-2011, 02:54 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by GritsT
There are 8 of us in a hotel room in NY and we are saddened by the derision on this thread. Please know that I considered it a great honor to be asked to organize this event, I was given very specific instructions, and I did it for Susan.
We had an absolutely wonderful afternoon - it ranks right up there with a wedding and/or the birth of a child!
Susan was in grand form, dressed in jeans and a purple top. Her hair was bobbed, tousled and darling. We welcomed her with a Hello, Susan version of Hello, Dolly and she danced her way into the room. Each fan had special one-on-one time with her. We presented her with flat Susan and an album of fan pictures with fS. We did a bit of line dancing to NY, NY. We were told that Susan WILL be on AGT 8/31! Andy is a gentleman and adores Susan (but you all already know that!)
Susan was relaxed, comfortable, loving and hilarious. If I had my fondest wish granted, it would be that each and all of you could have been there.
I don't think it is derision jeanine- it is the fact that this is a forum of fans and it has been real quiet in a month since China, and something like this was going on behind the scenes- if you were in their shoes- those who faithfully click here daily ( not me as i have been almost AWOL for the month with this wicked injury from my fall)
And then they are kind of surprised- they are expressing why. That is not derision-I am glad to hear Miss B was in good form, and of course, we know Andy adores her- that goes without saying.
What songs besides "Hello Dolly"did she sing?
P.S when i used the word "bodies" i meant fans- fans to show up in NYC quickly for something that was not a normal M & G. I think folks are confused thiking they were left out of a normal M & g, which this does not sound like it was.....
- 08-21-2011, 02:54 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by jclar
I am wondering that too.
Me too!
- 08-21-2011, 02:55 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Pickled Tink
I can think of 20 folk right now who on reading this thread will be getting that kick in the stomach feeling and quite frankly they should not be!!!
They ABSOLUTELY should NOT BE, you are so correct, Pickled Tink!!!
And, to the FORTUNATE 20, I urge you to share your joy freely, for there will always be those who try to discount and rob someone else of their JOY, as they focus upon the negatives and try to dump unearned GUILT upon the shoulders of those who have JOY TO SHARE. It's the old "I'm not feeling OK, so don't want you to feel OK either!" syndrome.
Each of us has a choice...to be ruled by jealousy or bitterness, or to celebrate the JOY OTHERS EXPERIENCED WITH SUSAN, and SHE EXPERIENCED WITH THEM. Let's not forget to focus upon that. This was Susan's need...and Susan's request. Let's show our love for Susan by honoring that.
Reflect back to those BGT TOUR video clips we treasured so deeply. Were they professional films? NO...but did we wait eagerly for each precious contribution??? YOU BET WE DID, and I still enjoy those video clips from long ago. Did we, in those days complain about those who lived in the region, and were fortunate to attend those BGT TOUR CONCERTS? Not that I can recall. We just thrilled that Susan had an audience who loved her, and with whom she so lovingly interacted as she performed.
Rather than focusing upon ourselves, let's focus upon the joy that Susan experienced, in having one more opportunity to spend a few moments of quality time with fans she had never met before. How special it is, that her heart cares to personally bond with her fans. And, rejoice with those who were blessed by personal moments with her.
At the beginning, we fans freely shared our memories and photos from fan gatherings, and those who were blessed to travel abroad, to Susan's events, also shared their photos and memories. If we want that joy to continue, we must not attack those who share with us. Whatever happened to the concepts of "graciousness" and "gratitude"? Love knows how to rejoice in another's joy. And, if we lose sight of that, we will all be losers...including our beloved Susan.
- 08-21-2011, 02:58 AM
Thanks for the report GritsT - I do love the visual of the fans singing Susan into the room! In fact one of my favorite past fan memories is when fans sang her out of the airport in Nov/2010 singing 'New York, New York' - that was such a great sight and Susan seemed to really enjoy it! Glad you all had a grand time!
- 08-21-2011, 02:59 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Pasett1
Thank you, Grits...it was very kind of you to report to us.
Did anybody get a pic of the "bobbed, tousled hair? That sounds like something new.
- 08-21-2011, 03:00 AM
Thank you Trish. Well I'm now going to bed because it seems nobody else is going to report back to us and I'm not surprised. So sad.
- 08-21-2011, 03:02 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by jclar
I wish that her management could arrange a meet and greet that is not secret. There was a mention of scheduling one once, but it was in Las Vegas, and I think there was not enough interest although that is hard to imagine. Or course, her management does what they think is best for Susan, and her time in the US is valuable. Glad she got to do something fun.
WEll, jclar, maybe Susan will come to NYC again this fall and be on theToday show again... and maybe she will come to the brunch this time ... and maybe some of us will get the opportunity then to at least have the opportunity to meet her. We can hope so, anyway.
- 08-21-2011, 03:03 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Trish (Pat Pierce)
They ABSOLUTELY should NOT BE, you are so correct, Pickled Tink!!!
And, to the FORTUNATE 20, I urge you to share your joy freely, for there will always be those who try to discount and rob someone else of their JOY, as they focus upon the negatives and try to dump unearned GUILT upon the shoulders of those who have JOY TO SHARE. It's the old "I'm not feeling OK, so don't want you to feel OK either!" syndrome.
Each of us has a choice...to be ruled by jealousy or bitterness, or to celebrate the JOY OTHERS EXPERIENCED WITH SUSAN, and SHE EXPERIENCED WITH THEM. Let's not forget to focus upon that. This was Susan's need...and Susan's request. Let's show our love for Susan by honoring that.
Reflect back to those BGT TOUR video clips we treasured so deeply. Were they professional films? NO...but did we wait eagerly for each precious contribution??? YOU BET WE DID, and I still enjoy those video clips from long ago. Did we, in those days complain about those who lived in the region, and were fortunate to attend those BGT TOUR CONCERTS? Not that I can recall. We just thrilled that Susan had an audience who loved her, and with whom she so lovingly interacted as she performed.
Rather than focusing upon ourselves, let's focus upon the joy that Susan experienced, in having one more opportunity to spend a few moments of quality time with fans she had never met before. How special it is, that her heart cares to personally bond with her fans. And, rejoice with those who were blessed by personal moments with her.
At the beginning, we fans freely shared our memories and photos from fan gatherings, and those who were blessed to travel abroad, to Susan's events, also shared their photos and memories. If we want that joy to continue, we must not attack those who share with us. Whatever happened to the concepts of "graciousness" and "gratitude"? Love knows how to rejoice in another's joy. And, of we lose sight of that, we will all be losers...including our beloved Susan.
I think, Trish, that's what we're waiting for, to be shared with about Susan. It's nice to hear this first report from Grits, but I hope more is forthcoming from the others, who were privileged to be there.
- 08-21-2011, 03:04 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by CanadianBill
Thanks for the report GritsT - I do love the visual of the fans singing Susan into the room! In fact one of my favorite past fan memories is when fans sang her out of the airport in Nov/2010 singing 'New York, New York' - that was such a great sight and Susan seemed to really enjoy it! Glad you all had a grand time!
That was a lot of fun. Like an old movie...made the news, too.
- 08-21-2011, 03:06 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Trish (Pat Pierce)
They ABSOLUTELY should NOT BE, you are so correct, Pickled Tink!!!
And, to the FORTUNATE 20, I urge you to share your joy freely, for there will always be those who try to discount and rob someone else of their JOY, as they focus upon the negatives and try to dump unearned GUILT upon the shoulders of those who have JOY TO SHARE. It's the old "I'm not feeling OK, so don't want you to feel OK either!" syndrome.
Each of us has a choice...to be ruled by jealousy or bitterness, or to celebrate the JOY OTHERS EXPERIENCED WITH SUSAN, and SHE EXPERIENCED WITH THEM. Let's not forget to focus upon that. This was Susan's need...and Susan's request. Let's show our love for Susan by honoring that.
Reflect back to those BGT TOUR video clips we treasured so deeply. Were they professional films? NO...but did we wait eagerly for each precious contribution??? YOU BET WE DID, and I still enjoy those video clips from long ago. Did we, in those days complain about those who lived in the region, and were fortunate to attend those BGT TOUR CONCERTS? Not that I can recall. We just thrilled that Susan had an audience who loved her, and with whom she so lovingly interacted as she performed.
Rather than focusing upon ourselves, let's focus upon the joy that Susan experienced, in having one more opportunity to spend a few moments of quality time with fans she had never met before. How special it is, that her heart cares to personally bond with her fans. And, rejoice with those who were blessed by personal moments with her.
At the beginning, we fans freely shared our memories and photos from fan gatherings, and those who were blessed to travel abroad, to Susan's events, also shared their photos and memories. If we want that joy to continue, we must not attack those who share with us. Whatever happened to the concepts of "graciousness" and "gratitude"? Love knows how to rejoice in another's joy. And, of we lose sight of that, we will all be losers...including our beloved Susan.
So well said Trish! None of this devisiveness has accomplished anything but a deep sadness on the forum at a time when we should be jumping for joy with news of Susan! Let us embrace those who were fortunate to be at the M & G today and welcome any information as we all did at the beginning of Susan's journey! Be happy for Susan who has been on a whirlwind for the past two years.. accomplishing things she could only dream about. This forum has one primary purpose: to support Susan!! Thank goodness for the fans who are able to bring us the news we so fervently seek!:grouphug:
- 08-21-2011, 03:12 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Helen101
And my post was for those who were disappointed. I feel very sorry for them. For those who were invited it would have been absolutely wonderful.
Disappointment is part of life. If we were fans of anyone except Susan noone would ever have a chance to meet her. It's because of Susan and her team that so many fans have had that opportunity. It can't be easy for Susan and her team to manage that but they do. We have no idea what it is like to be in their shoes and we just have to trust they are doing the best they can even if it isn't done the way WE would do it. So let's all put on our big girl (boy) panties and act like grown ups and celebrate all things Susan!!!!!!!! Especially her new up and coming CD!!! Whoop, whoop!!!!!!!!
- 08-21-2011, 03:13 AM
<<from Grits: Susan was relaxed, comfortable, loving and hilarious. If I had my fondest wish granted, it would be that each and all of you could have been there.>>
Great description of Susan, especially "loving and hilarious"! I often think of Susan that way and feel that is part of her charm. And your wish is taken in by many of us I'm sure... :love:
- 08-21-2011, 03:17 AM
I'm at work and read the first post awhile ago and then came back and read through just now.
First of all, kudos to Randma, GritsT, and Janna for whatever organizational role they played. I'm delighted for all who got to attend. I'm excited to learn of the purpose of the M&G. I would love to hear more from those who attended (whatever they're allowed to say).
I also think it would be good idea to start a new, positive thread for attendees who are willing to share.
- 08-21-2011, 03:19 AM
I just have to put my oar in the water and say that I am delighted for those who got to go. One said it was like the day of giving birth or a wedding. I totally get that. That's how I felt when I saw Susan sing in New York last Nov. from the front row. What a thrill. As long as I live it will be one of the highlights of my life. So be blessed my Susan-fan friends and enjoy your wonderful memories. :cloud: I love the part about Susan dancing into the room as they sang her in. I love her spirit. I think it's great that Susan and Andy and whoever else decided, that fans were even included inthis way - at all. If we get too cranky and devisive such things could not happen in the future if they determine that it causes problems. So I say :party: I am so happy for all of you who got to go and had a chance to show Susan by your love just how special she is. :Ilovesusan: I could never begrudge anyone such joy.
- 08-21-2011, 03:22 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by trennie
...it's a mistake to give the impression, wrongly I'm sure, that there is an "inner circle" of select fans, privy to secret information.
It would help if the folks, who were there, would get on the stick and report. As chosen representatives of Subo Fandom they are privileged but timely reporting is also the responsibility.
Yes!
- 08-21-2011, 03:23 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by GritsT
There are 8 of us in a hotel room in NY and we are saddened by the derision on this thread. Please know that I considered it a great honor to be asked to organize this event, I was given very specific instructions, and I did it for Susan.
We had an absolutely wonderful afternoon - it ranks right up there with a wedding and/or the birth of a child!
Susan was in grand form, dressed in jeans and a purple top. Her hair was bobbed, tousled and darling. We welcomed her with a Hello, Susan version of Hello, Dolly and she danced her way into the room. Each fan had special one-on-one time with her. We presented her with flat Susan and an album of fan pictures with fS. We did a bit of line dancing to NY, NY. We were told that Susan WILL be on AGT 8/31! Andy is a gentleman and adores Susan (but you all already know that!)
Susan was relaxed, comfortable, loving and hilarious. If I had my fondest wish granted, it would be that each and all of you could have been there.
Hugs to you, Grits, for taking the time to share such wonderful details with our eager hearts. You surely must be exhausted, and yet TOOK THE TIME TO SAY HELLO AND SHARE THE JOY YOU EXPERIENCED WITH SUSAN. Love, Trish
- 08-21-2011, 03:29 AM
Thanks Trish. You said it all.
- 08-21-2011, 03:31 AM
Thanks GritsT for the first report. So happy that the M&G was wonderful. I am so happy for you.
- 08-21-2011, 03:34 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by kathymc
Me too.
I can surely understand why the news is slow in coming. If I had been one of the twenty, I wouldn't want anyone here to know. Sure wouldn't want them jealous of me. However, maybe you can get past it and share more with us that you experienced in that wonderful meeting with Susan and her team. Most of us would be ashamed to admit we were disappointed or jealous, ( if we were) but a few folks seem to have to jump up and down and act like little children.
Please let part of this thread run like water off a duck's back, as most of us are so happy you represented us and helped Susan do what she is here to do.
- 08-21-2011, 03:35 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Pickled Tink
Whilst I understand that everyone wants to know how or why the people who attended got to go. Can I make the following points. This was not a forum meet and greet, there may be a lot of things we are not privy to and which they do not yet want us to know, they have their reasons, and we should respect them. So, maybe some of the comments and questions are perhaps not helpful. It is understandable that everyone wants to be there etc... .However, Susan has MILLIONS of fans and if there was a meet and greet every single day for the next ten years she could not meet them all. It's just not practicable. Yes of course everyone wants to meet her. Some of us have been very very lucky and we know that. Some have not been and I so wish that more folk had been. I also know that more folk will be in the future.
But can I ask you for for a few minutes to put yourselves in the shoes of those who have met Susan today. They have just had the time of their lives; they will be excited, over the moon, and just itching to share their news. They will come to the forum and what will they see? Posts which quite frankly seem a little resentful that some were chosen and they were not. How would you feel if that were you? There will always be someone who will be disappointed whatever criteria are used. But surely it is not too much to be happy that others got this opportunity and that they are willing to share it with you?
Amen to that. I think it's impossible to have Susan in a large mob of people. There are security issues and it could be very daunting (as the Brits say), to have a whole swarm of people wanting her time. So they did what they could and they didn't have to do any of it. I am THRILLED for those who attended and will be further THRILLED to hear about it. Wonderful - just wonderful.
- 08-21-2011, 03:36 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Kalua
Calling the fans bodies is insulting, and I do not think Andy decided they needed bodies.
I would like to assume that some of the fans present there were chosen by Susan.
Frankly I'm appaled with this kind of vocabulary, this is not animal farm it is a fansite!!!
"All animals are equal, but some animals are more equal than others." George Orwell, Animal Farm
Since words fail me right now, I'll let George Orwell speak for me.
- 08-21-2011, 03:36 AM
I am SO happy for the 20 that got to go to the Meet and Greet with Susan:) I know all of you have got to be on cloud 9 and thanks so much to GritsT for your report:) As all of you know Susan is such a special lady, she deserves the very best:D I can't get enough of her singing and wanting to know more about her!!! Can't wait for her third CD to come out!!! Can't wait for AGT appearance:D:D:D
- 08-21-2011, 03:38 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Linda Sharon
I just have to put my oar in the water and say that I am delighted for those who got to go. One said it was like the day of giving birth or a wedding. I totally get that. That's how I felt when I saw Susan sing in New York last Nov. from the front row. What a thrill. As long as I live it will be one of the highlights of my life. So be blessed my Susan-fan friends and enjoy your wonderful memories. :cloud: I love the part about Susan dancing into the room as they sang her in. I love her spirit. I think it's great that Susan and Andy and whoever else decided, that fans were even included inthis way - at all. If we get too cranky and devisive such things could not happen in the future if they determine that it causes problems. So I say :party: I am so happy for all of you who got to go and had a chance to show Susan by your love just how special she is. :Ilovesusan: I could never begrudge anyone such joy.
I am with you in your feelings Linda Sharon. I hope the lucky 20 are on cloud nine right now and when they come back down to earth I hope we hear more details and get pictures.
- 08-21-2011, 03:40 AM
What exciting news to hear that Susan was able to meet fans in New York. I'm sure this must have been a special highlight for Susan of her visit to New York. I can't wait to hear all the reports.
I was thinking as I looked at the photograph of Susan taken at the restaurant, how extraordinary that a lady who has lived her life in a small village in Scotland would be recognized by so many as she walked down the street in New York. It is amazing how much has taken place in her life in a little over two years and I hope she is enjoying it tremendously.
- 08-21-2011, 03:40 AM
As far as I can see, He only lost one.:p
- 08-21-2011, 03:42 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by retiredgran
I am with you in your feelings Linda Sharon. I hope the lucky 20 are on cloud nine right now and when they come back down to earth I hope we hear more details and get pictures.
Thanks hon. Hope to see you soon at one of our T.O. get togethers. hugs...
- 08-21-2011, 03:43 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by TxTammy
I feel sorry for those living in New York and are great fans of Susan. They must be hurting "just a little."
I would guess more than "a little."
- 08-21-2011, 03:46 AM
I'm thrilled that Susan undoubtedly had a great time. I doubt she met anyone she hadn't met before. I'm glad it went well and I congratulate everyone who put this together for what seems like a successful event.
- 08-21-2011, 03:46 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by sugar puddin
As far as I can see, He only lost one.:p
:laught2:
- 08-21-2011, 03:48 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Linda Sharon
I just have to put my oar in the water and say that I am delighted for those who got to go. One said it was like the day of giving birth or a wedding. I totally get that. That's how I felt when I saw Susan sing in New York last Nov. from the front row. What a thrill. As long as I live it will be one of the highlights of my life. So be blessed my Susan-fan friends and enjoy your wonderful memories. :cloud: I love the part about Susan dancing into the room as they sang her in. I love her spirit. I think it's great that Susan and Andy and whoever else decided, that fans were even included inthis way - at all. If we get too cranky and devisive such things could not happen in the future if they determine that it causes problems. So I say :party: I am so happy for all of you who got to go and had a chance to show Susan by your love just how special she is. :Ilovesusan: I could never begrudge anyone such joy.
Beautifully said, Linda. I also loved what Grits reported about Susan dancing into the room as they sang. Shows that she was relaxed and enjoying herself. That's what we all want for Susan. It matters not (to me) who got to go, as long as this fansite was represented.
- 08-21-2011, 03:48 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Henny
I can surely understand why the news is slow in coming. If I had been one of the twenty, I wouldn't want anyone here to know. Sure wouldn't want them jealous of me. However, maybe you can get past it and share more with us that you experienced in that wonderful meeting with Susan and her team. Most of us would be ashamed to admit we were disappointed or jealous, ( if we were) but a few folks seem to have to jump up and down and act like little children.
Please let part of this thread run like water off a duck's back, as most of us are so happy you represented us and helped Susan do what she is here to do.
Agree so much. Please don't punish the 98% of us who are thrilled for you and desperate to hear what happened and see pictures, because thre are 2% who are childish and jealous and want to spoil the fun.
- 08-21-2011, 03:52 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Retired In Kalifornia
Bern, TRUST ME, if I could had been able to "share my slot" after declinging the offer to attend the first person I'd ask to go would be SusaFan Lorias as she's my Fans For Susan Boyle Websites "boss" and a good friend. Lori has number of disabilities, I'd do anything short of carrying her on my back to NYC from Indiana for her to see Susan. I'll glady give up my "slot" for anybody else, including transporting any fan between Cameron Park to CBS Television City within reasonable distance from California State Route 99 to see Susan perform on AGT - if she indeed does - late this month or next for free, including paying for overnight lodging if we couldn't make it a day trip. I'd offered last year to do something like this to see Susan at AGT & DWTS BTW.
You are one gentleman, RIK!
- 08-21-2011, 03:52 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by lcmdom
Disappointment is part of life. If we were fans of anyone except Susan noone would ever have a chance to meet her. It's because of Susan and her team that so many fans have had that opportunity. It can't be easy for Susan and her team to manage that but they do. We have no idea what it is like to be in their shoes and we just have to trust they are doing the best they can even if it isn't done the way WE would do it. So let's all put on our big girl (boy) panties and act like grown ups and celebrate all things Susan!!!!!!!! Especially her new up and coming CD!!! Whoop, whoop!!!!!!!!
Just a little hard to do when we have been treated like children.
- 08-21-2011, 03:57 AM
RIK Will Susan Be Taped BEFORE AGT Or Live?
Quote:
Originally Posted by GritsT
There are 8 of us in a hotel room in NY and we are saddened by the derision on this thread. Please know that I considered it a great honor to be asked to organize this event, I was given very specific instructions, and I did it for Susan.
We had an absolutely wonderful afternoon - it ranks right up there with a wedding and/or the birth of a child!
Susan was in grand form, dressed in jeans and a purple top. Her hair was bobbed, tousled and darling. We welcomed her with a Hello, Susan version of Hello, Dolly and she danced her way into the room. Each fan had special one-on-one time with her. We presented her with flat Susan and an album of fan pictures with fS. We did a bit of line dancing to NY, NY. We were told that Susan WILL be on AGT 8/31! Andy is a gentleman and adores Susan (but you all already know that!)
Susan was relaxed, comfortable, loving and hilarious. If I had my fondest wish granted, it would be that each and all of you could have been there.
If she will be taped I'll likely have to leave Cameron Park around 11:30 p.m. the 30th IF there is A.M. taping, haven't done all-night drive in years - ugh!
- 08-21-2011, 04:01 AM
RIK Awww...
Quote:
Originally Posted by Marie Jean
You are one gentleman, RIK!
:love2:
- 08-21-2011, 04:02 AM
Well said Linda, my feelings exactly so happy for the very lucky people who got to meet Susan and delighted that Susan enjoyed herself and had fun.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Linda Sharon
I just have to put my oar in the water and say that I am delighted for those who got to go. One said it was like the day of giving birth or a wedding. I totally get that. That's how I felt when I saw Susan sing in New York last Nov. from the front row. What a thrill. As long as I live it will be one of the highlights of my life. So be blessed my Susan-fan friends and enjoy your wonderful memories. :cloud: I love the part about Susan dancing into the room as they sang her in. I love her spirit. I think it's great that Susan and Andy and whoever else decided, that fans were even included inthis way - at all. If we get too cranky and devisive such things could not happen in the future if they determine that it causes problems. So I say :party: I am so happy for all of you who got to go and had a chance to show Susan by your love just how special she is. :Ilovesusan: I could never begrudge anyone such joy.
- 08-21-2011, 04:04 AM
Grits can you tell us who the lucky 20 were today?
- 08-21-2011, 04:07 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Marie Jean
You are one gentleman, RIK!
He certainly is isnt he? :D
- 08-21-2011, 04:08 AM
Grits, I see you are on here now. Please give us a little more info if you can. You can see there are 91 on this thread, and almost all are waiting hopefully for a bit more info.
- 08-21-2011, 04:08 AM
I am dying to hear about the new songs Susan sang,are you allowed to share any details?
- 08-21-2011, 04:08 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by andyp
Andy may have been in the business for a long time, but he sure knows how to lose Susafans. This is the second time that he messsed up in my opinion. What a jerk. And please, mods, this is my honest opinion and I am entitled to it. No warnings, please. leave my post up if you are a democracy.
I find this post to be quite offensive on so many levels. You are of course entitled to your opinion, however, name calling is never appropriate. Stating that this forum is not a democracy if your rude comment is removed, is certainly threatening. Susan and her team have every right to do what they want and how they want, what the motives of their actions are, is quite frankly none of our business.
You have asked that you not be given warnings, I am sorry that I will not be able to comply with your request. You will be getting a PM from me shortly. You have violated Rule1 by not showing respect for Susan and her team and have violated and rule 2.
- 08-21-2011, 04:12 AM
Thanks Grits sounds like yall had a great time with Susan. What were the songs yall heard from the CD?
- 08-21-2011, 04:13 AM
Even though I doubt I could hop on a plane and get to NYC if it was an open invitation (and I am hardly ever jelous of others' good fortune), I do feel alienated from those who were able to pick and choose their acquaintances to go to this exclusive M&G. That said it was Susan and her management's decision and those involved made the best of it. I just don't like those who know Susan quite well telling me how I should view this M&G. Of course, I will be looking for all the reports and photos but wish the M&G had not been so very exclusive.
Quote:
Originally Posted by andyp
The Susan team are not doing themselves any favourites. They are alienating fans.
- 08-21-2011, 04:14 AM
Does anyone know of any other female star that arranges these meet and greets with fans? I think Susan and her team are absolutely wonderful for accomodating these gatherings. Susan is a unique artist with a unique relationship with her fans. I wrote Susan a letter a while back and told her that it is simply love that binds all of us to her.:love2:
- 08-21-2011, 04:15 AM
Thanks so much for the report Grits .Sounds like it was a blast.
- 08-21-2011, 04:20 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Anniev
I find this post to be quite offensive on so many levels. You are of course entitled to your opinion, however, name calling is never appropriate. Stating that this forum is not a democracy if your rude comment is removed, is certainly threatening. Susan and her team have every right to do what they want and how they want, what the motives of their actions are, is quite frankly none of our business.
You have asked that you not be given warnings, I am sorry that I will not be able to comply with your request. You will be getting a PM from me shortly. You have violated Rule1 by not showing respect for Susan and her team and have violated and rule 2.
Should not this post have been done by PM? " 1. First warning - No sanctions, but a PM reminder of the rules and notification of warning." This quote comes directly from the Rules for Forum Sanctions.
- 08-21-2011, 04:20 AM
Whew! I’m sure you all realize that no one who was there would post until they had read through all 24 pages of this thread first, and that takes time. Besides which I’ve been out for a family obligation and just got home.
I was one of the lucky, lucky, lucky ones! From the moment I got the message about it I have alternated between complete delirium/excitement and serious misgivings and worry about how the news would eventually be received on the forum. I know very well that if I had not been so fortunate this time I would have felt at least a twinge of envy and asked “why not me?” But then I would have to know that it appeared to be random, as I haven’t done anything to curry favor with anybody. So in the end, coming up with 20 people out of – gosh, how many are we in all? – was bound to cause disappointment among the remaining hundreds of fans. But believe me, we all had anxiety about how everyone else would feel. Then there were the many close friendships between some of the 20 and others on the forum. The first thing we would want to do is to share our news, but not one of us did, to my knowledge, because a promise is a promise. I absolutely believe Susan’s team – and it might have even come from beyond her team, although I’m not privy to all the information – had strong reasons for imposing a “gag” order about this. They are actually very conscient of Susan’s fans, believe it or not. Having seen Andy today, I’m more admiring of him than ever!
Having said that, I’ll say that GritsT’s initial description captures the essence of the event very well. Susan had been somewhere else this morning – and again, I have no idea where, nor did we ask – so we weren’t sure exactly when she would arrive. NYC traffic is unpredictable. So we ate quickly and waited. I have to admit to having a little trouble breathing when they said she was coming up the stairs. When you have seen her so many times on videos, the prospect of being in the same room is, well, kind of unreal. And what others have said in the past is true: seeing her in person is different. She has an aura that draws people to her; you can feel it. She was pretty casually dressed, and her hair was in her natural tousled curls. But it’s hard to focus on anything but her personality, as she hams it up, laughs and gives us all her energy. All the facial expressions we have seen over time come out in rapid succession. So fast that when you think you’re taking a picture of one, by the time the flash goes off, she’s on to another. She loves to clown.
We were all told we would have 3 minutes to sit with her one-on-one. But unbeknownst to us, she had not yet had lunch, so we waited while she ordered and gulped down a quick bite, along with Andy, Joanne, and others with her. As a result, I’m not sure, but I think in the end our time was shortened to 2 minutes. I say I’m not sure, because in the moment, things become a bit of a blur, and I’m not really sure about anything. Anyhow, while each person was with her, dozens of others were watching and taking pictures. Whatever I might have thought I would say to her, I pretty much forgot it when the moment came, but I guess I said something, and she was, of course, sweet and gracious. I can’t imagine how she can hold up under meeting with so many people she doesn’t know.
Then Andy gave us the extreme joy of hearing a sample from the new album (no, Susan did not sing for us), although he emphasized that it was still a work in progress and had not had the mixing completed. We were actually able to give our reaction to one song, which was: absolutely beautiful, but we want less orchestra and more Susan!! Sound familiar? He assured us that would still be adjusted. Unfortunately, and this will probably cause more cataclysmic reactions, Sony insists absolutely that the title not be revealed until they put it out officially. But you will know one quite soon, because Susan is going to sing it on AGT.
OK, I rushed to write some of this now, since I know you’re wanting to hear more about what went on. Some of those attending are on their way home and can't post yet. Some don't have access to computers yet. I know there will be pictures, but I'm not proficient at that.
I sincerely thank those of you who are being understanding of this event. If you are thinking it’s daunting to post about it after reading some bitterness, you are right. I feel like hiding under a couch. In addition, I will need some serious time to decompress. I know for sure if there is another occasion, it will be another group entirely, and you’ll have your turn. To anyone feeling really bad, I understand, but I hope you can wait, as PT advised, until more is known about the purpose of the event and the reasons behind it before jumping to negative conclusions. Susan is an absolute angel, and she has the strongest defender in the world in Andy. That makes me very happy.
- 08-21-2011, 04:23 AM
Hello, folks, I am not at my usual computer but am at my son's place in NY, after being "1 of the 20" who shared a spectacular time with Susan today. I have lots of photos, but haven't had a chance to download and upload my downloads! I'll do that when I return on the 26th.
In the spirit of love and joy I want to share with you the extraordinary graciousness extended to all of us by Andy and Susan, Joanna and others who came with them to New York. The rooms were very small in St. Andrews Restaurant. When I went to check out the place Friday evening, I had to ask several people where the "private reserved room" was. Nobody had a clue that Susan was coming. Not the bartender; not the waitress; not even the manager. The manager knew that someone "important" was coming but they did not know who. Let me explain that this restaurant had a door as well as a huge double door which was fully open to the sidewalk. It was almost as if pedestrians could walk right through the open space with only tables and a chair blocking the path. When I saw how vulnerable the restaurant was to pedestrian traffic not for one moment did I question the "secrecy" request which was a burden of trust put upon us not to let a word get out about this event. Unfortunately in today's world such news could jeopardize the life and/or safety of the "famous" folk such as Susan herself.
What I learned from today's Meet and Greet was that it turned out to be an enormous success because Susan enjoys small groups and relishes spending individual time with each. This event would not have been possible if 200 or more people had attended. Susan is one of the few singers who offer such "fan time" in the first place. Her comfort and her requirements were our top priorities. If word had gotten out in NYC that Susan would be physically present at St. Andrews for lunch for a M & G, the general public and local passersby might have mobbed the place which would have necessitated cancelling the entire event in order to insure the safely of Susan and others. Please also remember that if somebody had informed "Page 6" of the New York Post of the event, either deliberately or inadvertently, it could well have mushroomed into additional media coverage and the little restaurant could have been packed with curious onlookers who only want to see a celebrity while they are in NYC. Susan's management and Grits made all of the right decisions in the best interests of Susan and in the best interest of insuring that the event would be successful.
Meeting other fans the night before and sharing dinner was a great thrill, just to be able to meet flesh and blood after cyperspacing words with each other for 2 1/2 years. Everyone was kind and considerate and wonderful to be near.
Today Susan herself breezed in with Andy and her entourage. We immediately began signing "Hello, Susan!" to the tune of "Hello, Dolly!" She smiled ear to ear and then began mingling into the crowd with a hug and greeting for each of us. Then we all sat down and she had her lunch with us. When she was finished, she got up, gave a big hello to Flat Susan and we all had a chance to take as many photos as we wanted. And then she sat down in a chair with an emtpy chair beside her and we all took turns by numbers to sit with her for our "3 minutes" of one to one time. She was encouraging us to bring her all sorts of things to sign. I belive it was Graysea who had the back of her T-shirt signed. For me she signed two books and I had the great honor on behalf of HAPPY and all the Golden Girls to gift Susan with her own autographed copy of Catching the Dream. Susan seemed thrilled, as well as touched by the gift. I also read to her the dedication page and she gave another big hug in thanks to all of us who wrote poems for her.
Andy then announced that in appreciation of the fact that people had traveled long distances to be here with Susan, he and Susan wanted to share with us FOUR recordings which in all probability will be included in her next CD. Andy indicated that Sony wanted all of us to turn in our cameras and cellphones in order to insure that no recordings of the songs we were about to hear would leave the room. We were asked to place such items in the provided envelopes with our names on them. The Sony sound man played the recordings and we were sworn not to disclose the titles of any of the songs because a few of them are well known classics. He did give us permission, however, to let you know that Susan will sing one of the songs on the season finale of AGT. We listened to the songs and gave him feedback on each song.
The grand finale was a performance of a Texas line-dance performed to the tune of "New York, New York." Susan and Andy got a big kick out of that little number!
Susan was not in a rush to leave! She said goodbyes to each and all and gave even more hugs. This lady is well on her way to feeling totally comfortable with her fans and fame. And we truly loved the experience of being with Susan.
- 08-21-2011, 04:23 AM
At first. I did feel like I was in kindergarten, but I got my pacifier and I am okay now....lol
- 08-21-2011, 04:26 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by pardonmeboy
Just a little hard to do when we have been treated like children.
Puh-leez, people. This is NOT a private forum. Anyone using any name and any email address can register here. We surely know that paps, bloggers, and competing label research arms monitor here looking for any tidbits about what Susan is up to. The recording industry is hugely competitve which is why there is great secrecy about release dates, track lists and promotion plans. The pseudo M&G apparently was put together as some part of the overall promotion plan for Susan's CD. There is no way that it could have been announced on this forum because, again, this forum is in no way private, and who knows who would have shown up for purposes not in Susan's best interests. This was clearly a business arrangement and not a case of Susan just wanting to kick back with some fans. I don't want those who agreed to go to NY at their own expense to reveal song titles or anything else surrounding CD #3 that will put Susan at a competitive disadvantage.
- 08-21-2011, 04:28 AM
Amber,
Thank you SSOOOOO much for your report! What an absolutely wonderful experience you had to meet Susan. She is very very lucky to have Andy on her team!!! Now, get some much needed rest!!!:thanks::excellent:
- 08-21-2011, 04:29 AM
Thanks, Amber. After reading your post, I feel a little better. I was a sad little camper for a while there. Thank you for sharing your wonderful experience today. I can only imagine.
- 08-21-2011, 04:31 AM
Thank you so much, Amber Duke, for your wonderful report. So glad you were there and were willing to share with us who were waiting for more news. Sounds like a fantastic event.
- 08-21-2011, 04:31 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by ReynieCarroll
Puh-leez, people. This is NOT a private forum. Anyone using any name and any email address can register here. We surely know that paps, bloggers, and competing label research arms monitor here looking for any tidbits about what Susan is up to. The recording industry is hugely competitve which is why there is great secrecy about release dates, track lists and promotion plans. The pseudo M&G apparently was put together as some part of the overall promotion plan for Susan's CD. There is no way that it could have been announced on this forum because, again, this forum is in no way private, and who knows who would have shown up for purposes not in Susan's best interests. This was clearly a business arrangement and not a case of Susan just wanting to kick back with some fans. I don't want those who agreed to go to NY at their own expense to reveal song titles or anything else surrounding CD #3 that will put Susan at a competitive disadvantage.
This sounds like a good explanation .:excellent:
- 08-21-2011, 04:32 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by sunandroses
Hello, folks, I am not at my usual computer but am at my son's place in NY, after being "1 of the 20" who shared a spectacular time with Susan today. I have lots of photos, but haven't had a chance to download and upload my downloads! I'll do that when I return on the 26th.
In the spirit of love and joy I want to share with you the extraordinary graciousness extended to all of us by Andy and Susan, Joanna and others who came with them to New York. The rooms were very small in St. Andrews Restaurant. When I went to check out the place Friday evening, I had to ask several people where the "private reserved room" was. Nobody had a clue that Susan was coming. Not the bartender; not the waitress; not even the manager. The manager knew that someone "important" was coming but they did not know who. Let me explain that this restaurant had a door as well as a huge double door which was fully open to the sidewalk. It was almost as if pedestrians could walk right through the open space with only tables and a chair blocking the path. When I saw how vulnerable the restaurant was to pedestrian traffic not for one moment did I question the "secrecy" request which was a burden of trust put upon us not to let a word get out about this event. Unfortunately in today's world such news could jeopardize the life and/or safety of the "famous" folk such as Susan herself.
What I learned from today's Meet and Greet was that it turned out to be an enormous success because Susan enjoys small groups and relishes spending individual time with each. This event would not have been possible if 200 or more people had attended. Susan is one of the few singers who offer such "fan time" in the first place. Her comfort and her requirements were our top priorities. If word had gotten out in NYC that Susan would be physically present at St. Andrews for lunch for a M & G, the general public and local passersby might have mobbed the place which would have necessitated cancelling the entire event in order to insure the safely of Susan and others. Please also remember that if somebody had informed "Page 6" of the New York Post of the event, either deliberately or inadvertently, it could well have mushroomed into additional media coverage and the little restaurant could have been packed with curious onlookers who only want to see a celebrity while they are in NYC. Susan's management and Grits made all of the right decisions in the best interests of Susan and in the best interest of insuring that the event would be successful.
Meeting other fans the night before and sharing dinner was a great thrill, just to be able to meet flesh and blood after cyperspacing words with each other for 2 1/2 years. Everyone was kind and considerate and wonderful to be near.
Today Susan herself breezed in with Andy and her entourage. We immediately began signing "Hello, Susan!" to the tune of "Hello, Dolly!" She smiled ear to ear and then began mingling into the crowd with a hug and greeting for each of us. Then we all sat down and she had her lunch with us. When she was finished, she got up, gave a big hello to Flat Susan and we all had a chance to take as many photos as we wanted. And then she sat down in a chair with an emtpy chair beside her and we all took turns by numbers to sit with her for our "3 minutes" of one to one time. She was encouraging us to bring her all sorts of things to sign. I belive it was Graysea who had the back of her T-shirt signed. For me she signed two books and I had the great honor on behalf of HAPPY and all the Golden Girls to gift Susan with her own autographed copy of Catching the Dream. Susan seemed thrilled, as well as touched by the gift. I also read to her the dedication page and she gave another big hug in thanks to all of us who wrote poems for her.
Andy then announced that in appreciation of the fact that people had traveled long distances to be here with Susan, he and Susan wanted to share with us FOUR recordings which in all probability will be included in her next CD. Andy indicated that Sony wanted all of us to turn in our cameras and cellphones in order to insure that no recordings of the songs we were about to hear would leave the room. We were asked to place such items in the provided envelopes with our names on them. The Sony sound man played the recordings and we were sworn not to disclose the titles of any of the songs because a few of them are well known classics. He did give us permission, however, to let you know that Susan will sing one of the songs on the season finale of AGT. We listened to the songs and gave him feedback on each song.
The grand finale was a performance of a Texas line-dance performed to the tune of "New York, New York." Susan and Andy got a big kick out of that little number!
Susan was not in a rush to leave! She said goodbyes to each and all and gave even more hugs. This lady is well on her way to feeling totally comfortable with her fans and fame. And we truly loved the experience of being with Susan.
That was a fine report, S&R. Thanks. Are you allowed to tell us if there was one song the majority liked best and if so, was it a new one? Also what about their tempo.
- 08-21-2011, 04:33 AM
Thank you, thank you, thank you, Amber Duke and sunandroses. I appreciate so much your taking the time to give us some idea of what went on today. Obviously a fantastic time. Can't wait for pictures.
- 08-21-2011, 04:33 AM
Great reports sunandroses and Amber Duke. Thank you so much for filling us in. Glad the M&G was such a great success and Susan enjoyed herself. I am off to :zzz: now and will have happy dreams about your great party. :goodnight:
- 08-21-2011, 04:34 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by ReynieCarroll
Puh-leez, people. This is NOT a private forum. Anyone using any name and any email address can register here. We surely know that paps, bloggers, and competing label research arms monitor here looking for any tidbits about what Susan is up to. The recording industry is hugely competitve which is why there is great secrecy about release dates, track lists and promotion plans. The pseudo M&G apparently was put together as some part of the overall promotion plan for Susan's CD. There is no way that it could have been announced on this forum because, again, this forum is in no way private, and who knows who would have shown up for purposes not in Susan's best interests. This was clearly a business arrangement and not a case of Susan just wanting to kick back with some fans. I don't want those who agreed to go to NY at their own expense to reveal song titles or anything else surrounding CD #3 that will put Susan at a competitive disadvantage.
Thank you, RC and others who have pointed these things out, that is exactly right. New York City is not West Lothian, by a long shot, so there is no comparison with the lovely local m&g's there. Sunandroses also expressed very well the situation that could very well have arisen, and very likely would have, had any word gotten out. They would simply have canceled it. This forum is not just "us," folks, and we all know that.
- 08-21-2011, 04:34 AM
Amberduke & Sunandroses thank you so much for the reports! :D It sounds like a rousing success! :dance: Susan's safety & that of her team & fans are of the utmost importance!
Can't wait to see AGT! :Ilovesusan::susanrocks:
- 08-21-2011, 04:37 AM
THANK YOUAmber duke and sunandroses !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Much appreciated and very happy for you :love::love:
C::thankyou::kisses::hug::hug::hug:
- 08-21-2011, 04:38 AM
Thanks Amber Duke and Sunandroses for the great reports. It sounds like Susan had as much fun as her fans.
- 08-21-2011, 04:38 AM
sunandroses, Thank you!!! Susan is such a gift to all of us... actually meeting small groups of fans and giving them her time and attention! I can see why there had to be such secrecy about this M & G. Susan is known worldwide now and a leak could have created a media storm that would have messed up everything that was planned. Susan really does love meeting her fans!! I know we all can't wait to see her perform on AGT! Thank you again.
- 08-21-2011, 04:39 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by chocolate eyes
"All animals are equal, but some animals are more equal than others." George Orwell, Animal Farm
Since words fail me right now, I'll let George Orwell speak for me.
After reading this, if I had been lucky enough to have been asked to attend, I would not be sharing my experience with anyone. A few of you have managed to spoil what was I am sure a very exciting a happy experience for those in attendance. Think about what you have posted and how those in NY may feel when they those posts.
- 08-21-2011, 04:40 AM
Thank you also, sunandroses, for your nice report about the M & G today in NY.
- 08-21-2011, 04:41 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Amber Duke
Whew! I’m sure you all realize that no one who was there would post until they had read through all 24 pages of this thread first, and that takes time. Besides which I’ve been out for a family obligation and just got home.
I was one of the lucky, lucky, lucky ones! From the moment I got the message about it I have alternated between complete delirium/excitement and serious misgivings and worry about how the news would eventually be received on the forum. I know very well that if I had not been so fortunate this time I would have felt at least a twinge of envy and asked “why not me?” But then I would have to know that it appeared to be random, as I haven’t done anything to curry favor with anybody. So in the end, coming up with 20 people out of – gosh, how many are we in all? – was bound to cause disappointment among the remaining hundreds of fans. But believe me, we all had anxiety about how everyone else would feel. Then there were the many close friendships between some of the 20 and others on the forum. The first thing we would want to do is to share our news, but not one of us did, to my knowledge, because a promise is a promise. I absolutely believe Susan’s team – and it might have even come from beyond her team, although I’m not privy to all the information – had strong reasons for imposing a “gag” order about this. They are actually very conscient of Susan’s fans, believe it or not. Having seen Andy today, I’m more admiring of him than ever!
Having said that, I’ll say that GritsT’s initial description captures the essence of the event very well. Susan had been somewhere else this morning – and again, I have no idea where, nor did we ask – so we weren’t sure exactly when she would arrive. NYC traffic is unpredictable. So we ate quickly and waited. I have to admit to having a little trouble breathing when they said she was coming up the stairs. When you have seen her so many times on videos, the prospect of being in the same room is, well, kind of unreal. And what others have said in the past is true: seeing her in person is different. She has an aura that draws people to her; you can feel it. She was pretty casually dressed, and her hair was in her natural tousled curls. But it’s hard to focus on anything but her personality, as she hams it up, laughs and gives us all her energy. All the facial expressions we have seen over time come out in rapid succession. So fast that when you think you’re taking a picture of one, by the time the flash goes off, she’s on to another. She loves to clown.
We were all told we would have 3 minutes to sit with her one-on-one. But unbeknownst to us, she had not yet had lunch, so we waited while she ordered and gulped down a quick bite, along with Andy, Joanne, and others with her. As a result, I’m not sure, but I think in the end our time was shortened to 2 minutes. I say I’m not sure, because in the moment, things become a bit of a blur, and I’m not really sure about anything. Anyhow, while each person was with her, dozens of others were watching and taking pictures. Whatever I might have thought I would say to her, I pretty much forgot it when the moment came, but I guess I said something, and she was, of course, sweet and gracious. I can’t imagine how she can hold up under meeting with so many people she doesn’t know.
Then Andy gave us the extreme joy of hearing a sample from the new album (no, Susan did not sing for us), although he emphasized that it was still a work in progress and had not had the mixing completed. We were actually able to give our reaction to one song, which was: absolutely beautiful, but we want less orchestra and more Susan!! Sound familiar? He assured us that would still be adjusted. Unfortunately, and this will probably cause more cataclysmic reactions, Sony insists absolutely that the title not be revealed until they put it out officially. But you will know one quite soon, because Susan is going to sing it on AGT.
OK, I rushed to write some of this now, since I know you’re wanting to hear more about what went on. Some of those attending are on their way home and can't post yet. Some don't have access to computers yet. I know there will be pictures, but I'm not proficient at that.
I sincerely thank those of you who are being understanding of this event. If you are thinking it’s daunting to post about it after reading some bitterness, you are right. I feel like hiding under a couch. In addition, I will need some serious time to decompress. I know for sure if there is another occasion, it will be another group entirely, and you’ll have your turn. To anyone feeling really bad, I understand, but I hope you can wait, as PT advised, until more is known about the purpose of the event and the reasons behind it before jumping to negative conclusions. Susan is an absolute angel, and she has the strongest defender in the world in Andy. That makes me very happy.
Loved this, Amber. Glad Susan has the stalwart Andy by her side. Thanks for feeding us hungry beasts. Glad you guys got in that bit about pulling back on the orchestra.
- 08-21-2011, 04:41 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by southernfan
Thanks Amber Duke and Sunandroses for the great reports. It sounds like Susan had as much fun as her fans.
What she said!!!!
08-21-2011, 04:38 AM
CzechLadyUSA
sunandroses, Thank you!!! Susan is such a gift to all of us... actually meeting small groups of fans and giving them her time and attention! I can see why there had to be such secrecy about this M & G. Susan is known worldwide now and a leak could have created a media storm that would have messed up everything that was planned. Susan really does love meeting her fans!! I know we all can't wait to see her perform on AGT! Thank you again.
08-21-2011, 04:39 AM
Anniev
Quote:
Originally Posted by chocolate eyes
"All animals are equal, but some animals are more equal than others." George Orwell, Animal Farm
Since words fail me right now, I'll let George Orwell speak for me.
After reading this, if I had been lucky enough to have been asked to attend, I would not be sharing my experience with anyone. A few of you have managed to spoil what was I am sure a very exciting a happy experience for those in attendance. Think about what you have posted and how those in NY may feel when they those posts.
08-21-2011, 04:40 AM
antique
Thank you also, sunandroses, for your nice report about the M & G today in NY.
08-21-2011, 04:41 AM
trennie
Quote:
Originally Posted by Amber Duke
Whew! I’m sure you all realize that no one who was there would post until they had read through all 24 pages of this thread first, and that takes time. Besides which I’ve been out for a family obligation and just got home.
I was one of the lucky, lucky, lucky ones! From the moment I got the message about it I have alternated between complete delirium/excitement and serious misgivings and worry about how the news would eventually be received on the forum. I know very well that if I had not been so fortunate this time I would have felt at least a twinge of envy and asked “why not me?” But then I would have to know that it appeared to be random, as I haven’t done anything to curry favor with anybody. So in the end, coming up with 20 people out of – gosh, how many are we in all? – was bound to cause disappointment among the remaining hundreds of fans. But believe me, we all had anxiety about how everyone else would feel. Then there were the many close friendships between some of the 20 and others on the forum. The first thing we would want to do is to share our news, but not one of us did, to my knowledge, because a promise is a promise. I absolutely believe Susan’s team – and it might have even come from beyond her team, although I’m not privy to all the information – had strong reasons for imposing a “gag” order about this. They are actually very conscient of Susan’s fans, believe it or not. Having seen Andy today, I’m more admiring of him than ever!
Having said that, I’ll say that GritsT’s initial description captures the essence of the event very well. Susan had been somewhere else this morning – and again, I have no idea where, nor did we ask – so we weren’t sure exactly when she would arrive. NYC traffic is unpredictable. So we ate quickly and waited. I have to admit to having a little trouble breathing when they said she was coming up the stairs. When you have seen her so many times on videos, the prospect of being in the same room is, well, kind of unreal. And what others have said in the past is true: seeing her in person is different. She has an aura that draws people to her; you can feel it. She was pretty casually dressed, and her hair was in her natural tousled curls. But it’s hard to focus on anything but her personality, as she hams it up, laughs and gives us all her energy. All the facial expressions we have seen over time come out in rapid succession. So fast that when you think you’re taking a picture of one, by the time the flash goes off, she’s on to another. She loves to clown.
We were all told we would have 3 minutes to sit with her one-on-one. But unbeknownst to us, she had not yet had lunch, so we waited while she ordered and gulped down a quick bite, along with Andy, Joanne, and others with her. As a result, I’m not sure, but I think in the end our time was shortened to 2 minutes. I say I’m not sure, because in the moment, things become a bit of a blur, and I’m not really sure about anything. Anyhow, while each person was with her, dozens of others were watching and taking pictures. Whatever I might have thought I would say to her, I pretty much forgot it when the moment came, but I guess I said something, and she was, of course, sweet and gracious. I can’t imagine how she can hold up under meeting with so many people she doesn’t know.
Then Andy gave us the extreme joy of hearing a sample from the new album (no, Susan did not sing for us), although he emphasized that it was still a work in progress and had not had the mixing completed. We were actually able to give our reaction to one song, which was: absolutely beautiful, but we want less orchestra and more Susan!! Sound familiar? He assured us that would still be adjusted. Unfortunately, and this will probably cause more cataclysmic reactions, Sony insists absolutely that the title not be revealed until they put it out officially. But you will know one quite soon, because Susan is going to sing it on AGT.
OK, I rushed to write some of this now, since I know you’re wanting to hear more about what went on. Some of those attending are on their way home and can't post yet. Some don't have access to computers yet. I know there will be pictures, but I'm not proficient at that.
I sincerely thank those of you who are being understanding of this event. If you are thinking it’s daunting to post about it after reading some bitterness, you are right. I feel like hiding under a couch. In addition, I will need some serious time to decompress. I know for sure if there is another occasion, it will be another group entirely, and you’ll have your turn. To anyone feeling really bad, I understand, but I hope you can wait, as PT advised, until more is known about the purpose of the event and the reasons behind it before jumping to negative conclusions. Susan is an absolute angel, and she has the strongest defender in the world in Andy. That makes me very happy.
Loved this, Amber. Glad Susan has the stalwart Andy by her side. Thanks for feeding us hungry beasts. Happy you guys got in that bit about pulling back on the orchestra. Can you tell us if the "absolutely beautiful" song was an original and also, what was your reaction to the other 3? Just anything you feel you can disclose.
08-21-2011, 04:41 AM
Henny
Quote:
Originally Posted by southernfan
Thanks Amber Duke and Sunandroses for the great reports. It sounds like Susan had as much fun as her fans.
What she said!!!!
08-21-2011, 04:43 AM
Thornton
I should like to know how you get to be on the A list! There are probably many of us who buy multiple copies of Subo's CD's but do not have the time to devote hours every day to following everything she does. We are no less fans! It is not really important to me whether I meet her or not but I feel somewhat disappointed by all of this.
08-21-2011, 04:47 AM
bunnyohare
All I can say is Wow!!!! Congratulations to the 20 chosen ones. I can't even imagine what it would have felt like to get a message inviting me to meet Susan. I am enjoying reading some of the comments from those who attended.
Rik, you are such a dear man to have been willing to give your chance to meet Susan to Lori. I know that must have meant a lot to her.
As for me, I once dreamed Susan was showing me around her kitchen and making a pot of tea for us to drink. I'll just keep waiting patiently until that dream comes true. After all, it would be my first trip to Scotland and I'd have more than 3 minutes to talk to her. :biggrin:;)
Okay, now that I've given my 2 cents worth, come on you 20. I want to hear more of your wonderful day in New York!!!!
Frannie
08-21-2011, 04:47 AM
JudyMcKinn
Quote:
Originally Posted by Anniev
After reading this, if I had been lucky enough to have been asked to attend, I would not be sharing my experience with anyone. A few of you have managed to spoil what was I am sure a very exciting a happy experience for those in attendance. Think about what you have posted and how those in NY may feel when they those posts.
I can't help but feel, Anniev, that most are mature enough to not pay too much attention to the few who are attempting to ruin this for all the rest of us. Please don't hesitate to post, NY 20, and know that the great majority are tickled to death for you, and waiting for reports and pictures. There are always a few--please don't let them ruin it for the rest of us.
08-21-2011, 04:49 AM
Amber Duke
Quote:
Originally Posted by trennie
Loved this, Amber. Glad Susan has the stalwart Andy by her side. Thanks for feeding us hungry beasts. Glad you guys got in that bit about pulling back on the orchestra.
LOL! It was a funny moment, actually, because practically everybody in the room was yelling the same thing. "Orchestra too loud!" By the way, Susan, was sitting sort of apart from us while the songs were playing, looking embarrassed, but pleased when we applauded. At one point she got very teary. So did we, in fact. For the last song she disappeared entirely.
Another sweet thing: Andy stood talking to us about the album, etc., with his arm around Susan. And she, in her style, kept mimicking him behind his back, making funny faces. Of course he knows her so well, and he realized it and chuckled. But she kept on doing it. In the end she gave him a big hug. She just melts your heart. I got a tear just now thinking of how loving she is.
08-21-2011, 04:51 AM
Linda Sharon
Quote:
Originally Posted by bunnyohare
All I can say is Wow!!!! Congratulations to the 20 chosen ones. I can't even imagine what it would have felt like to get a message inviting me to meet Susan. I am enjoying reading some of the comments from those who attended.
Rik, you are such a dear man to have been willing to give your chance to meet Susan to Lori. I know that must have meant a lot to her.
As for me, I once dreamed Susan was showing me around her kitchen and making a pot of tea for us to drink. I'll just keep waiting patiently until that dream comes true. After all, it would be my first trip to Scotland and I'd have more than 3 minutes to talk to her. :biggrin:;)
Okay, now that I've given my 2 cents worth, come on you 20. I want to hear more of your wonderful day in New York!!!!
Frannie
Love your dream. I also like the twitter report of someone who dreamed a dragon was coming for them and Susan banished it by singing at it. :overjoyed: That's pretty funny... now on to read about all this...so exciting...
08-21-2011, 04:52 AM
trennie
Quote:
Originally Posted by Robert the Bruce
I completely agree. It was most considerate of them to include dedicated fans in their tight schedule and to make an effort to have folks that haven't met her their focus.
Well done!
Hey, RTB. Your in box is full.
08-21-2011, 04:52 AM
Revel
Quote:
Originally Posted by Anniev
After reading this, if I had been lucky enough to have been asked to attend, I would not be sharing my experience with anyone. A few of you have managed to spoil what was I am sure a very exciting a happy experience for those in attendance. Think about what you have posted and how those in NY may feel when they those posts.
Oh, AnnieV, surely no amount of jealousy and complaining could compete with the joyful sunshine of time spent with Susan. :grouphug:
Thank you, Amber, for understanding any disappointment, and for sharing your thoughts, feelings and experience. And thank you, Sunandroses, for your report. So fun to hear the different details that different people remember. It's like filling in a picture with more and more points of light. Thanks again to both of you for your for your thoughtful reports!:grouphug:
P.S. I'm so very happy to read about some classic titles . . .:biggrin:
08-21-2011, 04:53 AM
Linda Sharon
Quote:
Originally Posted by JudyMcKinn
I can't help but feel, Anniev, that most are mature enough to not pay too much attention to the few who are attempting to ruin this for all the rest of us. Please don't hesitate to post, NY 20, and know that the great majority are tickled to death for you, and waiting for reports and pictures. There are always a few--please don't let them ruin it for the rest of us.
That's right - don't let ANYBODY rain on your parade. Enjoy your :cloud: Life dishes out a lot of awful things but this round honey - life dished out something wonderful for you. Savour the experience! -while we cheer you on.
08-21-2011, 04:53 AM
Amber Duke
Quote:
Originally Posted by Thornton
I should like to know how you get to be on the A list! There are probably many of us who buy multiple copies of Subo's CD's but do not have the time to devote hours every day to following everything she does. We are no less fans! It is not really important to me whether I meet her or not but I feel somewhat disappointed by all of this.
I don't believe there was an "A-list." I don't have any special connections that I know of, and there are plenty of more devoted forum posters than me, or than many of the ones who went, some of whom post only seldom. I just wonder, if confronted by the request to assemble 20 fans, how would you suggest? As I said, it sure looked random to me.
08-21-2011, 04:57 AM
Joan M for Susan
Thank you Amber Duke for your wonderful report. I loved reading your adventure and time with Susan.
08-21-2011, 04:58 AM
JudyMcKinn
Says there are currently 100 users on this thread. we haven't had this kind of interest and excitment for a while!
08-21-2011, 04:58 AM
gcy1
Quote:
Originally Posted by Amber Duke
Whew! I’m sure you all realize that no one who was there would post until they had read through all 24 pages of this thread first, and that takes time. Besides which I’ve been out for a family obligation and just got home.
I was one of the lucky, lucky, lucky ones! From the moment I got the message about it I have alternated between complete delirium/excitement and serious misgivings and worry about how the news would eventually be received on the forum. I know very well that if I had not been so fortunate this time I would have felt at least a twinge of envy and asked “why not me?” But then I would have to know that it appeared to be random, as I haven’t done anything to curry favor with anybody. So in the end, coming up with 20 people out of – gosh, how many are we in all? – was bound to cause disappointment among the remaining hundreds of fans. But believe me, we all had anxiety about how everyone else would feel. Then there were the many close friendships between some of the 20 and others on the forum. The first thing we would want to do is to share our news, but not one of us did, to my knowledge, because a promise is a promise. I absolutely believe Susan’s team – and it might have even come from beyond her team, although I’m not privy to all the information – had strong reasons for imposing a “gag” order about this. They are actually very conscient of Susan’s fans, believe it or not. Having seen Andy today, I’m more admiring of him than ever!
Having said that, I’ll say that GritsT’s initial description captures the essence of the event very well. Susan had been somewhere else this morning – and again, I have no idea where, nor did we ask – so we weren’t sure exactly when she would arrive. NYC traffic is unpredictable. So we ate quickly and waited. I have to admit to having a little trouble breathing when they said she was coming up the stairs. When you have seen her so many times on videos, the prospect of being in the same room is, well, kind of unreal. And what others have said in the past is true: seeing her in person is different. She has an aura that draws people to her; you can feel it. She was pretty casually dressed, and her hair was in her natural tousled curls. But it’s hard to focus on anything but her personality, as she hams it up, laughs and gives us all her energy. All the facial expressions we have seen over time come out in rapid succession. So fast that when you think you’re taking a picture of one, by the time the flash goes off, she’s on to another. She loves to clown.
We were all told we would have 3 minutes to sit with her one-on-one. But unbeknownst to us, she had not yet had lunch, so we waited while she ordered and gulped down a quick bite, along with Andy, Joanne, and others with her. As a result, I’m not sure, but I think in the end our time was shortened to 2 minutes. I say I’m not sure, because in the moment, things become a bit of a blur, and I’m not really sure about anything. Anyhow, while each person was with her, dozens of others were watching and taking pictures. Whatever I might have thought I would say to her, I pretty much forgot it when the moment came, but I guess I said something, and she was, of course, sweet and gracious. I can’t imagine how she can hold up under meeting with so many people she doesn’t know.
Then Andy gave us the extreme joy of hearing a sample from the new album (no, Susan did not sing for us), although he emphasized that it was still a work in progress and had not had the mixing completed. We were actually able to give our reaction to one song, which was: absolutely beautiful, but we want less orchestra and more Susan!! Sound familiar? He assured us that would still be adjusted. Unfortunately, and this will probably cause more cataclysmic reactions, Sony insists absolutely that the title not be revealed until they put it out officially. But you will know one quite soon, because Susan is going to sing it on AGT.
OK, I rushed to write some of this now, since I know you’re wanting to hear more about what went on. Some of those attending are on their way home and can't post yet. Some don't have access to computers yet. I know there will be pictures, but I'm not proficient at that.
I sincerely thank those of you who are being understanding of this event. If you are thinking it’s daunting to post about it after reading some bitterness, you are right. I feel like hiding under a couch. In addition, I will need some serious time to decompress. I know for sure if there is another occasion, it will be another group entirely, and you’ll have your turn. To anyone feeling really bad, I understand, but I hope you can wait, as PT advised, until more is known about the purpose of the event and the reasons behind it before jumping to negative conclusions. Susan is an absolute angel, and she has the strongest defender in the world in Andy. That makes me very happy.
I am disappointed I was not invited since I live in midtown NYC.
However, I am very happy for all of you who were invited and grateful for sharing your experience and excitement with us. This is the beginning of promotion for Susan's 3rd album, the real test for the longivity of her career.
08-21-2011, 04:59 AM
Joan M for Susan
Thank you very much sunandroses for your sharing of your time with Susan and the fans. I loved reading your post.
08-21-2011, 04:59 AM
kat d
Thankyou both for your reports,great to hear about the songs,and all the other little details.Now it is going to feel like a long wait before we hear them!
08-21-2011, 05:02 AM
Clemmie
Quote:
Originally Posted by Amber Duke
Whew! I’m sure you all realize that no one who was there would post until they had read through all 24 pages of this thread first, and that takes time. Besides which I’ve been out for a family obligation and just got home.
I was one of the lucky, lucky, lucky ones! From the moment I got the message about it I have alternated between complete delirium/excitement and serious misgivings and worry about how the news would eventually be received on the forum. I know very well that if I had not been so fortunate this time I would have felt at least a twinge of envy and asked “why not me?” But then I would have to know that it appeared to be random, as I haven’t done anything to curry favor with anybody. So in the end, coming up with 20 people out of – gosh, how many are we in all? – was bound to cause disappointment among the remaining hundreds of fans. But believe me, we all had anxiety about how everyone else would feel. Then there were the many close friendships between some of the 20 and others on the forum. The first thing we would want to do is to share our news, but not one of us did, to my knowledge, because a promise is a promise. I absolutely believe Susan’s team – and it might have even come from beyond her team, although I’m not privy to all the information – had strong reasons for imposing a “gag” order about this. They are actually very conscient of Susan’s fans, believe it or not. Having seen Andy today, I’m more admiring of him than ever!
Having said that, I’ll say that GritsT’s initial description captures the essence of the event very well. Susan had been somewhere else this morning – and again, I have no idea where, nor did we ask – so we weren’t sure exactly when she would arrive. NYC traffic is unpredictable. So we ate quickly and waited. I have to admit to having a little trouble breathing when they said she was coming up the stairs. When you have seen her so many times on videos, the prospect of being in the same room is, well, kind of unreal. And what others have said in the past is true: seeing her in person is different. She has an aura that draws people to her; you can feel it. She was pretty casually dressed, and her hair was in her natural tousled curls. But it’s hard to focus on anything but her personality, as she hams it up, laughs and gives us all her energy. All the facial expressions we have seen over time come out in rapid succession. So fast that when you think you’re taking a picture of one, by the time the flash goes off, she’s on to another. She loves to clown.
We were all told we would have 3 minutes to sit with her one-on-one. But unbeknownst to us, she had not yet had lunch, so we waited while she ordered and gulped down a quick bite, along with Andy, Joanne, and others with her. As a result, I’m not sure, but I think in the end our time was shortened to 2 minutes. I say I’m not sure, because in the moment, things become a bit of a blur, and I’m not really sure about anything. Anyhow, while each person was with her, dozens of others were watching and taking pictures. Whatever I might have thought I would say to her, I pretty much forgot it when the moment came, but I guess I said something, and she was, of course, sweet and gracious. I can’t imagine how she can hold up under meeting with so many people she doesn’t know.
Then Andy gave us the extreme joy of hearing a sample from the new album (no, Susan did not sing for us), although he emphasized that it was still a work in progress and had not had the mixing completed. We were actually able to give our reaction to one song, which was: absolutely beautiful, but we want less orchestra and more Susan!! Sound familiar? He assured us that would still be adjusted. Unfortunately, and this will probably cause more cataclysmic reactions, Sony insists absolutely that the title not be revealed until they put it out officially. But you will know one quite soon, because Susan is going to sing it on AGT.
OK, I rushed to write some of this now, since I know you’re wanting to hear more about what went on. Some of those attending are on their way home and can't post yet. Some don't have access to computers yet. I know there will be pictures, but I'm not proficient at that.
I sincerely thank those of you who are being understanding of this event. If you are thinking it’s daunting to post about it after reading some bitterness, you are right. I feel like hiding under a couch. In addition, I will need some serious time to decompress. I know for sure if there is another occasion, it will be another group entirely, and you’ll have your turn. To anyone feeling really bad, I understand, but I hope you can wait, as PT advised, until more is known about the purpose of the event and the reasons behind it before jumping to negative conclusions. Susan is an absolute angel, and she has the strongest defender in the world in Andy. That makes me very happy.
Thank you Grits, Amber Duke and Sunandroses for your wonderful comments which I ditto. I too have been both hiding under the couch, decompressing and at the same time preparing for a big event. Therefore I am not able to write at length at this time, but want to say that I too was there and I wish everyone could have been there. Susan is a dear and precious woman with a heart of gold. Her talent is without measure. We are all so lucky to have her in our lives.
08-21-2011, 05:02 AM
soothed
Thank you for the reports. I just am anxious for RIK to get his song. Hope it is on there.
08-21-2011, 05:03 AM
Lisa Pully
Quote:
Originally Posted by Amber Duke
LOL! It was a funny moment, actually, because practically everybody in the room was yelling the same thing. "Orchestra too loud!" By the way, Susan, was sitting sort of apart from us while the songs were playing, looking embarrassed, but pleased when we applauded. At one point she got very teary. So did we, in fact. For the last song she disappeared entirely.
Another sweet thing: Andy stood talking to us about the album, etc., with his arm around Susan. And she, in her style, kept mimicking him behind his back, making funny faces. Of course he knows her so well, and he realized it and chuckled. But she kept on doing it. In the end she gave him a big hug. She just melts your heart. I got a tear just now thinking of how loving she is.
First thank you to GritsT, sunandroses and Amber Duke for the recap of todays splended event! Please Blessed 20, please the rest of you give us your story.
And Amber Duke?? I so cannot see Susan doing the high lighted words ....:laught2:
08-21-2011, 05:04 AM
trennie
Quote:
Originally Posted by Amber Duke
LOL! It was a funny moment, actually, because practically everybody in the room was yelling the same thing. "Orchestra too loud!" By the way, Susan, was sitting sort of apart from us while the songs were playing, looking embarrassed, but pleased when we applauded. At one point she got very teary. So did we, in fact. For the last song she disappeared entirely.
Another sweet thing: Andy stood talking to us about the album, etc., with his arm around Susan. And she, in her style, kept mimicking him behind his back, making funny faces. Of course he knows her so well, and he realized it and chuckled. But she kept on doing it. In the end she gave him a big hug. She just melts your heart. I got a tear just now thinking of how loving she is.
Do you mean she got teary at a song, Amber?
08-21-2011, 05:04 AM
irisheyes
So happy to hear your reports!! I love all the descriptions... We're all so lucky to be able to share this time...this Susan Boyle time in history...
- 08-21-2011, 05:06 AM
Thanks for posting, Clemmie. Looking forward to more of your thoughts, when you feel up to it. Everyone there sort of saw the same things, but all will have different feelings and thoughts, so please don't hesitate to post, everyone, just because others of the lucky 20 have already posted. We look forward to everyone's thoughts and comments.
- 08-21-2011, 05:07 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Kalua
Ok folks sometimes you simply do not realize when to stop, if you really would read all that was said carefully
you would have understood that is is the documentary that the team wanted to keep under wraps. By mentioning it over and over again you are killing something that Subo Team wanted to be secret
Now all posts talking about it will be deleted by the staff and mine also once it has been read.
Thank you for your understanding
I have run ahead and read thru what starts to be page 26 of notes tonight. I understand all the opinions expressed here and particularly appreciate that three of the attendees have given us the thumbnail sketch of today's M&G. As much as we 'nosey Susan lovers' want to see and hear More and More and More, there are times when we really need LESS.
I'm pleased that RIK was asked and saddened that he and LisaP couldn't put feet or wings to any plans to attend. I hope at least one other male fan was included; sometimes it seems a tad lopsided when it is just SusaSisters, though I love a hen fest as much as anyone.
There is something that is a tiny spec in the note above from our Leader and apparently alluded in other posts ..... dealing with the 'doc' word .... I hope that the SONY team has a careful knowledge of where their 'doc' is going IF they Are going to add today's (or any other day's) M&G footage to their 'doc in progress'. The flip side of that, whether dvd or tv or what, is Susan's FUTURE SAFETY. Just saying .... I hope it is edited and presented in a way so we as forum and fansites are not deluged with even more trolls in the future. And where you find trolls you find paps, etc. and vice versa and maybe other strange events we have seen intrude upon Susan.
After reading this full day's dialogue I have a thought I'll toss out for Leadership's consideration. Kalua has alluded to all 'doc' posts being deleted when the thread dies down. I would take it a step further: There are not more than a dozen really good posts in this thread, most are from the attendees. Rather than let this entire thread fuminate in our archives, I would rather those really good posts be culled, harvested and put into a future thread in coming days for all the reports of the attendees --- and the rest of this entire thread be vanquished to the ether. We keep saying we want more members to come to the forum, but when they get inside the doors and start reading discussions like this one with so much negative dialog, I would rather it be deep-sixed altogether, gone at Midnight EST along with the rest of Cinderella's mice and coach. So that's my request, Skipper -- our Captain K. --- would request to tie an anchor on the thread and deep-six it at 23:59, Sir.
(PS It WAS Lovely to have seen such a nice turnout today. Looking forward to seeing everyone again in a day or two when the 20 attendees can finish updating us, although I must admit, I think we know more than we need to already. AGT confirmation is plenty for me.)
:grouphug: :Ilovesusan:
- 08-21-2011, 05:16 AM
I agree, Zasu, I'd like a thread with just reports.
(And a big thanks to GritsT, sunandroses, and Amber Duke for the reports so far.)
- 08-21-2011, 05:25 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by gcy1
I am disappointed I was not invited since I live in midtown NYC.
However, I am very happy for all of you who were invited and grateful for sharing your experience and excitement with us. This is the beginning of promotion for Susan's 3rd album, the real test for the longivity of her career.
GCY, your last sentence is so true (I'd bold it if I'd learned). You're right, what was really important about today was not all this other stuff, but that it was the beginning of Phase II of her career. And I'd really love to hear more reaction to the 4 songs.
- 08-21-2011, 05:28 AM
I don't think the folks who have expressed disappointment are necessarily trying to steal the joy of those who were fortunate enough to have been chosen. I believe their feelings were genuinely hurt, especially if they've felt overlooked in the past. But since at least 3 of the fans who were with Susan have kindly shared their stories of their time with her, I think it's becoming clearer that security was paramount, folks who had never met her were selected fairly randomly and personal slights were never intended. Folks who haven't met her yet may well be able to enjoy a similar experience in the future. Thank you, Grits, Amber Duke and S & R for sharing your special time with Susan. These are moments to treasure. :) I hope you've jotted them all down for posterity!
- 08-21-2011, 05:28 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by JudyMcKinn
I can't help but feel, Anniev, that most are mature enough to not pay too much attention to the few who are attempting to ruin this for all the rest of us. Please don't hesitate to post, NY 20, and know that the great majority are tickled to death for you, and waiting for reports and pictures. There are always a few--please don't let them ruin it for the rest of us.
No one is attempting to ruin anything - a number of fans are simply sharing their feelings.
- 08-21-2011, 05:32 AM
May I add my thanks to GritsT, Amber Duke and sunandroses for your wonderful reports. AD, I could almost imagine I was one of the twenty and "remembering" that marvellous experience rather than reading about your experience :) And S&R, thank you for describing so well the environment of the gathering and how important it was not to attract attention from outsiders. You have explained very clearly why it needed to be kept a secret. I loved to read that Susan was happy and relaxed and funny and enjoying herself. Can't wait to see some photos.
Also looking forward to detailed reports from Clemmie and from the other members of the NY20 when they have finally floated down to earth. :biggrin:
- 08-21-2011, 05:33 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by trennie
Do you mean she got teary at a song, Amber?
Trennie, I believe she got teary at our response. I'm sure she was anxious about it.
- 08-21-2011, 05:35 AM
I don't agree ZaSu. I guess I'm a purist. i don't think this thread should be edited to keep some posts. It's organic and it's just my opinion that threads should not be tampered with. I feel this is a historical account of Susan's journey through the fans point of view and should not be altered.
- 08-21-2011, 05:37 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Anniev
I find this post to be quite offensive on so many levels. You are of course entitled to your opinion, however, name calling is never appropriate. Stating that this forum is not a democracy if your rude comment is removed, is certainly threatening. Susan and her team have every right to do what they want and how they want, what the motives of their actions are, is quite frankly none of our business.
You have asked that you not be given warnings, I am sorry that I will not be able to comply with your request. You will be getting a PM from me shortly. You have violated Rule1 by not showing respect for Susan and her team and have violated and rule 2.
While"What a Jerk" is perhaps not the most diplomatic of descriptions to use, we are adults and should be treated as such. This "naughty step" business, I find troubling and I agree with another post that it would have been better protocol to deal with any matter which caused concern in a private way.
08-21-2011, 05:40 AM
trennie
Quote:
Originally Posted by Amber Duke
Trennie, I believe she got teary at our response. I'm sure she was anxious about it.
That's so interesting. So she sat through two songs looking somewhat embarrassed got teary, at the third(?) and left at the 4th. Did Joanne or Andy go with her? And did she return later?
08-21-2011, 05:41 AM
diane wheldrake
Thank you Grits, Amber and Sunandroses for your wonderful reports, now I shall go to bed happy and dream of Susan.
08-21-2011, 05:49 AM
Linda Sharon
Quote:
Originally Posted by trennie
That's so interesting. So she sat through two songs looking somewhat embarrassed got teary, at the third(?) and left at the 4th. Did Joanne or Andy go with her? And did she return later?
Well here's the thing (as Mr. Monk says), I write poems/songs etc.and if someone else is reading them I feel really squirmy and a little self conscious til I see if they like them or not. Maybe it was something like that. So her reaction makes perfect sense to me. You feel really vulnerable when someone is critiquing your work.
08-21-2011, 05:49 AM
fanfromgeorgia
A new thread has been created for all current and additional reports from the M&G with Susan.
http://forum.susan-boyle.com/threads...usan-8-20-2011
Current reports will be moved over shortly..
08-21-2011, 05:50 AM
Glo
Quote:
Originally Posted by MollBobbers
May I add my thanks to GritsT, Amber Duke and sunandroses for your wonderful reports. AD, I could almost imagine I was one of the twenty and "remembering" that marvellous experience rather than reading about your experience :) And S&R, thank you for describing so well the environment of the gathering and how important it was not to attract attention from outsiders. You have explained very clearly why it needed to be kept a secret. I loved to read that Susan was happy and relaxed and funny and enjoying herself. Can't wait to see some photos.
Also looking forward to detailed reports from Clemmie and from the other members of the NY20 when they have finally floated down to earth. :biggrin:
What she said!
08-21-2011, 05:52 AM
GritsT
Others took lots more pictures than I did, but here's a picture of Susan "hamming it up!"
Now I'm going to bed - early flight back to TX in the morning!
http://i52.tinypic.com/10xdp9c.jpg
08-21-2011, 05:56 AM
trennie
Quote:
Originally Posted by Linda Sharon
Well here's the thing (as Mr. Monk says), I write poems/songs etc.and if someone else is reading them I feel really squirmy and a little self conscious til I see if they like them or not. Maybe it was something like that. So her reaction makes perfect sense to me. You feel really vulnerable when someone is critiquing your work.
I think you're probably right, Linda and she left for the last one, because it was just getting a little too much.
08-21-2011, 05:57 AM
Lisa Pully
Quote:
Originally Posted by GritsT
Others took lots more pictures than I did, but here's a picture of Susan "hamming it up!"
Now I'm going to bed - early flight back to TX in the morning!
http://i52.tinypic.com/10xdp9c.jpg
Thank you so much GritsT, This woman sure knows how to crack me up!! :D I LOVE the sun visor LOL
08-21-2011, 05:57 AM
Glo
Thank you, GritsT - that's a lovely photo Susan.
08-21-2011, 05:57 AM
Linda Sharon
Quote:
Originally Posted by GritsT
Others took lots more pictures than I did, but here's a picture of Susan "hamming it up!"
Now I'm going to bed - early flight back to TX in the morning!
http://i52.tinypic.com/10xdp9c.jpg
\
Great stuff. Susan 'hamming it up' is one of her most endearing qualities.
In New York last Nov as well, she cracked me up swishing the tales of her coat back and forth and making muscle man motions with her arms. Part of her wonderful charm. Can't wait for more of these pics.
08-21-2011, 05:58 AM
Retired In Kalifornia
Quote:
Originally Posted by GritsT
Others took lots more pictures than I did, but here's a picture of Susan "hamming it up!"
Now I'm going to bed - early flight back to TX in the morning!
http://i52.tinypic.com/10xdp9c.jpg
:dance::clap::dance:
08-21-2011, 05:58 AM
chocolate eyes
Quote:
Originally Posted by Anniev
After reading this, if I had been lucky enough to have been asked to attend, I would not be sharing my experience with anyone. A few of you have managed to spoil what was I am sure a very exciting a happy experience for those in attendance. Think about what you have posted and how those in NY may feel when they those posts.
Annie, with all due respect, I said nothing in my post to cast any aspersions upon those fans fortunate enough to attend. I am very glad that they had the privilege and joy of meeting Susan, Andy, Joanne and the rest of the entourage. They are very kind to share their experiences and their happiness.
Believe me, I thought VERY carefully about what I posted before I posted it. Lest there be any further misunderstanding, my post was NOT directed at those lucky fans. My statement concerned the interesting, shall we say, manner in which the encounter was planned and executed. But, I will say no more.
08-21-2011, 05:59 AM
MollBobbers
Others took lots more pictures than I did, but here's a picture of Susan "hamming it up!"
Thank you GritsT. That pic is precious. Awwwww. :)
08-21-2011, 06:04 AM
gaylefromva
I am so happy to hear all of the reports. It sounds as though you had a wonderful time. I think the old saying holds true: "You can please some of the people some of the time, but you can't please all of the people all of the time." I think that soon, we will be able to see the whole picture and know why these decisions were made. I think all of Susan's fans are important to her. I can't wait to hear her new song on AGT.
08-21-2011, 06:05 AM
MollBobbers
Quote:
Originally Posted by fanfromgeorgia
A new thread has been created for all current and additional reports from the M&G with Susan.
http://forum.susan-boyle.com/threads...usan-8-20-2011
Current reports will be moved over shortly..
Thank you FFG. I take it that all photos will be moved over there also? That would be great. :)
08-21-2011, 06:13 AM
Trish (Pat Pierce)
Quote:
Originally Posted by Retired In Kalifornia
If she will be taped I'll likely have to leave Cameron Park around 11:30 p.m. the 30th IF there is A.M. taping, haven't done all-night drive in years - ugh!
Richard...if Susan WILL be on AGT on 8/31, wouldn't she surely be taping on 8/30? I plan to go down on AMTRAK on 8/29 th, to leave a bit of a cushion, since AMTRAK doesn't always run on schedule. Hope to see you and many more Susafriends there at AGT...YIPPEEE... We stood in line for four hours last year, then Susan wasn't allowed to sing. Hope we're successful this time, so Richard, I suggest that you get your name on that waiting list for tickets for the 30th, as well, until we get definite word just when the TAPING will occur.
08-21-2011, 06:14 AM
pardonmeboy
Quote:
Originally Posted by riseandshine
I don't agree ZaSu. I guess I'm a purist. i don't think this thread should be edited to keep some posts. It's organic and it's just my opinion that threads should not be tampered with. I feel this is a historical account of Susan's journey through the fans point of view and should not be altered.
I agree.
08-21-2011, 06:16 AM
Trish (Pat Pierce)
Quote:
Originally Posted by Lisa Pully
He certainly is isnt he? :D
YES, RIK is a compassionate gentleman and DEVOUT SUSAFAN! And, Lisa, I'M glad to hear you received an invitation, at least, for all you have contributed through the months past. Hugs to you! ~Trish
08-21-2011, 06:18 AM
downfaw
Quote:
Originally Posted by Muey
I don't think the folks who have expressed disappointment are necessarily trying to steal the joy of those who were fortunate enough to have been chosen. I believe their feelings were genuinely hurt, especially if they've felt overlooked in the past. But since at least 3 of the fans who were with Susan have kindly shared their stories of their time with her, I think it's becoming clearer that security was paramount, folks who had never met her were selected fairly randomly and personal slights were never intended. Fans who have not yet met Susan may well be able to enjoy a similar experience in the future. Thank you, Grits, Amber Duke and S & R for sharing your special time with Susan. These are moments to treasure. :) I hope you've jotted all your favorite memories down for posterity!
I agree totally.
08-21-2011, 06:20 AM
cac1936
Great report, AD. Please don't spend another minute behind that couch!!!:biggrin: I know it was a magical moment for you and am so happy for you and the others who were able to experience being up close to the charismatic and amazing Susan Boyle. I can't imagine how it could have been planned or executed differently or better.
08-21-2011, 06:21 AM
Lisa Pully
Quote:
Originally Posted by Trish (Pat Pierce)
YES, RIK is a compassionate gentleman and DEVOUT SUSAFAN! And, Lisa, I'M glad to hear you received an invitation, at least, for all you have contributed through the months past. Hugs to you! ~Trish
Trish, you are such a dear, I just hope that if the offer ever comes back up that I will be asked maybe once again. Until I will love and enjoy the visit through the eyes of the Blessed 20 :D
08-21-2011, 06:25 AM
Retired In Kalifornia
Quote:
Originally Posted by Trish (Pat Pierce)
Richard...if Susan WILL be on AGT on 8/31, wouldn't she surely be taping on 8/30? I plan to go down on AMTRAK on 8/29 th, to leave a bit of a cushion, since AMTRAK doesn't always run on schedule. Hope to see you and many more Susafriends there at AGT...YIPPEEE... We stood in line for four hours last year, then Susan wasn't allowed to sing. Hope we're successful this time, so Richard, I suggest that you get your name on that waiting list for tickets for the 30th, as well, until we get definite word just when the TAPING will occur.
Trish "best info" I have it will be August 31st and I now have doubts that I'll make it as am on the Waiting List so my odds aren't good.
08-21-2011, 06:25 AM
Trish (Pat Pierce)
Thank you, Amber, for sharing your memories and emotions so transparently. WE LOVE YOU, and are so thrilled that you had the honor and joy of meeting Susan and Andy in person! And, you surely needed more decompression time, but cared enough to make it to your keyboard to touch base with us...and WE THANK YOU FOR YOUR THOUGHTFULNESS! HUGS! ~Trish
08-21-2011, 06:26 AM
ksdust
I'm glad fans got to be with Susan and report back to us. thank you!
now here are the most important things to me:
1. they heard songs from the new cd and thought they were good! I know Susan is good big grin but I have been a little worried about how they'd have her sing, I don't like much of today's pop music.
2. we will all hear a new song when she sings it on AGT. and that is soon. lots closer than November!
3. Susan is getting publicity in the U.S.!
and always the most important thing is that Susan is happy!
08-21-2011, 06:32 AM
cac1936
I'm not sure I think the question of security should even have had to be explained, S&R, but you did it perfectly. Thanks for the great report. Am so happy for you that you had such a wonderful day and hope you will feel free to share pix and any other thoughts about things you can discuss.
08-21-2011, 06:39 AM
fanfromgeorgia
as posted previously, all future reports from the M&G and all photos are to be put on this thread:
http://forum.susan-boyle.com/threads...863#post559863
Thank you!
08-21-2011, 06:43 AM
tweek
Amber,
Thank you for the wonderful report...and after having met you last fall in New York, I am so glad you had this opportunity to take part in this wonderful Meet & Greet. I sense from all your posts that you are a great Susan fan and rightfully deserved this chance.
I think what people have to realize here Susan did not personally make the choice of who was there. Susan is most relaxed when in smaller groups so even if more people could have been invited, it would have been too stressful for her. Susan also realizes that each one of her fans is important to her. She is where she is today, not only because she is extremely talented, but because of the support she gets from each and every one of us... in whatever small way it is. We are all important to Susan and feeling hurt or left out...is not the answer.
I have met Susan only once and it was not at a Meet and Greet...if I am never able to meet her again...then that's the way it will go down. Will I feel bad? No! I feel in my heart I am just as important to Susan as each and everyone else is. She appreciates all of us. And, that's what you all need to remember. We all love Susan, and her music has given each of us something special. That will not change. Am I a better fan than you, No I am not.... have I done more for Susan than you... No I have not. We all make up Susan's fan base whether we contribute a great deal or something small. She loves all of us...whether we be in her physical presence or not. Maybe she will never get to meet each and every one of us...but be grateful for what she has given to all of us.
I think some of you have expressed yourself better than myself but I wanted to at least say a few words and I am also happy for those who had their chance today.
tweekie
08-21-2011, 06:52 AM
entropydecides
Soothed, Thanks so much for your humor throughout this thread.
Feelings of disappointment are not childish, but understandable given the level of excitement that a visit with Susan generates.
Those selected to participate could have easily been any one of us, it's just hard to accept that fact given the
required secrecy. I hope to hear more stories soon. All who participate on this forum should congratulate themselves on the level of support that they have provided to Susan over the years. I feel those selected and those not selected are on equal footing in their admiration and enthusiasm for Susan.
Amber Duke, Thanks so much for your excellent recollection of events. (I always forget everything that happened) I'm glad you all expressed a shared desire to tone down the orchestra. Grits T. has shown herself to be a woman of action and had very little time to pull this off.
08-21-2011, 06:55 AM
Amber Duke
Quote:
Originally Posted by trennie
That's so interesting. So she sat through two songs looking somewhat embarrassed got teary, at the third(?) and left at the 4th. Did Joanne or Andy go with her? And did she return later?
Sorry, I probably didn't report that quite right. There were 2 rooms with a connecting wide doorway. We were sitting in one, and she was sitting in the other at that moment, but in view of some of us. For the last song, she just moved to another side of that room where we didn't see her. For whatever reason, and I don't want to overdo with speculation. I felt maybe she didn't want to be observed at that moment. But of course there may have been another reason. Joanne was also over there. She came back when we burst into applause. What I am sure of is that it's a little traumatic for anyone to have recorded something new and sit while your fans hear it for the first time. I would have been anxious if it had been me. I can tell you, though, that after the first song, we were the ones in tears.
08-21-2011, 07:02 AM
fantine
On the "Susan In New York" thread I responded to a picture of Susan by saying that it was nice to see her enjoying a pleasant summer afternoon in New York. Well, it appears Susan had a very pleasant time with her adoring fans, too! Thanks to all the attendees for extending a warm welcome to Susan. The few reports already posted are great! Going to the new thread and looking forward to more news of the exciting event.
Thank you for the heads up about AGT on Aug. 31!
- 08-21-2011, 07:12 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by entropydecides
Soothed, Thanks so much for your humor throughout this thread.
Feelings of disappointment are not childish, but understandable given the level of excitement that a visit with Susan generates.
Those selected to participate could have easily been any one of us, it's just hard to accept that fact given the
required secrecy. I hope to hear more stories soon. All who participate on this forum should congratulate themselves on the level of support that they have provided to Susan over the years. I feel those selected and those not selected are on equal footing in their admiration and enthusiasm for Susan.
Amber Duke, Thanks so much for your excellent recollection of events. (I always forget everything that happened) I'm glad you all expressed a shared desire to tone down the orchestra. Grits T. has shown herself to be a woman of action and had very little time to pull this off.
I completely agree with you, entropydecides. The fact is that GritsT was given very little time to pull something together, and she did so admirably, in spite of the fact that she was more than inundated with her personal life at the same time. I doubt that she ever got to sleep! Somebody has to organize, and she, Randma and Janna stepped up to the plate and did a fantastic job. I thank them all, as well as others who helped them in many ways.
Tweek, you said it beautifully.
And Lisa and RIK (also several others who were approached and couldn't make it), I'm so sorry you weren't there. Although, come to think of it, maybe that's why I got to go! :biggrin: Who knows?
- 08-21-2011, 07:21 AM
Thank you, sunandroses, for your marvelous, detailed report. Yes, I agree, that Susan's safety and privacy is of utmost importance. Susan will forever cherish that lovely poetry book. Thank you for taking the time to type out such wonderful details for us to enjoy, for I know you all must be so very weary.
How did those who had never flown to NYC previously manage to find their way from the airport to the hotel? Did Andy provide transportation and an escort for those who needed assistance, if they were inexperienced travelers in a enormous city? Isn't Andy just the epitome of thoughtfulness! He is absolutely the perfect manager and business partner for Susan. And, yes, what joy it is to see Susan enjoying gatherings with small groups of her fans. She has a tender heart for people, such a key component of her amazing character and personality.
I'm hoping to be able to get AMTRAK tickets to L.A., for Susan's AGT studio recording, but we are all unsure if it will be recorded on the 30th or the 31st. It seems as though she would need to record the previous day, if her performance was broadcast on August 31st. Are any of you allowed to provide some clear guidelines for those of us wanting to make train reservations, etc. plans to be there to support Susan in person at the Burbank CBS Recording Studio? Love, Trish
- 08-21-2011, 07:29 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by fanfromgeorgia
as posted previously, all future reports from the M&G and all photos are to be put on this thread:
http://forum.susan-boyle.com/threads...863#post559863
Thank you!
I'm bumping this one up, for this is the first time I've noticed this post. THANKS, fanfromgeorgia!
- 08-21-2011, 08:05 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by pardonmeboy
No one is attempting to ruin anything - a number of fans are simply sharing their feelings.
Some fans have simply expressed their compassion to those who were not invited. I had always thought to have concern for others less fortunate was a pretty commendable quality. For some apparently it is, for others apparently not.
- 08-21-2011, 08:06 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by entropydecides
Soothed, Thanks so much for your humor throughout this thread.
Feelings of disappointment are not childish, but understandable given the level of excitement that a visit with Susan generates.
Those selected to participate could have easily been any one of us, it's just hard to accept that fact given the
required secrecy. I hope to hear more stories soon. All who participate on this forum should congratulate themselves on the level of support that they have provided to Susan over the years. I feel those selected and those not selected are on equal footing in their admiration and enthusiasm for Susan.
Amber Duke, Thanks so much for your excellent recollection of events. (I always forget everything that happened) I'm glad you all expressed a shared desire to tone down the orchestra. Grits T. has shown herself to be a woman of action and had very little time to pull this off.
Entropydecides, thank you. I went to bed and couldn't sleep. Mixed emotions. Worried about everyone, but for anyone who comes here and thinks we don't care about each other, they are wrong. We are a combined force, united by our love for Susan and nothing is going to change that. Now that I have seen the great photos of our lovely lady slumber will come easily. Thank you all for the reports and have a good night.
08-21-2011, 08:36 AM
pmweber1
Quote:
Originally Posted by Susan43212
I'm happy for the fans who were a part of this M&G especially the first timers. I'm looking forward to sharing the experience through reading their stories. How exciting!! I hope we hear from them soon.
:Ilovesusan:
:excellent: I wholeheartedly second my friend, Susan43212's post, thoughts and sentiments! I, too, hope -- one day -- to meet Miss Susan Boyle in person and to hear her sing in a live performance! If it is meant to be; it will happen! Until and if then, I'm so happy for EVERYONE who was able to meet, greet and hear Miss Boyle sing in person on Saturday! Thank you, most of all, dear Susa-Friends, for generously sharing your excitment, recollections and photos with ALL of us!
:Ilovesusan::susanrocks:
:love: to ALL!
Patty
08-21-2011, 08:50 AM
Misti in Seattle
Quote:
Originally Posted by Amber Duke
Whew! I’m sure you all realize that no one who was there would post until they had read through all 24 pages of this thread first, and that takes time. Besides which I’ve been out for a family obligation and just got home.
I was one of the lucky, lucky, lucky ones! From the moment I got the message about it I have alternated between complete delirium/excitement and serious misgivings and worry about how the news would eventually be received on the forum. I know very well that if I had not been so fortunate this time I would have felt at least a twinge of envy and asked “why not me?” But then I would have to know that it appeared to be random, as I haven’t done anything to curry favor with anybody. So in the end, coming up with 20 people out of – gosh, how many are we in all? – was bound to cause disappointment among the remaining hundreds of fans. But believe me, we all had anxiety about how everyone else would feel. Then there were the many close friendships between some of the 20 and others on the forum. The first thing we would want to do is to share our news, but not one of us did, to my knowledge, because a promise is a promise. I absolutely believe Susan’s team – and it might have even come from beyond her team, although I’m not privy to all the information – had strong reasons for imposing a “gag” order about this. They are actually very conscient of Susan’s fans, believe it or not. Having seen Andy today, I’m more admiring of him than ever!
Having said that, I’ll say that GritsT’s initial description captures the essence of the event very well. Susan had been somewhere else this morning – and again, I have no idea where, nor did we ask – so we weren’t sure exactly when she would arrive. NYC traffic is unpredictable. So we ate quickly and waited. I have to admit to having a little trouble breathing when they said she was coming up the stairs. When you have seen her so many times on videos, the prospect of being in the same room is, well, kind of unreal. And what others have said in the past is true: seeing her in person is different. She has an aura that draws people to her; you can feel it. She was pretty casually dressed, and her hair was in her natural tousled curls. But it’s hard to focus on anything but her personality, as she hams it up, laughs and gives us all her energy. All the facial expressions we have seen over time come out in rapid succession. So fast that when you think you’re taking a picture of one, by the time the flash goes off, she’s on to another. She loves to clown.
We were all told we would have 3 minutes to sit with her one-on-one. But unbeknownst to us, she had not yet had lunch, so we waited while she ordered and gulped down a quick bite, along with Andy, Joanne, and others with her. As a result, I’m not sure, but I think in the end our time was shortened to 2 minutes. I say I’m not sure, because in the moment, things become a bit of a blur, and I’m not really sure about anything. Anyhow, while each person was with her, dozens of others were watching and taking pictures. Whatever I might have thought I would say to her, I pretty much forgot it when the moment came, but I guess I said something, and she was, of course, sweet and gracious. I can’t imagine how she can hold up under meeting with so many people she doesn’t know.
Then Andy gave us the extreme joy of hearing a sample from the new album (no, Susan did not sing for us), although he emphasized that it was still a work in progress and had not had the mixing completed. We were actually able to give our reaction to one song, which was: absolutely beautiful, but we want less orchestra and more Susan!! Sound familiar? He assured us that would still be adjusted. Unfortunately, and this will probably cause more cataclysmic reactions, Sony insists absolutely that the title not be revealed until they put it out officially. But you will know one quite soon, because Susan is going to sing it on AGT.
OK, I rushed to write some of this now, since I know you’re wanting to hear more about what went on. Some of those attending are on their way home and can't post yet. Some don't have access to computers yet. I know there will be pictures, but I'm not proficient at that.
I sincerely thank those of you who are being understanding of this event. If you are thinking it’s daunting to post about it after reading some bitterness, you are right. I feel like hiding under a couch. In addition, I will need some serious time to decompress. I know for sure if there is another occasion, it will be another group entirely, and you’ll have your turn. To anyone feeling really bad, I understand, but I hope you can wait, as PT advised, until more is known about the purpose of the event and the reasons behind it before jumping to negative conclusions. Susan is an absolute angel, and she has the strongest defender in the world in Andy. That makes me very happy.
WHHAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAATT???? LOL you got invited! How super! And yes, you were able to keep it a super secret!! I never had a clue! :) Good for you!!!! So happy for you.
And personally I think they were very wise to keep it quiet. After all, a lady should be able to plan a little party without half the world expecting to be invited or, worse yet, crashing it. :)
08-21-2011, 08:57 AM
AngelPrecious
Quote:
Originally Posted by pmweber1
:excellent: I wholeheartedly second my friend, Susan43212's post, thoughts and sentiments! I, too, hope -- one day -- to meet Miss Susan Boyle in person and to hear her sing in a live performance! If it is meant to be; it will happen! Until and if then, I'm so happy for EVERYONE who was able to meet, greet and hear Miss Boyle sing in person on Saturday! Thank you, most of all, dear Susa-Friends, for generously sharing your excitment, recollections and photos with ALL of us!
:Ilovesusan::susanrocks:
:love: to ALL!
Patty
:excellent:
Although I can somewhat understand the sadness of some fans that were not invited, I think its best to trust that the ones chosen were meant to meet Susan at this time. I am very happy that 20 of Susan's fans could share in this experience!!! I hope that all that attended will feel free to share this wonderful experience with the forum! I can't wait to find out about the songs that you people heard and I am very, very excited that Susan will be on the finals of AGT!!!
:Ilovesusan:
08-21-2011, 08:58 AM
Amber Duke
Quote:
Originally Posted by Misti in Seattle
WHHAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAATT???? LOL you got invited! How super! And yes, you were able to keep it a super secret!! I never had a clue! :) Good for you!!!! So happy for you.
And personally I think they were very wise to keep it quiet. After all, a lady should be able to plan a little party without half the world expecting to be invited or, worse yet, crashing it. :)
Thanks, Sue. Yep, it was pretty durn hard to keep the secret from good friends! Sorry. :'(
Aren't those the cutest pictures? Many thanks to Sandi for posting them!
08-21-2011, 09:04 AM
Amber Duke
Quote:
Originally Posted by pmweber1
:excellent: I wholeheartedly second my friend, Susan43212's post, thoughts and sentiments! I, too, hope -- one day -- to meet Miss Susan Boyle in person and to hear her sing in a live performance! If it is meant to be; it will happen! Until and if then, I'm so happy for EVERYONE who was able to meet, greet and hear Miss Boyle sing in person on Saturday! Thank you, most of all, dear Susa-Friends, for generously sharing your excitment, recollections and photos with ALL of us!
:Ilovesusan::susanrocks:
:love: to ALL!
Patty
Oh, don't I wish we had heard her sing in person! It was recordings they played for us, and they weren't the finished product. Still, Susan's voice . . . ! :cloud: Well, actually, we did hear her in person for one split second. As she was about to leave, we sang the first lines of "Perfect Day," and she chimed in on just a couple of words/notes. But it went by too fast!
08-21-2011, 09:13 AM
UKSusanfanAnn
Just finished reading the whole thread, wow, and just wanted to say thankyou to Grits, sunandroses, and AmberDuke, great reports and now over to the other thread, :)
08-21-2011, 09:13 AM
bgad
:Its All Good::thankyou: for all the good reporting from the Dream Meet. To one and all: :Peace: and :love2:
08-21-2011, 09:23 AM
Jenny Wren
Quote:
Originally Posted by Maya
I'm thrilled that Susan undoubtedly had a great time. I doubt she met anyone she hadn't met before. I'm glad it went well and I congratulate everyone who put this together for what seems like a successful event.
Are you saying that PT and Grits T are lying and that Susan has met all these fans before? If so that is a very serious allegation, and you need to be very sure of your facts and to have evidence to back it up!
Quote:
Originally Posted by pardonmeboy
Just a little hard to do when we have been treated like children.
If the cap fits as the saying goes!
I left this site a year a ago as the behavior of many fans was just dreadful. I came back and thought it had improved. I see now that I was wrong. The same few people remain self indulgent and think it is all about them. I showed this thread to my children and asked them what they thought. My ten year old said that she did not want to be a grown up if grown ups behaved like this, and both my teenagers said that they could not believe that grown women were being so selfish. They both go to pop concerts and would be ecstatic if their friends got to meet their favourite star. Their would be none of this its not fair, I wanna go, let's throw a hissy fit and spit the dummy out of the pram mentality. As one said, "they behave like little kids who want an ice cream and can't have one and are throwing a tantrum in the supermarket". You should all be ashamed. I feel so bad for the fans who went and for the majority who I have seen watching who are desperate for more news from other fans and whose hopes could be dashed because some people behave like spoiled kids.
08-21-2011, 09:32 AM
Kalua
Seeing the way this thread is going and as I gave my word of honor that some of the elements of the M&G would remain confidential I'm closing this thread.
Please move to the reports threads so we all can enjoy what was said and done in New York.
